American Idol - Top 12 (March 16th and 17th)

[Satellitegirl]

I thought it was ok...but not a great song choice for him. So far, no one has wowed me tonight.

[PRlady]

I just don't like that song. Or Bon Jovi, much, if I'm being honest.

I've never used my Subaru as a green weapon of death but you're tempting me.

[Jenna]

Clearly, I know bugger all about music. I thought that sounded horrible.

I thought it was shaky in spots. Sooo much better last week!

[rfisher]

I've never used my Subaru as a green weapon of death but you're tempting me.

Is it their music you like or Jon Bon Jovi?

[PrincessLeppard]

I've never used my Subaru as a green weapon of death but you're tempting me.

Great. There's an avocado after me.

[Cyn]

I have no TV in the office any longer so I can't do PBP , so I'm here during the commercials.

Naima - Awful

Paul - can't even call it awful because that wasn't singing. It was a feline castration while on helium

Thia - Total snooze. When did Randy start making sense?

James - I wanted to like it. I really did. But it was not up to par with his ability. Plus I find Bon Jovi to be the epitome of Pop Rock and about as rock and roll as a Marshmallow Peep . If only he'd been born in 1987 - he could have sung something from Def Leppard's Hysteria album.

Love that Steven Tyler got majorly bleeped - what did he say?

[kylet3]

Haley... somewhere a drag queen is offended... and elsewhere a goat and a gerbil on helium is howling at a moon!

[PrincessLeppard]

Why does Haley grunt when she sings?

And how did she get lipstick on her chin?

[Satellitegirl]

I thought Haley was the best of night so far.

[Allskate]

Haley - "I'm Your Baby Tonight". Bad song choice, IMO. I do not like what she's trying to do with this. I don't like her phrasing or what she does to the songs she chooses. Lyrics seem irrelevant to her.

[Jenna]

I thought Haley was the best of night so far.

I agree.

[my little pony]

there is an amazing voice deep deep deep down inside of hayley that can't crawl out from behind this dull demeanor, it is like she isnt being herself and so it doesnt work

(peter - that's about hayley)

[Allskate]

I disagree with Randy because, even though the originals of these songs may have come from different genres, Haley generally sings (or mumbles) them the same way.

[my little pony]

I've never used my Subaru as a green weapon of death but you're tempting me.

believe me, that smoky car of yours is a carcinogen

[JILEN]

Hate that Whitney Houston song but that was a strong performance by Hailey..at least she's getting out of her comfort zone.

[kylet3]

maybe its my being ill but they are all doing a damn good job of splitting my ears tonight... Can we replace this with last night's Glee episode instead?

[PrincessLeppard]

I would prefer Stefano try out Funky Cold Medina rather than caterwauling to Simply Red.

[Allskate]

Stefano -- "If You Don't Know Me By Now" - He's still closing his eyes too much. He's kind of acquiring a lounge singer vibe. Meh.

[Satellitegirl]

Ok Stefano had the best performance so far, now. Last note he ran out of air on a bit, but otherwise really good.

And I agree, Allskate...don't care for the faces he was making.

[PRlady]

Is it their music you like or Jon Bon Jovi?

What a dumb question.

Both, actually. But Jon is aging better than any rock star I can think of...and he's age appropriate for

It's not an avocado, it's a bronze n' green tank, Princess, and don't you forget it.