NNN by far. She had the whole package minus the lutz. Super talented and like others already said, she was oozing with personality and charisma. She just had that "look". Totally agree, I never would have thought in a million years that Sarah, and not Naomi would be the one to make it big.
I wasn't that impressed with Bebe when I first saw her, but I did enjoy her programs 2005-2007, especially her Firedance SP. Unlike the majority of the ladies mentioned in the original post, she had a very long career. A top 10 finish at Worlds during the Mao-Yuna era is nothing to sneeze at.
Jenny Kirk and AP were also very good but I never thought they were World podium material.