Yes, because the Amanar is the quad of gymnastics....
I am free of all prejudices. I hate everyone equally.~W. C. Fields
There will be a triple twisting Yurchenko vault within two years by either McKayla Maroney or Simone Biles, so all this Amanar talk will die down soon enough. This was not a one year ordeal, it was the first of many looking at the junior crop, and I think we are on the brink of women's vault being taken to a level we haven't seen before.
Last edited by Karpenko; 08-05-2012 at 05:00 AM.
I can't wait until all the Yurchenkos get devalued.
I'm looking forward to seeing handsprings and Tsuk's again.
At least Chuso has kept other vaults alive.
And then everyone will be doing TTY's...oh dear Lord. Just Say No; Save the Knees!
Well I must admit I do far prefer the way mens vaults are valued. 0.4 difference from 2.5TY and 2TY and 0.4 from 2.5TY and Dragulescu. And they have two extra apparatuses to make up the difference.
For women I really don't see why there can't be a 0.4 difference between the Amanar and Double Yurchenko and then another 0.4 difference for a 1.5TY. Amanar still gives an advantage and likely would continue to be used if a gymnast can do it without putting so much pressure on gymnasts that are unable to do an amanar. At the same time those that have trouble doing a double twisting yurchenko can do a 1.5 twisting yurchenko instead.
The proposal is to drop the amanar to 6.3 value which would give a 0.5 difference which is better but if the men don't have such a difference then why do the women? Seems a bit crazy to me.
Though I do agree gymnasts doing something other than a yurchenko would be rather welcomed though I don't actually understand why they dropped gymnasts having to do two vaults.
Edit: A further problem is the seeming rewarding of greater execution simply because they pull off a more difficult vault.
Last edited by gingercrush; 08-05-2012 at 05:24 AM.
I don't have an issue with the Amanar score, though it'd be good to see some other vaults also getting a similar d score. I think the leveling out of d scores across all the events has been good overall. I remember in 2008, Nastia had a mind blowing 7.7 start value on bars. While I was rooting for Nastia to win, I always thought it was kind of ridiculous that Shawn was doing the hardest skills in the world on beam, vault, and floor, and she was getting only a 7.0??, 6.5, and 6.3?? start values for those events.
I agree. I was rooting for Nastia and beyond thrilled when she won. However, Shawn Johnson really was short-changed by the Code in 2008.
I'm happy that Gabby wants to continue.
I hope that all proceeds as she wishes.
Some trustworthy people need to see that she/her mother get proper management/financial advice; so that they can make the best choices of the options that will open to them in the months ahead.
I would hate to see her become a "victim" of her success, in any way.
Finally watched this. Needed a few days breaks after hearing of results. I agree with the medalists though all the amanars were overscored but especially Komova. Were bars scoring increased or did people just show better bars? Mustafina in particular looked way better than in qualification and team finals. I felt Douglas was slightly overscored on beam but her connections were spot on. Floor. Komova was great and probably deserved a slightly higher score.
Raisman is incredibly unlucky with the tie rules but I do feel Mustafina was the better gymnast on the day. I love that Izbasa and Deng Linlin round off the top six. Iordache being ninth is wrong. I hope she continues and has some great competition as what she has done at these olympics is no reflection on the gymnast she really is
http://abcnews.go.com/Sports/london-...7#.UBzCVKAnNCS -- but I wanted to link it again because it's an interview that shows Gabby's mother giving Missy - the woman who housed Gabby in Iowa - a lot of credit. I was pretty impressed.
She hasn't been in the limelight for positive things lately.
Her life in America has been pretty tough in spite of all the support people have given her.
1) A failed marriage
2) Her son end up in jail
3) Contract disputes over her exclusivity at various gyms.
4) Shoplifiting incident over food
Nevertheless, people will always remember her as the perky Gold Medalist from Munich, taking away thunder from the Olympic champ, Ludmilla Tourischeva.
McKayla Maroney has a great sense of humor. She posted this after she went to the pool and found it closed: