Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 23
  1. #1
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    128
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0

    Had Fumie won bronze and gold in 2006, would they be tainted by Kwan's absence

    As everyone knows Kwan was missing from the 2006 Olympics and 2006 Worlds. However for most skaters this left no asterik on their achievements as Kwan was no longer the one to beat, and Cohen, Slutskaya, Arakawa, were all likely to beat her anyway. Even for Meissner, the absence of Asada and Kim tainted her achievement more than Kwan not being there. However Fumie is the exception of the top skaters.

    Had she won bronze over Slutskaya at the 2006 Olympics, and gold over Meissner at the 2006 Worlds, as many felt she deserved, her marks probably would have been tainted by Kwan not being there. In fact in her case more than Asada not being there, as she had beaten Asada at Japanese Nationals but never beaten Kwan. This is the reverse of the others whose achievements were not tainted in anyway by Kwan's absence as they all probably would have beaten her anyway, but are tainted by Mao not being there. In Fumie's case she has never beaten Kwan in any competition though, not even in a COP meeting, so anything great she would have achieved would have been tainted by Kwan not being there.

  2. #2
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    1,824
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by chanunderrated View Post
    As everyone knows Kwan was missing from the 2006 Olympics and 2006 Worlds. However for most skaters this left no asterik on their achievements as Kwan was no longer the one to beat, and Cohen, Slutskaya, Arakawa, were all likely to beat her anyway. Even for Meissner, the absence of Asada and Kim tainted her achievement more than Kwan not being there. However Fumie is the exception of the top skaters.

    Had she won bronze over Slutskaya at the 2006 Olympics, and gold over Meissner at the 2006 Worlds, as many felt she deserved, her marks probably would have been tainted by Kwan not being there. In fact in her case more than Asada not being there, as she had beaten Asada at Japanese Nationals but never beaten Kwan. This is the reverse of the others whose achievements were not tainted in anyway by Kwan's absence as they all probably would have beaten her anyway, but are tainted by Mao not being there. In Fumie's case she has never beaten Kwan in any competition though, not even in a COP meeting, so anything great she would have achieved would have been tainted by Kwan not being there.
    I don't think anyone would have though that. Perhaps if Fumie won bronze, there may have been talk that Michelle could have possibly won bronze but I don't think her results woud be "tainted". She would have also beaten Irina, who was the heavt favorite of the whole competition.

    I also don't think Kimmie's WC was tainted in any way either. She was at her first worlds and she beat the reigning world and Olympic silver medalist who basically just had to show up to win, along with a few other world medalists. Asada and Kim were ineligable to compete at that Championship so I don't see what you mean.

  3. #3

    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    7,390
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    4361
    I also don't understand what you mean. Why would an Oly and/or World medal won by Fumie be any more (or any less) "tainted" by Kwan's absence than the same medals won by others?

  4. #4

    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    En el trabajo en mi obra maestra, "Bodegón de rosas, las toronjas y el Planetario", que se llevará algún tiempo.
    Age
    33
    Posts
    23,078
    vCash
    80943
    Rep Power
    90938
    Quote Originally Posted by attyfan View Post
    I also don't understand what you mean. Why would an Oly and/or World medal won by Fumie be any more (or any less) "tainted" by Kwan's absence than the same medals won by others?
    What chanunderrated is stressing is that Arakawa, Cohen, and Slutskaya had already beaten Kwan at Worlds (twice in the case of the latter two, and in a phase of Olympic competition in the last case), whereas Suguri never had. On the other hand, Kwan had been skating "half-seasons" for the past two years and, in the free skate at 2005 Worlds, Kwan's lead over Suguri was a mere 1.44. ETA: Now that I think of it, Suguri did beat Kwan in the qualifying round in Moscow by some way.

    Of course, every competition is different and the 2006 Olympics took place eleven months after the last time all of those skaters had competed at the same event, so I wouldn't think of any of the medals won in the absence of a top skater as being tarnished in any case.
    Last edited by falling_dance; 07-11-2013 at 09:09 PM.
    I can call the moon a pear, but it doesn't make it so. -- kwanfan1818

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Some place competitive and athletic, but ultimately more like an audition than anything else.
    Posts
    7,785
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    19086
    No more than Paul Wylie winning the Silver or Sarah Hughes winning the Gold, if at all. At least at her best (2001-03ish) Fumie was a World Silver-Bronzish skater if she skated her best, unlike Wylie and Hughes. Quite frankly, had Fumie been placed properly in the SP at SLC, Hughes would not have won and Michelle and Irina would have been properly placed and Fumie could have won the Bronze.
    Last edited by bardtoob; 07-11-2013 at 09:08 PM.

  6. #6
    Registered User
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Somewhere, beyond the sea...
    Posts
    1,863
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by chanunderrated View Post
    As everyone knows Kwan was missing from the 2006 Olympics and 2006 Worlds. However for most skaters this left no asterik on their achievements as Kwan was no longer the one to beat, and Cohen, Slutskaya, Arakawa, were all likely to beat her anyway. Even for Meissner, the absence of Asada and Kim tainted her achievement more than Kwan not being there. However Fumie is the exception of the top skaters.

    Had she won bronze over Slutskaya at the 2006 Olympics, and gold over Meissner at the 2006 Worlds, as many felt she deserved, her marks probably would have been tainted by Kwan not being there. In fact in her case more than Asada not being there, as she had beaten Asada at Japanese Nationals but never beaten Kwan. This is the reverse of the others whose achievements were not tainted in anyway by Kwan's absence as they all probably would have beaten her anyway, but are tainted by Mao not being there. In Fumie's case she has never beaten Kwan in any competition though, not even in a COP meeting, so anything great she would have achieved would have been tainted by Kwan not being there.

    Michelle had not competed all season long and was injured. No one knows what kind of shape she would have been in but that's neither here nor there. Michelle had been out of the picture for a year and the fact that she never returned to competition only emphasizes the point. And Mao and Yu-Na were not even eligible to be at worlds that year so there's no point to throw their names in either. Had Michelle competed and Fumie beat her then good for Fumie; she'd have beat her fair and square...but the reality of the matter is Fumie couldn't beat a healthy a Michelle.

  7. #7
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    128
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Hmm surprising to hear some dimiss Kimmie winning Worlds with Mao and Yu Na not there atleast. Mao and Yu Na were only months younger than Meissner and had competed vs her and dominated her in juniors. They should not have been ineligible for Worlds (or Olympics) in the first place. It seems some of you remember around that time 7 years ago as that is what many said right about Meissner's World win, with a few Meissner fans valiantly trying to defend the result to the masses of critics Even Shizuka's Olympic win was marred by some since Asada who had beaten her 3 times that season wasnt there.

    Now Michelle was past her prime and no longer the dominant skater even healthy, so the only one tainted by her absence was Fumie had she achieved something more, only since she never beat Kwan and even lost all their COP meetings where Kwan is supposably weaker. Fumie would have beaten Michelle and Kostner for the bronze at the 2005 Worlds had she either not fallen in the short or not doubled her 2nd triple lutz in the long though.

  8. #8
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Posts
    128
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by bardtoob View Post
    No more than Paul Wylie winning the Silver or Sarah Hughes winning the Gold, if at all. At least at her best (2001-03ish) Fumie was a World Silver-Bronzish skater if she skated her best, unlike Wylie and Hughes. Quite frankly, had Fumie been placed properly in the SP at SLC, Hughes would not have won and Michelle and Irina would have been properly placed and Fumie could have won the Bronze.
    Hughes won bronze at the 2001 Worlds, bronze at the 2001 and 2002 GPF, and the gold at the 2002 Olympics. She was a much more regular podium finisher in that 2 season stretch than Fumie ever was in her life.

    Who would Fumie have beaten for bronze at the 2002 Olympics even with a better result in the short. Fumie was a relative nobody back then, an only 5 triple program for her wouldnt have beaten a 6 triple Slutskaya (even lackluster) or 6 triple Kwan (even with a fall on a 7th triple attempt).

  9. #9

    Join Date
    Mar 2003
    Posts
    7,390
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    4361
    Quote Originally Posted by falling_dance View Post
    What chanunderrated is stressing is that Arakawa, Cohen, and Slutskaya had already beaten Kwan at Worlds (twice in the case of the latter two, and in a phase of Olympic competition in the last case), whereas Suguri never had. On the other hand, Kwan had been skating "half-seasons" for the past two years and, in the free skate at 2005 Worlds, Kwan's lead over Suguri was a mere 1.44. ETA: Now that I think of it, Suguri did beat Kwan in the qualifying round in Moscow by some way.

    Of course, every competition is different and the 2006 Olympics took place eleven months after the last time all of those skaters had competed at the same event, so I wouldn't think of any of the medals won in the absence of a top skater as being tarnished in any case.
    I agree that the absence of Kwan doesn't "taint" anything, but I doubt that the fact that Fumie had never beaten Kwan before would have made much of a difference. Kwan had long lost the "aura of invincibility" and her medaling was no longer regarded as a "sure thing".

  10. #10

    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Quadland
    Posts
    6,284
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    3052
    Quote Originally Posted by chanunderrated View Post
    Hmm surprising to hear some dimiss Kimmie winning Worlds with Mao and Yu Na not there atleast. Mao and Yu Na were only months younger than Meissner and had competed vs her and dominated her in juniors. They should not have been ineligible for Worlds (or Olympics) in the first place. It seems some of you remember around that time 7 years ago as that is what many said right about Meissner's World win, with a few Meissner fans valiantly trying to defend the result to the masses of critics Even Shizuka's Olympic win was marred by some since Asada who had beaten her 3 times that season wasnt there.

    Now Michelle was past her prime and no longer the dominant skater even healthy, so the only one tainted by her absence was Fumie had she achieved something more, only since she never beat Kwan and even lost all their COP meetings where Kwan is supposably weaker. Fumie would have beaten Michelle and Kostner for the bronze at the 2005 Worlds had she either not fallen in the short or not doubled her 2nd triple lutz in the long though.
    This whole thing is totally ridiculous!! Not just to Meissner but Cohen Arakawa and Slutskaya! Everyone! Mao beat everyone in run up to Turin! Everyone! So every achievement could be seen as dismissable. But the rules are the rules. Mao was ineligible for what would might have been a guaranteed Gold in Turin! Yes Mao could not win Gold in Turin or Gold in Calgary Worlds but not one medal or win is tarnished by Mao not being eligible. She wasn't eligible! Of the eligible people and those who competed it is what it is! Kwan not skating doesn't tarnish anyone because at like no point in the whole 2005-2006 did she skate anywhere of a major official status! Kwan absence doesn't tarnish, mao absence doesn't tarnish! This is just not anything at all in any way!

  11. #11
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Phoenix, AZ
    Age
    25
    Posts
    9,105
    vCash
    1529
    Rep Power
    0
    This is a super weird question.

  12. #12

    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Age
    48
    Posts
    17,933
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    33055
    Quote Originally Posted by michiruwater View Post
    This is a super weird question.
    This isn't the only one of late. Off season and people are pulling things out of their butt to generate content for this forum.
    When you are up to your arse in alligators it is difficult to remember you were only meant to be draining the swamp.

  13. #13
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Posts
    452
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Someone's absence doesn't taint the medals of those present. And that's true of everyone in every sport.

    So that's that answer, next thread please?

    Quote Originally Posted by Aussie Willy View Post
    This isn't the only one of late. Off season and people are pulling things out of their butt to generate content for this forum.
    I know right? By the way I am still waiting for that best hair poll - I mean, we need to get that one out of the way before we move on to that very important question near the end of July: Gracie Gold's cupcakes or Sasha Cohen's cookies? Much more interesting and fascinating debate than the one in the OP here to be honest

  14. #14

    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Age
    48
    Posts
    17,933
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    33055
    Quote Originally Posted by rayhaneh View Post
    I know right? By the way I am still waiting for that best hair poll - I mean, we need to get that one out of the way before we move on to that very important question near the end of July: Gracie Gold's cupcakes or Sasha Cohen's cookies? Much more interesting and fascinating debate than the one in the OP here to be honest
    I think Sokolova would have something to say about Gracie Gold's cupcakes.
    When you are up to your arse in alligators it is difficult to remember you were only meant to be draining the swamp.

  15. #15
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Posts
    1,592
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    No.

  16. #16
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    1,824
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by chanunderrated View Post
    Hmm surprising to hear some dimiss Kimmie winning Worlds with Mao and Yu Na not there atleast. Mao and Yu Na were only months younger than Meissner and had competed vs her and dominated her in juniors. They should not have been ineligible for Worlds (or Olympics) in the first place. It seems some of you remember around that time 7 years ago as that is what many said right about Meissner's World win, with a few Meissner fans valiantly trying to defend the result to the masses of critics Even Shizuka's Olympic win was marred by some since Asada who had beaten her 3 times that season wasnt there.

    Now Michelle was past her prime and no longer the dominant skater even healthy, so the only one tainted by her absence was Fumie had she achieved something more, only since she never beat Kwan and even lost all their COP meetings where Kwan is supposably weaker. Fumie would have beaten Michelle and Kostner for the bronze at the 2005 Worlds had she either not fallen in the short or not doubled her 2nd triple lutz in the long though.
    Hu??? Mao and Yuna were too young to compete at the Olympics and worlds in 2006. It was/is a rule. There is nothing to defend about Kimmie's world title or Shizuka's Olympic title.

    Kimmie beat Yu Na in the LP in 2007 just as an FYI. And Mao didn't even win that world championship.

  17. #17
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    207
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by rayhaneh View Post
    Someone's absence doesn't taint the medals of those present. And that's true of everyone in every sport.
    ITA. What would have been the case if something had been different than it was is musing aobut something not worth discussing, IMO. What may taint someone's medal (or achievement) are utterances like these. "You wouldn't have won if soandso had been there...!" - "Maybe. But soandso wasn't there."

  18. #18
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    Secret Garden
    Posts
    57
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    All golds won by female medallists after 2006 were tainted.

  19. #19

    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    2,032
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by UGG View Post
    Hu??? Mao and Yuna were too young to compete at the Olympics and worlds in 2006. It was/is a rule. There is nothing to defend about Kimmie's world title or Shizuka's Olympic title.
    Basically I agree with you, but first of all Korea did not have any spot to send their skater to Olympics in 2006.

  20. #20
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Posts
    163
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by chanunderrated View Post
    Hughes won bronze at the 2001 Worlds, bronze at the 2001 and 2002 GPF, and the gold at the 2002 Olympics. She was a much more regular podium finisher in that 2 season stretch than Fumie ever was in her life.

    Who would Fumie have beaten for bronze at the 2002 Olympics even with a better result in the short. Fumie was a relative nobody back then, an only 5 triple program for her wouldnt have beaten a 6 triple Slutskaya (even lackluster) or 6 triple Kwan (even with a fall on a 7th triple attempt).
    How many inaccuracies can be stuffed into two paragraphs to support an illogical poll and conclusion?

    Fumie won bronze at the 2002 and 2003 Worlds, silver at 2006 Worlds, gold at the 2003-2004 GPF, as well as both the 2003 and 2005 4CC. In that same time period (02-06), she was also top 5 at every World and Olympic event she competed in aside from 04 Worlds. How in the world is that record not comparable to Hughes' from 00-02?

    Lastly, Kwan landed 5 triples in SLC (she two-footed the 3T), not 6, and there's certainly a case for Suguri being as high as 3rd in each program.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •