Vanessa Crone

Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by puglover, Jan 6, 2012.

  1. puglover

    puglover Active Member

    707
    184
    43
    Does anybody know if Vanessa has found a new partner? I was so sorry to hear of her split with Paul. She always seemed to have spunk and I really liked her athletic style. I hope this is not the end of her dance career.
     
  2. Ladida

    Ladida Member

    133
    22
    18
    I thought she is skating now with K. Hubbell. I definitely saw some pics with her and other icedancers from Camarlengo group. Can anyone confirm it?
     
  3. arakwafan2006

    arakwafan2006 Active Member

    783
    166
    43
    I was there enjoying watching skating and i dont remember seeing her there. Shae Lynn was there and she's even more beautiful in person :D She might of been there earlier in the day but was not there when i was... i dont think... lol
     
  4. Tak

    Tak Well-Known Member

    2,481
    288
    83
    Does anyone think Crone/Hill would make a good team? Though Ralph/Hill have improved, basically she is nowhere near as good as he is and is holding the team down. He needs a better partner - he's an excellent dancer with a great sense of rhythm, but he'll never get anywhere IMO until he gets a better partner.

    And to leave Vanessa languishing without a partner is just so wrong - she's the Jana of Canada - definitely too good to waste.
     
  5. ltnskater

    ltnskater Active Member

    603
    40
    28
    No, that plan fell through ages ago I believe. (Though you are right that they were trying out earlier).
     
  6. smithie

    smithie New Member

    35
    2
    0
    Vanessa and Keifer started a partnership at the end of September and were skating at DSC with Camrlengo. They skated together until December, and were looking really amazing. They would have given G/P more than just a run for their money. They had synched together beautifully and had great charisma together.

    However, Keifer is a much more accomplished skater, nationally and internationally than Piper, and the USFSA was not willing to grant a release for him as they did with her. Nor does he have a Canadian family connection to get him a quick citizenship as Piper does.

    It is really too bad as they truly had great potential. I wish them both good luck, but in particular Vanessa, who is a very talented skater with lovely edges. As the female, though, she will have a much more difficult time finding a suitable partner than Keifer - if she even wants to after all she must have been through in the last 8 months.

    Maybe Keifer can skate with Piper and Vanessa and Paul can get back together.
     
  7. Yukari Lepisto

    Yukari Lepisto Active Member

    698
    45
    28
    and I assume the Canadian Fed won't release Vanessa either? if they were to skate for the US?
     
  8. ltnskater

    ltnskater Active Member

    603
    40
    28
    Piper and Keifer had already tried out, and it did not work out, because I believe Madison Chock was his first choice. After she turned him down for Evan Bates, Keifer wanted Piper back, but of course, she was with Paul and would not be Keifer's second choice.

    Vanessa and Keifer tried out, but unfortunately the dilemma here was that neither federation would release either of them, and the partnership dissolved because there the Olympics would not have been possible.
     
  9. mirage

    mirage Member

    178
    13
    18


    They did not just ```try out`` . This was a very good, go ahead partnership with full steam ahead training.

    The Olympics is not the be all and end all. The issue is that an athlete has to be released by their federation to even compete internationally. Piper is in Canada, because she thinks she has a good shot at getting to the Olympics, which she would not have had a prayer to do in the USA.

    Vanessa competed at Worlds in 2011, is a National Champion and an Olympic athlete. Not a hope she will be released any time soon. With the skategods in their corner, Vanessa and Keifer might have had a chance to compete in 2014-2015 at the earliest. We all know in Ice Dance that may as well be an eternity.
     
  10. lavenderblue

    lavenderblue Active Member

    498
    55
    28
    Ugh, that's terribly depressing. I was so intrigued by the rumblings about Vanessa and Keiffer, but the potential release issue made me wonder.

    There's also an odd sort of "wrongness" to me (even as I understand it from the fed's perspective) that dancers and pairs skaters with less success have that greater advantage in creating new partnerships.
     
  11. Yukari Lepisto

    Yukari Lepisto Active Member

    698
    45
    28
    They trained together for quite some time, it wasn't just a "try out", and it didn't fall through ages ago.
     
  12. Jayar

    Jayar Well-Known Member

    8,648
    2,182
    113
    I always thought that Keiffer would look good with Charlotte Lichtman, but I would never advocate splitting up any team.
     
  13. ltnskater

    ltnskater Active Member

    603
    40
    28
    I'm not entirely sure which team you are referring to about me saying "try out", Piper and Keiffer? or Vanessa and Keiffer?

    Because it was simply a try out for Piper and Keiffer, not a partnership. With Vanessa, yes I did say "try out" but i meant it in a different sense (from Piper and Keiffer) that it was a partnership that would have worked had they been able to have the possibility of going to the Olympics for 2014. Unfortunately, this was not going to happen, but YES you are correct that the earliest they could compete internationally IF either one of them were released by their federation, would be in 3 years/seasons hence missing the 2014 Olympics and unfortunately, this was the crucial point that dissolved that temporary/short partnership. (tryout - whatever you want to call it)

    With regards to Piper, certainly with Paul, and competing in Canada, the chances of going to the Olympics are certainly higher, but that is only part of the reason, there are many other reasons (they work well together, coaches knew Piper from before, able to be released and compete internationally after one year, and again as I mentioned above, she was not going to be Keiffer's second choice, Chock being his first - btw, I really hope I'm not mixing up Emily Samuelson and Madison Chock, I'm pretty sure it was Madison, but it has been a few months so my memory has faded a bit). There are also probably more reasons I don't know about, but those are the ones I do know, but yes, being able to compete internationally after only 1 year is something Piper and Paul is able to do, but not Vanessa and Keiffer.

    Ok, ok, I was exaggerating a little when I said ages ago because it has been only a couple months since the partnership dissolved (as far as I've heard, I know Vanessa was by herself back in Canada by November, I didn't know she was still with Keiffer in Dec. is the poster above who posted sure of that?). As I just mentioned above, I said "try out" because the partnership hinged on whether or not it was even possible for them to compete at the 2014 Olympics, and not only that, but also the 3 years they must wait to even compete internationally...
     
  14. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,841
    3,732
    113
    The citizenship rules are quite clear, and based on being a permanent resident and having three out of four years of residency in Canada, or getting an exception granted at high levels of government, like Kaitlyn Weaver did.

    Hubbell would qualify for permanent residency just as easily as Gllles without any family connection whatsoever, because through his "participation at a world-class level in cultural activities or athletics" he would be considered a self-employed person who has "relevant experience that will make a significant contribution to the cultural or athletic life of Canada."
     
  15. tapper88

    tapper88 New Member

    311
    6
    0
    Just curious, how did Kaitlyn end up getting an exception granted? (I'm glad she did!)
     
  16. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,841
    3,732
    113
    I don't know what the process is, i.e., whether she applied for it or was nominated, but it took a decision by the federal cabinet to issue a special grant of citizenship:

    http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/department/media/releases/2009/2009-06-22a.asp

    (This announcement was made by Immigration Canada and posted to its website.)
     
  17. smithie

    smithie New Member

    35
    2
    0

    Yes, receiving permanent residency would apply to both of them but an expedited citizenship is not so easy. From G/P, because she has family with Canadian citizenship, she can receive/be grandfathered to Canadian citizen on an accelerated timeline.
     
  18. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,841
    3,732
    113
    As a child born outside Canada, if Gilles has at least one Canadian parent, including those parents born outside Canada and lost/couldn't get (because of holding another citizenship that prevented it) Canadian citizenship between 1947 and 1977, she would automatically be a citizen, She would need only to file before age 28 that plans to keep Canadian citizenship and apply for proof of citizenship in order to get a passport; there's no expedited citizenship process.

    The CIC site says nothing about expedited citizenship for people born outside Canada before 17 April 2009 and who have family members who are Canadian citizens, while it has extensive information for those who wish to sponsor family members for permanent residency. It's also interesting that for the years that I have been a part of forums for families immigrating to Canada, that there was never a single mention of any expedited process for citizenship, apart from provisions of a new law that applied to children born after 17 April 2009, and that question is asked rather frequently.
     
    PeterG and (deleted member) like this.
  19. Erin

    Erin Well-Known Member

    5,233
    941
    113
    Kind of funny that a thread about Vanessa Crone turns into a discussion about Piper's citizenship, but I believe one of the articles that came out of the Canadian challenge discussion indicated that it's one of Piper's maternal grandparents who is Canadian, and that her mom was going through the process of getting her citizenship, because doing so would somehow make Piper's citizenship faster/easier. I can't speak to whether any of that is true, but I can't see why Piper's mom would be dealing with citizenship now if it wasn't some benefit.
     
  20. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,841
    3,732
    113
    The rules are tricky due to the 2009 law, which tries to prevent Canadian citizenship for those who live outside Canada for multiple generations, but if Gilles' mother qualifies for Canadian citizenship through her mother, including her Gilles' mother and/or grandmother having it reinstated automatically by the 2009 or earlier law/ruling, then Gilles, having been born before 17 April 2009, would automatically become a Canadian citizen. Gilles wouldn't have to apply for citizenship, but would need to apply for proof of citizenship to get a passport. If her mother doesn't qualify, then Gilles has to go through the PR route, which Hubbell would have had to do, as would any non-Canadian with whom Crone would team up.

    I was wrong about Gilles having to file before age 28: I misread a qualification that doesn't apply to her, but may apply to her mother.
     
    Last edited: Jan 9, 2012
  21. NorthernDancers

    NorthernDancers Active Member

    223
    62
    28
    I'm a proud Canadian through and through, but I really think at this high level we need to do what is best for the athletes. To me it seems like a fair trade. Canada can keep Piper, and the US can keep Vanessa. Maybe there are easier routes to citizenship for Vanessa in the US.

    I get that there has been some support and commitment to Vanessa (and Paul) over the years in Canada, but I'm pretty sure the lion's share of the expenses were not paid by Skate Canada, but her parents and private supporters. She's already given back by winning Nationals and participating internationally for many years. Why can't we just let her go and skate with someone who is a good match for her? I don't see why Skate Canada should "own" any athlete. At the Senior level, the field of potential is exceptionally small, even internationally. There should be some way for this partnership, if it is good fit, to be possible.
     
  22. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,841
    3,732
    113
    Does anyone know the details on USFS' position on Hubbell? USFS has been inconsistent with the lengths of releases. According to Gilles, USFS is holding her for two seasons. It told Matthews it would hold her for four, the maximum its own rules say they can. They released her partner, Maxim Zavozin, in less than that; at the time, there were allegations that the Hungarian Fed paid USFS for the earlier release and that Zavozin had to pay back the Hungarian Fed.

    Did USFS agree to the same release schedule as Gilles, which was too late for Crone, or did they say they would keep him for longer/the maximum?

    There is a rule in the ISU constitution that allows the ISU to grant release after two years to citizens and, in some cases, permanent residents of a second Federation, if the second Federation files for the exception. I wonder if USFS' agreement to release Gilles and Zavozin in two seasons, the same amount of time in the ISU exception process, stemmed from likely impending citizenship in the new Federations country, but insist on longer terms for those who don't have the citizenship route.
     
  23. euterpe

    euterpe Well-Known Member

    11,908
    1,152
    113
    Gilles' last international competition was 2010 JW, where she and Zach Donohue placed 9th. Their last medal was in the 2009-2010 JGP, where they won two bronze medals. They made the JGPF but withdrew before the competition. The US is holding Piper back until nearly 2013, about 3 years.

    The Hubbells won bronze at 2010 4CC. The US could refuse to release him until 2014 on that basis.
     
  24. miffy

    miffy Well-Known Member

    9,164
    1,480
    113
    Are these federations that refuse releases actively helping/trying to find a suitable match for the skaters?
     
  25. MarieM

    MarieM Grumpy Cynical Ice Dance Lover

    5,007
    836
    113
    Nope. They're ... not taking into consideration the athletes there, just the medal potential they can loose. Sore loosers.
     
  26. marbri

    marbri Hey, Kool-Aid!

    11,217
    2,019
    113
    The Olympics are in two years. Even if both were released by their federations I don't see how either could gain citizenship in two years? Isn't that what somebody on the previous page said was the main issue for them?
     
  27. clarie

    clarie Well-Known Member

    2,556
    320
    83
    It's just such a shame that there are wonderful skaters like Vanessa who are world class that cannot skate because of these rules set out by federations. We are being robbed as well as them :(.
     
  28. mirage

    mirage Member

    178
    13
    18

    The Olympics is just one competition, albeit quite the event.

    The issue is a federation release is required for an athlete to compete at ANY international competition. Without it they would be training to compete at Nationals only, with no opportunity to go anywhere from there.
     
  29. museksk8r

    museksk8r Holding an edge and looking dangerously sexy

    3,301
    472
    83
    Crone, K. Hubbell, and Yankowskas . . . :drama::wuzrobbed. I really hope to see them all back on the ice competing soon!
     
  30. professordeb

    professordeb Well-Known Member

    3,817
    414
    83
    Really feeling bad for Vanessa and others who are in skating limbo like this. Here's to hoping something can be done soon.