American Idol Top 5 Poll

[PeterG]

Peter, just save yourself and only watch Haley's rendition of House of the Rising Sun. You can skip the others.

I did watch everything and LOVED Haley singing "You And I". Best performance of the night, don't know what the judges were thinking. (Plus I'm tired of young people doing old moldy classics...I never want to hear any human on the planet sing "Stand By Me", "Sitting On The Dock Of The Bay", "Georgia On My Mind", etc., etc. ever again!!!

P.S. I thought Jacob's vocals were one step this side of totally atrocious. It sounded like he was singing "No Air" in either a completely wrong key, or starting singing one octave too high!

[BigB08822]

I thought he came out singing an octave too high which is really crazy considering he was singing a womans vocals as it was so it was already set pretty high. He could not maintain it at all. It was probably his worst vocal and that says something. Well, until he went and made a complete fool of himself at the end of tonight's show. I hope Slezak let's him have it in the next Idoloonies.

[Aceon6]

I hope Slezak let's him have it in the next Idoloonies.

Didn't quite rip him a new one, but he's no fan.