American Idol (May 4th and 5th) - The Top Five (That’s Life…All The Way)

[Fridge_Break]

I think Casey brought multiple goats tonight.

[soxxy]

I think Casey struggled badly with Blue Skies....really badly

[LuckyCharm]

Wow. I don't think that arrangement did Casey any favors.

[kylet3]

Casey makes me want to hide... he sounds like when you have a dentist run that machine that makes the spinning noise...

[my little pony]

if Casey and Carmen Rasmussen had a baby, it might be an actual goat

[PrincessLeppard]

I didn't really like it, but then this isn't my kind of music. I don't think it's as bad as Randy said.

But he was totally uncomfortable without a guitar.

[soxxy]

Casey should have taken the $50 gig with his friend. Kara mentions a lamb.

[kylet3]

if Casey and Carmen Rasmussen had a baby, it might be an actual goat

[Cyn]

Well, I missed seeing Aaron's performance thanks to two stupid phone calls, one being an automated call from the Superintendent from our school district reminding us that it's Teacher Appreciation Week

Casey - Pitch issues all over the damn place. I get what he was trying to do, but that was a fcuking trainwreck. Unless someone tanks worse, I have a feeling Casey is going to be toast tomorrow night.

ZOMG Kara brings up the Goat Throat . You only noticed that now? Are you fcuking deaf, you daft bint?

[numbers123]

I do like Casey's purple shirt.

[kylet3]

I don't care who goes as long as it's Lee and Crystal that end up in the final 2...

[shells]

I would like Ellen to stop making jokes about the piano. I get it, you're friends.

[shan]

I think Casey brought multiple goats tonight.

Yeah he had a whole herd of them!!


to Kara for actually pointing it out!!

[Allskate]

I hope they have a better theme next week. I don't like it when they limit it so much to one artist. Last week it was Shania and this week it's Frank Sinatra. I hope it's something really wide open next week.

[haribobo]

Um, so I woke up at 8:17 to turn on the tv and Aaron had just finished singing the first song? What did they fill all that time with?

[soxxy]

Um, so I woke up at 8:17 to turn on the tv and Aaron had just finished singing the first song? What did they fill all that time with?

Harry's career highlights and Frank's.

[Fridge_Break]

Um, so I woke up at 8:17 to turn on the tv and Aaron had just finished singing the first song? What did they fill all that time with?

Commercials, fluff pieces, Ryan whoring the camera, etc.

[Allskate]

This season is so boring there's even a shortage of snark. I'm surprised the ratings aren't significantly lower.

[kylet3]

Crystal seriously schooling the other two... Superb

[rjblue]

Crystal is wearing my daughter's prom dress from 2003. Except my daughter is 5'10" and weighs 135.