Gold- Yu Na Kim 2010 (duh). All 9 1st place votes under 6.0 atleast a 20 point win margin (short program alone would be atleast 10 points higher) under COP.
Silver- Under 6.0 Tara from 98. Under COP probably Asada from 2010 due to a huge short program lead over either Tara or Kwan from 98.
Bronze- Under 6.0 Kwan from 98. Under COP Kwan from 98 as well probably.
4th- Under 6.0 Asada from 2010. Under COP Tara from 98.
5th- Under 6.0 Nagasu from 2010. Under COP Rochette from 2010.
6th- Reverse of 5th place.
7th- Arakawa from 2006.
8th- Under 6.0 Hughes from 2002 I guess. Under COP Cohen from 2006.
9th- Kerrigan from 1994 I guess.
10th- Chen from 1994.
If we went down to the top 20, 10 to 12 of the top 20 would all come from 2010, as well as 4 of the top 6 as it is.