Stephane Lambiel (2006)
Paul Wylie (1992)
Elizabeth Manley (1988)
Kitty & Peter Carruthers (1984)
Dan Zhang & Hao Zhang (2006)
Qing Pang & Jian Tong (2010)
Isabelle & Paul Duschenay (1992)
Tanith Belbin & Benjamin Agosto (2006)
In the SP, he did a double axel and didn't do his 4/3 combo as cleanly as he could have. Hence his third place finish there (but with the third highest PCS in that portion). In the LP, he made three major mistakes but scored nearly two points higher than Lysaceck in PCS. Lysaceck may have beaten Lambiel in the LP, but Lysaceck had a much cleaner performance and had a nearly two-point TES advantage, and still only beat Lambiel by 0.41 points. Buttle may have possibly beaten him, but even in his "mistake-riddled" LP, he made less mistakes than Lambiel in the LP.
You're saying that Lambiel got lucky the other guys didn't perform better, but why not give the same consideration to Lambiel who didn't perform up to his best either? It's not as if the judges didn't like him as he did come in as the World Champion. I just find it odd to say that the other men were more favored to win a medal over Lambiel (or that nobody thought he could have won a medal) when Lambiel was pretty well-liked at the time and it's not as if the other men (outside Plushenko) were known for their consistency.
I love Weir, but you know it was a messy competition when he places second behind Plushenko in the SP.
Last edited by VIETgrlTerifa; 07-07-2013 at 03:50 AM.
You really think Buttle or especialy Lysacek wouldnt have been alot more lucky if they won silver. Lambiel was actually the one who made more mistakes than he usually does, despite that he isnt super consistent and rarely skates clean either; while Jeff made about the same as usual, and Evan about the same as usual too. Evan had rep since he has a mere World bronze but Stephane with a World gold didnt, LOL! Stephane was lucky to beat two guys he had beaten consistently for 2 years at that point, and who he would have had to make alot of mistakes and them make much fewer (Buttle) or none at all (Lysacek) in order to lose to?
Yep pretty stupid. Now back under your bridge.
PS- lucky is Lysacek in Vancouver. Lucky that Lambiel and Takahashi were coming off injury/temporary retirement layoffs and that Lambiel bombed the Olympics, while Takahashi was screwed in the SP then screwed himself in the LP; lucky that Buttle retired rather than stay in for Vancouver not forseeing even a mediocre non quadster like Evan could win, lucky that Plushenko gave away the gold with overconfidence, lucky that Abbott didnt skate like Nationals, lucky that....well you get the picture.
Last edited by judgejudy27; 07-07-2013 at 04:13 AM.
What I'm saying is that an imperfect Lambiel needed Jeff to be imperfect, and he was lucky that that's what happened.
I'm going back under my bridge now.
LOL Lambiel over the two programs had 2 falls, doubled 2 planned triple axels (and yes at that point he usually attempted them and sometimes landed them like Worlds), and had two very shaky landings. Jeff had 2 falls (one on a quad attempt he had no hope of landing) and had two small hand downs. Lambiel had atleast 8 points more worth of mistakes over the two programs. How on earth would Jeff and Stephane be about the same if both skated cleanly with Jeff having no quad. Their PCS was always about the same, and Jeff has a base value about 10 points lower over the two programs without a quad. OK he tried the quad in the long here so I think it was more like 6 points apart in base value over the two programs but still behind. At the Grand Prix final both made similar errors and Jeff lost by about 12 points, and at Worlds both had a clean short and major mistakes in the long (Stephane popped 3 jumps, 2 of them to singles, and Jeff had 2 falls) and the gap was huge. Maybe if both skated cleanly with quads and triple axels they would come almost tied, but as all know Jeff's quad did not exist. For the record I do love Jeff's skating and wish he had stuck around after his World win to prevent Evan Lysacek, the most mediocre Olympic Champion in history, from vulturing the Vancouver gold that he could have won.
BTW regarding Evan again it is quite possible he would not have medalled in Turin even with a clean short, even with the huge disaesters of many other skaters, especialy Lambiel. At that point in time the best a clean short from him was capable of was something 75-77. Actually his PB in the best in the short at the time was in the low 70s, but based on his score for 2 major mistakes I will be kind and say 75-77. That with his LP score, although his LP score might have been higher in the final flight, still wouldnt have beaten Lambiel, and might not have medalled. If he did it would have meant nipping Buttle for the bronze though, so I guess if anyone was lucky if you want to look at it that way....
Last edited by judgejudy27; 07-07-2013 at 04:54 PM.
FP - Happiness
I can't find the behind the scenes shots when he found out he won the silver. That was a nice moment too.
Some others -
Last edited by A.H.Black; 07-09-2013 at 05:01 PM.
Liz Manley and Paul were so happy and to them the silver was Gold. I loved to revisit the genuine joy on their faces on the podium. That is winning
I think Pang/Tong were delighted with their silver in Vancouver, mainly because I don't think they expected to beat both S/S and K/S; it was made all the sweeter after missing out in Torino IMO.
“Freedom is the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.” George Orwell
Last edited by torren; 07-10-2013 at 04:25 AM.
Michelle Kwan cried about her silver because she was sad she lost. All of the women silver medalists do. This leads to the question, are women skaters more emotional and bitter about losing than men?
Of course we have to exclude Oda from our sample as an extreme outlier.
I don't think so. Maybe men are better at hiding their emotions due to societal expectations, but you can't really say that Orser, Stojko (1994), Plushenko (2002 and 2010) among others were non-emotional about their silver medals.
Whereas, Midori Ito, Elizabeth Manley (at the time), and Sasha Cohen weren't exactly crying on the podium either.
I agree with you. The women get more media attention, so their post-Olympic years of coming to terms with loss-- e.g. Janet Lynn, Fratianne, Sumners, Manley, Thomas, Trenary, Ito, Kerrigan, Kwan, Slutskaya, and Cohen--are more exposed. The men get to have the same "issues" without the public seeing it as much. Some skaters-- and this is true of men as often as women--are prone to melancholy. Dorothy Hamill said she was a tiny bit sad at the time she won, because she knew her dream was coming to end. This was just her temperament. She could be tough, but she had a predisposition to getting depressed--even in happy times.
Last edited by TheIronLady; 07-10-2013 at 07:46 AM.
"I hit him with my shoes... if he had given me the medal like I told him to, I wouldn't have had to hit him!" -- 8-year-old Rhoda Penmark in "The Bad Seed"
Surya Bonaly was very disrespectful, but we forgive her because she came from an insane family.
Last edited by TheIronLady; 07-10-2013 at 07:48 AM.
Sasha Cohen looked disappointed in every event she skated in, but I think she was still a graceful non winner. I still remember the interview at 2003 nationals where she was staring at her water bottle the whole interview. Girl was upset at how she skated. I see no fault in that!
The US gymnastics ladies were clearly upset with their silver medals in 2004 and 2008. Does that make them selfish?
The gold medalists are probably not even thinking of the silver medalists. Do you really think Sarah felt her moment in 2002 was ruined by Michelle and Irina being upset at how they skated? Michelle was visibly upset in 1998 and I am 100% sure that did not ruin Tara's moment.
The only competition that I can think of where the silver medalist might have been on the gold medalists mind is the women's vault competition at the
2012 Olympics when Mckayla Marony was like the clear favorite, ended up with silver, and was doing the whole "not impressed" face. LOL.
Many of these athletes are children.
Last edited by UGG; 07-10-2013 at 08:05 AM.
As for being disrespectful: sobbing on the podium from disappointment is understandable (as it is behind the scenes and everywhere else) and I wouldn't say it's disrspectful. Emotions can't be helped most times, and with the pressure decreasing, tears just run. It may appear thoughtless crying because of a silver or bronze, but it's not tactless against those who won, but rather tactless against those who haven't even made the podium - although have dreamt to make it just as much.