Page 19 of 52 FirstFirst ... 9171819202129 ... LastLast
Results 361 to 380 of 1022
  1. #361
    Registered User
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Somewhere, beyond the sea...
    Posts
    1,884
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by judgejudy27 View Post
    1. Miki "overrated" Ando is one of the most overmarked skaters of all time and a huge judges pet and has gotten many scores, medals, and titles she did not deserve, and I would include the 2011 Worlds in that IMHO considering she and Kim had almost comparable mistakes and Kim is twice the skater Ando is, even her jumps are better quality which is Ando's only asset really. Wagner is not the judges pet Ando was, and probably never will be. The judges like and respect her now unlike before, but unlike judges pets such as Ando, Chan, and others she has to earn every mark she gets still, especialy at the World level.

    2. The biggest difference of all, Miki had only one person she needed to falter to win the 2011 Worlds, Kim, she was clearly above everyone else. Needing 1 person to falter to win is drastically different to needing 3. Even a clean Suzuki might be a threat to Wagner as well. I see the odds of none of those 3 skating very well close to nil, which is why I am hard pressed to see her winning this year, although not totally impossible, but I agree with you that a medal is quite a strong possability as it is unlikely all 3 of those would skate well.

    Lol! Say what you will about Miki but she was able to capitalize on other skaters' mistakes which is what you have to do to beat someone who is more talented than you are...just so happens she's done that more than anyone else in recent memory.

    I agree with point #2. After the SP, it was down to Miki and Yu-Na and the luck went in Miki's favor b/c of Yu-Na's mistakes...still that less than two point difference shows that had Yu-Na managed to complete that damn 2T on the end of her 3S, she'd have won.

    It's a lot less likely that the top 4 contenders will make mistakes this year (Mao, Carolina, Yu-Na and Akiko) but I think it's likely at least two of them will. To be honest, I think the judges might favor Ashley over Akiko. I don't know how I'd feel about that b/c I adore Akiko and I adore Ashley, but Akiko so often gets the short end of the stick. You'd have to start breaking the score down bit by bit to determine who would deserve the upper hand. Both have strong LPs and decent SPs but if Ashley can add that 3-3 to her FS (likely a 3F-3T), I think that would give her the upper hand...aslo Ashley's spins are better than Akiko's...but while I love Ashley's SP, I think I like Akiko's SP more. *sigh*

    It's going to be a tough call. IDK what's going to happen but this is shaping up to be a much better worlds than last year, that's for sure...

  2. #362
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    3,922
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by judgejudy27 View Post
    Honestly I still see Wagner a bit below Asada, Kostner, and quite a bit below Kim. I do think there is a good chance she will sneak in for a medal at Worlds (unless somehow she loses Nationals, in which case it is game over as far as a World medal this year for any U.S lady),
    No, I would not say that...as long as she is on the world team, she has a chance.

    That chance is probably not very high, but it is there.

  3. #363
    Registered User
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Somewhere, beyond the sea...
    Posts
    1,884
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by RD View Post
    No, I would not say that...as long as she is on the world team, she has a chance.

    That chance is probably not very high, but it is there.

    Agreed. To be honest, I can't see Ashley not making the team this year. I just think back to last year and how the scores were finagled in both the SP and LP to get Alissa into that 2nd spot despite the mistakes she made in both programs. Alissa should have been 3rd or possibly even 4th BUT b/c she was the top US lady from the previous year and GP series, she got that ticket. Given Alissa's performances last year, Ashley would have to go into full zamboni-mode not to make it this year.

    I'm not trying to tempt TPTB or the skate gods, but I honestly can't see her not making the team...

  4. #364
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Age
    23
    Posts
    13,271
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Actually after coming 4th at Nationals the Japense federation are probably going to give Suzuki even less support now, so come to think of it even a clean Suzuki probably wont beat a pretty good Ashley. Losing Nationals past was not a big deal for a U.S lady since they had many that were considered amongst the best. However for Wagner to lose Nationals somehow and go to the Worlds as the #2 American would be a death knall for her, for this year anyway IMO, as none of the other U.S ladies is remotedly considered a contender at the World level right now besides her. She absolutely has to win Nationals to be taken seriously come Worlds.

  5. #365
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    3,922
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    To clarify, I meant that it really doesn't (shouldn't) make a difference whether Wagner gets on the team in 1st or 2nd, as long as she is on the team. Wagner already made her statement to be taken seriously last year at 4CCs and worlds, and this season on the GP.

    And yes, assuming Wagner's good health, it is difficult to envision a scenario where she misses out on worlds. But- remember, it's not impossible.

    Actually I think Czisny's score was ok last year. Not like Zawadzki lit things up in her FS...and Zhang, even in her improved state, was not on Czisny's level. The real issue I had was what happened afterwards, but no need to beat that dead horse again.

  6. #366
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Helping Mirai choose between Italian dressing and vinaigrette.
    Age
    30
    Posts
    1,652
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by judgejudy27 View Post
    Actually after coming 4th at Nationals the Japense federation are probably going to give Suzuki even less support now, so come to think of it even a clean Suzuki probably wont beat a pretty good Ashley. Losing Nationals past was not a big deal for a U.S lady since they had many that were considered amongst the best. However for Wagner to lose Nationals somehow and go to the Worlds as the #2 American would be a death knall for her, for this year anyway IMO, as none of the other U.S ladies is remotedly considered a contender at the World level right now besides her. She absolutely has to win Nationals to be taken seriously come Worlds.
    I don't think it would be that bad for Ashley if Mirai and/or Gracie beat her. Mirai is #8 and Gracie #10 on the best overall scores this season and each of those scores they both have several mistakes. Christina would be a shock of course just because she was pretty much perfect and only #11. If Gracie and Mirai were clean I don't see why they wouldn't both have been around 180-185 and that is not far off Ashley and the top three scores this season. Yes Ashley is in top shape right now and has skated well this season but it has been very within her comfort zone. We will see what happens when the pressure comes and has to go for more if others are clean.

  7. #367
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    10,234
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by judgejudy27 View Post
    1. Miki "overrated" Ando is one of the most overmarked skaters of all time and a huge judges pet and has gotten many scores, medals, and titles she did not deserve, and I would include the 2011 Worlds in that IMHO considering she and Kim had almost comparable mistakes and Kim is twice the skater Ando is, even her jumps are better quality which is Ando's only asset really. Wagner is not the judges pet Ando was, and probably never will be. The judges like and respect her now unlike before, but unlike judges pets such as Ando, Chan, and others she has to earn every mark she gets still, especialy at the World level.

    2. The biggest difference of all, Miki had only one person she needed to falter to win the 2011 Worlds, Kim, she was clearly above everyone else. Needing 1 person to falter to win is drastically different to needing 3. Even a clean Suzuki might be a threat to Wagner as well. I see the odds of none of those 3 skating very well close to nil, which is why I am hard pressed to see her winning this year, although not totally impossible, but I agree with you that a medal is quite a strong possability as it is unlikely all 3 of those would skate well.
    I think that's being a bit harsh on Miki. She is a very strong jumper who knew how to work CoP, which, combined with her consistency under pressure, allowed her to win all those medals. Sure, she didn't have the most interesting programs or the best spins in the world, but she had good basics, her jumps were big and clean with nice technique, and her spins were certainly adequate. I don't think most people give her the credit she deserves for the transformation she underwent between the 2006 Olympics and 2007 Worlds. She worked her butt off and earned that World title. So what if she watered down her content afterwards because she didn't need it to win? She was just being strategic, why risk injuring herself, making mistakes, or getting downgrades and/or negative GOEs trying high risk elements if they weren't necessary to win?

    Miki was a consistent jumper, her jumps racked up good GOE, and she backloaded her programs to give her BV a boost - she and Morozov knew that she could hit the triples and hit them well even putting them so late in the program, and based on that, she could get away without trying a 3-3, or even sometimes without the 2a-3t, and still win/medal at most events due to the strength and consistency of her other jumps and high component scores. Everyone knows reputation plays a role in determining PCS, and Miki to her credit did have a World title, another world medal, a GPF silver, a few trips to the GPF, and several GP medals to her name when she won Worlds in 2011, and out of fairness to her, she did really deserve that title because no one else skated better.

    Ashley is pretty much doing what Miki did from 2007-2011 and her results are similarly skyrocketing. I find Ashley a more interesting and dynamic skater, sure, but in terms of basics she's about the same and the content she's trying is similar to Miki's "watered down" content, it's more the consistency that is making the difference. It's nice to see ladies going for hard 3-3s and 7 triple FS programs, sure, but if they don't execute the jumps cleanly or are prone to making several errors like Liza, Gracie, etc. have been doing, then a clean but conservative performance from a more polished and mature skater like Ashley or Miki that includes 5 or 6 well-executed triple jumps should deserve to come out on top IMO.

    Another thing is Miki seems to get crap for watering down her content but at least when she won stuff it was with 5 or so triples and no visible errors...the likes of Korpi and Lepisto, even Kostner, have won many a medal with about 3 triples in the FS, meaning 2 or 3 of the jumping passes were clearly aborted into doubles, which was never really the case with Miki, who would sometimes downgrade a 2a-3t to a 2a-2t, which isn't even an obvious or disruptive error. And she at least could be counted on to hit 3 3lutzes between her two programs without fail, which can't be said for the Euro ladies...
    Last edited by pinky166; 01-02-2013 at 11:13 PM.

  8. #368
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Age
    23
    Posts
    13,271
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Miki won Worlds with basically the same content as Kostner last year so if people are going to give Kostner, a way higher quality skater in between the jumps than Miki ever could be, so much flak for winning with watered down content, then Miki certainly deserves the same. As for 2011 Worlds like I said the way I see it is Kim and Ando had similar mistakes and content in the LP, and Kim is a better skater than Ando in everyway, even her jumps which are Miki's main asset generally get bested in GOEs by Kim, so how on earth Ando came out ahead I have no idea. We all know an on fire Kim with 7 triples would crush an on fire Ando with 7 triples by atleast 20 points, so why would an average Ando ever come out ahead of an average Kim.

    I do agree on her improvement from 2006 to 2007, and while she needed Asada and Kim to make major errors I was impressed with her win in 2007, she did 2 very difficult programs with a triple lutz-triple loop in both, and landed 10 total triples, while showing much improved presentation. Her win in 2011 is probably the most bleh World win since Trenary at the 1990 Worlds however, and 2 World titles is too much for someone of Miki's level. She is definitely the weakest 2 time (note I said 2 time, so dont start comparing her to some of the weaker 1 time only winners) World Champion in the history of the sport by far.

    I agree Wagner is basically doing what Ando was doing in 2010/2011 now, just with lower quality jumps and IMO much better presentation basically. However Wagner has to do 6 or 7 triples just to win a grand prix event, she would never be awarded a World gold even in a lackluster event with only 5 triples and making a major mistake as Ando was, so that isnt really a fair comparision, and was my point basically, Wagner will definitely not be given a World title for doing as little as Ando did.

    Anyway no more comments about Miki Ando as this is off topic to the thread.

  9. #369
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    3,922
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by Jarrett View Post
    I don't think it would be that bad for Ashley if Mirai and/or Gracie beat her.
    Mirai OR Gracie perhaps...but if they BOTH beat her?

    I dunno. I don't see Wagner in 3rd getting preferential treatment and being chosen over Nagasu or Gold for the world team. It didn't happen in 2010. If anything, though, the judges will probably do what they can (short of a scandal) to keep Wagner in the 2nd spot. I don't think that sort of activity is fair and it compromises the integrity of the event, but hey, that's what happens when you make Nationals the one-all competition.
    Last edited by RD; 01-03-2013 at 01:00 AM.

  10. #370
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Age
    23
    Posts
    13,271
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    I agree the judges would not override National results and place someone on the team who didnt make it. If you arent in the shape due to injury or time off from injury to skate at the level to be safe to make the team, but are someone who is fairly safe to get a bye, you are best to just not show up at Nationals, like Kwan in 2006. Bobek assumed the same in 1996 when she withdrew before the long program, but overrated the USFSA's faith in her after a poor season. Now if Wagner pulled out with injury (which seems unlikely) she would be given a bye IMO, but not if she shows up and is beaten into 3rd or worse.

  11. #371
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    619
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    If Wagner places 3rd I would bet $20 that she's on the world team. At very least they would send her to 4CC and make a decision after that. USFSA knows Ashley is a medal threat on an average day for her (keeping in mind that Ashley's average is very stellar), the same can't be said about the other American ladies. IMO Ashley could scoop up a world Bronze with an "average" long program, any other American lady would have to go lights out skate-of-the-year to grab that Bronze. The odds are in her favour.

    Pointless to discuss this anyways, Ashley is a cut above, she'll do just fine at Nationals.

  12. #372
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Posts
    1,995
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    I think you guys are thinking too much into this. I'm 99% certain that Ashley will defend her title. Her "bombing" still ended up with a 115+ and Gracie/Mirai didn't bomb on the grand prix and still didn't beat that. I think though that Ashley is possibly beatable in the SP by any of the top U.S. ladies (if she decideds to play it safe in the SP and doesn't include a triple-triple), but she is pretty much untouchable in the LP considering her consistency (and she should have a major PCS advantage also).

  13. #373
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    3,922
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    It may very well be likely - and I agree that Wagner is the favorite, perhaps even the overwhelming favorite- but if 10 years of following skating has taught me anything, it's that nothing- NOTHING is certain in skating.

    Throw in the fact that Wagner is the defending champ and the pressure on her just got turned up a notch. GPs had little if any pressure. Plus, she showed recent vulnerability at GPF (this happens to every skater, Yuna Kim included)

    I don't think I'm "thinking too much" if I consider the possibility that Wagner may not successfully defend her US title.

  14. #374
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Miami, FL, USA
    Posts
    6,940
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    ^Just my $.02.

    A wild card for Wagner is the 3-3 in the SP. I think if she hits a 3f-3t in the SP and rocks the rest of the elements, she could be 2nd behind a clean Yu Na and ahead of even a clean Kostner and Asada. I also think it's more likely that Wagner has a 3-3 than Asada has a 3x or Kostner a 3z-3t / 3f-3t. (Although I do think Kostner will easily do a 3t-3t). That scenario might give her some point cushion going into the LP and a better chance of a medal. Who knows. But I agree Ashley on a typical day is probably just on the outside looking in on Asada, Kostner and Kim. But, I love that position for her because she's good at attacking from behind.

  15. #375

    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Age
    26
    Posts
    2,028
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by olympic View Post
    But I agree Ashley on a typical day is probably just on the outside looking in on Asada, Kostner and Kim.
    I don't agree, I don't think Asada has anything that really puts her above Wagner, except maybe footwork, and that's only 1 element in each program. She hasn't been completing 3-3s or 3A and she's prone to under-rotations on her jumps.

  16. #376
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    619
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by mgobluegirl View Post
    I don't agree, I don't think Asada has anything that really puts her above Wagner, except maybe footwork, and that's only 1 element in each program. She hasn't been completing 3-3s or 3A and she's prone to under-rotations on her jumps.
    Mao clean has the edge over Ashley clean. Mao is much more fluent and balletic. She would score huge points with a clean program.

    I'd also wager that Mao won't go clean all season, she UR's at least a jump or two in every lp, and she has a pop or two (or like 4 in NHK). Clean Ashley (which is very likely from her) beats a flawed Mao.

    I think the poster who you quoted was assuming Asada, Kostner, and Kim went clean. None of the three have that consistency yet, we'll see by worlds.

  17. #377

    Join Date
    Jun 2004
    Location
    Minnesota
    Age
    26
    Posts
    9,001
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    1017
    Cross-posting this from the Fun with Numbers thread...

    Quote Originally Posted by chipso1 View Post
    Season Average Scores -- Ladies

    *Scores averaged include Regionals, Sectionals, JGP events, Sr. B's, GP events, and the JGP/GP Final.

    Just for fun!

    Average Total Scores:
    1. Ashley WAGNER (186.98)
    2. Mirai NAGASU (167.75)
    3. Agnes ZAWADZKI (166.65)
    4. Gracie GOLD (165.92)
    5. Christina GAO (164.50)
    6. Vanessa LAM (162.23)

    7. Hannah MILLER (160.05)
    8. Angela WANG (158.37)
    9. Samantha CESARIO (156.05)
    10. Yasmin SIRAJ (154.10)
    11. Courtney HICKS (152.29)
    12. Ashley CAIN (151.37)

    13. Becky BERESWILL (147.60)
    14. Haley DUNNE (146.61)
    15. Leah KEISER (144.97)
    16. Kiri BAGA (144.21)
    17. Caroline ZHANG (137.40)
    18. Joelle FORTE (130.48)

    19. Morgan BELL (129.25)
    20. Sophia ADAMS (126.59)
    21. Amanda HOFMANN (117.31)
    22. Alissa CZISNY (0.00)


    Average SP Scores:
    1. Ashley WAGNER (63.38)
    2. Agnes ZAWADZKI (60.15)
    3. Gracie GOLD (57.91)
    4. Mirai NAGASU (57.90)
    5. Hannah MILLER (55.33)
    6. Ashley CAIN (55.15)

    7. Vanessa LAM (54.15)
    8. Haley DUNNE (54.11)
    9. Christina GAO (52.58)
    10. Yasmin SIRAJ (51.94)
    11. Courtney HICKS (51.93)
    12. Samantha CESARIO (51.51)

    13. Angela WANG (51.45)
    14. Leah KEISER (51.02)
    15. Kiri BAGA (50.66)
    16. Morgan BELL (50.36)
    17. Becky BERESWILL (49.88)
    18. Joelle FORTE (48.77)

    19. Caroline ZHANG (48.18)
    20. Amanda HOFMANN (42.94)
    21. Sophia ADAMS (41.81)
    22. Alissa CZISNY (0.00)


    Average FS Scores:
    1. Ashley WAGNER (123.60)
    2. Christina GAO (111.92)
    3. Mirai NAGASU (109.85)
    4. Vanessa LAM (108.08)
    5. Gracie GOLD (108.01)
    6. Angela WANG (106.92)

    7. Agnes ZAWADZKI (106.50)
    8. Hannah MILLER (104.72)
    9. Samantha CESARIO (104.54)
    10. Yasmin SIRAJ (102.16)
    11. Courtney HICKS (100.36)
    12. Becky BERESWILL (97.72)

    13. Ashley CAIN (96.22)
    14. Leah KEISER (93.95)
    15. Kiri BAGA (93.55)
    16. Haley DUNNE (92.50)
    17. Caroline ZHANG (89.22)
    18. Sophia ADAMS (84.78)

    19. Joelle FORTE (81.71)
    20. Morgan BELL (78.89)
    21. Amanda HOFMANN (74.37)
    22. Alissa CZISNY (0.00)

  18. #378
    Registered User
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    11,199
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    At this stage, I think Wagner would have to be pretty awful to lose Nationals, or next to being a human zamboni to come below 2nd and have her world spot in jeopardy. She won the free skate at Japan Open, both of her GPs and got the silver at GPF despite falling twice and be beaten by Asada whom she beat earlier this season at Japan Open and on home soil. Traditionally the lady who placed well enough at Worlds the previous season gets some cushion at the next Nationals (Flatt in 2010, Czisny at 2012 etc).

    While it is entirely possible that one or more of Asada, Kim and Kostner could falter at Worlds, it is also possible that one of the Russian girls or Suzuki or Korpi could pull it all together. Wagner is an unknown at Worlds without a 3/3 in the short and 2/3 in the free. If she skated at Worlds exactly like how she skated at the French GP she could secure a top 5 without question, but I doubt a medal is ensured. Not to mention that she has had spin level issues so far this season.

  19. #379
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Age
    23
    Posts
    13,271
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by mgobluegirl View Post
    I don't agree, I don't think Asada has anything that really puts her above Wagner, except maybe footwork, and that's only 1 element in each program. She hasn't been completing 3-3s or 3A and she's prone to under-rotations on her jumps.
    You may think that but it is clear the judges dont think that. The protocals show even had Wagner gone clean at the GP final she probably would have lost to Asada who wasnt clean, and really had only 3 clean triples. Asada's advantages over Wagner seem to be higher levels in spins and non jump elements (Asada has been doing all level 3s and 4s in her programs, Wagner has not been getting her spins and other elements graded as such), higher PCS, and sometimes higher GOEs. I think Asada has been overmarked all year but that is the reality of things, being Japanese #1 lady is a powerful thing these days.

  20. #380
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Age
    23
    Posts
    13,271
    vCash
    500
    Rep Power
    0
    Quote Originally Posted by cbd1235 View Post
    I think the poster who you quoted was assuming Asada, Kostner, and Kim went clean. None of the three have that consistency yet, we'll see by worlds.
    Well Kim definitely doesnt have to skate cleanly to beat Ashley. She just needs to avoid disaester to be frank. I am not even sure if Kim would need to skate cleanly to beat a clean Asada or Kostner either, I dont think so with their current jump content in fact (nor do I think either Asada or Kostner will skate totally clean anyway). I know it isnt the Kim of Vancouver, and we wont see that until next season (if ever again) but Asada couldnt come close to that Kim even with clean performances with 3/3s and the triple axel, so I think Mao is making a huge mistake in thinking just because Kim is probably weaker now she can suddenly lay way off the jump content as she is doing now, also seemingly now be prone to URs to boot, and beat Kim; or perhaps even Kostner who suddenly isnt really doing much or any less than Mao is attempting now and is beloved by the European judging community and is the reigning World Champion. I am pretty sure Kim and Kostner at their most recent outings would have beaten Mao from the GP final, and both Kim and Kostner have a long way to potentially grow from that, so Mao had best reconsider her current plan if she wants the gold at Worlds.

    How much margin Kostner and Asada have over Wagner, and how they are likely to skate (how close to clean they are likely to skate), is a bigger question when it comes to Wagner and her chance though. Along with if Wagner can regain her early season momentum and consistency, and build on some aspects of her performances, adding a 3/3 or 2/3 in one or both programs, upping her spin and footwork levels, polishing some of the little things of her program which still could be better, etc..
    Last edited by judgejudy27; 01-03-2013 at 04:38 AM.

Page 19 of 52 FirstFirst ... 9171819202129 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •