U.S. Ladies [#4]: Gold or Pyrite?

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by Vagabond, Apr 4, 2012.

  1. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,101
    636
    113
    I wish Dunne and Sophia Adams would get a chancw to compete at an ISU event
    On a good day they compare favorably with their rivals at nationals
    I'd be curious how they would fare abroad.
     
  2. carriemarie

    carriemarie New Member

    328
    14
    0
    I know she will get an assignment, but I like Polina Edmunds. She is very young and looks like she will grow, but her short program at Nationals was quite impressive this year. I think David Glynn has done a good job with her thus far.
     
  3. skfan

    skfan Member

    404
    20
    18
    it would be nice if dunne, sophia adams and aimee buchanan get more opportunities. yes, i know aimee wouldn't even be at nationals if cesario didn't withdraw, but she skated and she delighted me with her charm. anyway, the world needs more beautiful layback spins :)
     
  4. demetriosj

    demetriosj Well-Known Member

    1,082
    55
    48
    How do you know? Why can't she have a break-through season? Last year at this time there was no Gracie G buzz. Things can change.
     
  5. RD

    RD Well-Known Member

    3,966
    155
    63
    I'm not saying she CAN'T...just that if she was going to make noise, from a statistical standpoint it's likely it would have happened by now. But in general I agree that things change, stranger things have happened and we can't know for sure.
     
  6. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,521
    4,924
    113
    I agree that Polina is very talented, but her 6th place finish in Junior at Nationals doesn't guarantee her a JGP assignment. I counted 17 JGP age-eligible ladies listed in the ISP (only 3 of whom finished behind her at Nationals) -- see: http://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/showthread.php?p=3556714#post3556714
     
  7. Jammers

    Jammers Well-Known Member

    4,082
    421
    83
    How do you figure that? Alissa was 21 when she won her first title. Nancy Kerrigan was 23. Skaters peak at different times and ages.
     
  8. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,521
    4,924
    113
    It should be noted that Alissa won her first medal at Nationals in 2001 (Junior silver) when she was 13 and started competing internationally then, too (Junior gold at Triglav Trophy in April 2001).
     
  9. RD

    RD Well-Known Member

    3,966
    155
    63
    But Czisny is the exception...when you look at the top American skaters- Kwan, Lipinski, Hughes, Cohen, Meissner, Flatt, Zhang, Nagasu, even Wagner- from their debut, they made their mark on the national scene. (It remains to be seen if Gold will follow the same route, but assuming she remains healthy it's highly likely.) For Czisny, it took a few seasons- 2007 was her breakout year nationally, although from 2005 you could see the talent present.
     
  10. ProgramerUSFS

    ProgramerUSFS Member

    156
    20
    18
    I think Gold will be very special. She has jumping technic like nothing I have ever seen before. She is someone to watch going forward, as I think she will out shine the rest that you mention.
     
  11. 5Ali3

    5Ali3 Active Member

    437
    178
    43
    I may be misunderstanding your post, but for many of the skaters on your list, I hardily disagree that they "made their mark" on the National scene from their debut. Michelle Kwan made so little impression on me that in mid-1992, I couldn't recall a single thing about Kwan's National debut (1992 Junior, 9th), including that she existed - now Caroline Song (1992 Junior, 1st), I could tell you about that performance in detail! What a beautiful skater... Similarly, despite (apparently) watching Sasha Cohen's Nationals debut (1998 Novice, 6th) and National follow-up (1999 Junior, 2nd), I didn't particularly notice her until 2000 Nationals (Senior, 1st after SP, 2nd overall). I believe that I did not see Lipinski's Nationals debut (1994 Novice, 2nd), but her Nationals follow-up (1995 Junior, 2nd) would have been utterly forgettable if it weren't for Christine Brennan's book about the 1995-1996 season. For that matter, I'm not sure that I consider Gold's Nationals debut (2010 Novice, 4th) to have "made a mark." I'll stop now and try to make a broader point.

    Come to think of it, I'm not sure what broad point we're discussing. I see a few options:
    1) To become one of the top U.S. women, does one need to have made a mark in one's Nationals debut? No, however we're measuring "made a mark."

    2) Does making a mark in Junior Ladies predict anything about a skater's Senior Ladies' career? Yes, it's a fairly good predictor of qualifying for Nationals as a Senior Lady the following year, but it's a lousy predictor of long-term international success as a Senior Lady. I refer you to Megan Hyatt, Sandy Rucker, Erica Archambault, Louann Donovan, Joan Cristobal, Sara Wheat, Andrea Gardiner, Jennifer Karl, Michelle Cho, and Caroline Song in the post-figures era alone.

    3) Is Gold going to achieve success as a top international competitor at the Senior level? I honestly believe this cannot be predicted, based on history. I think Gold has many factors working in her favor that may not have been working in the favor of other Junior Ladies' champions (adult body, excellent jump timing). However, the other Junior Ladies' champ who had those same factors - and who Gold's skating reminds me of - is Sydne Vogel. Vogel had a successful career following her Junior Ladies' title in 1995 (over Lipinski), but she certainly didn't achieve the kind of success that was predicted for her in 1995. FWIW, Vogel's competition results in 1995-1996 and 1996-1997 were very strong (including the 1997 Junior World title in the fall of 1996 and a bronze medal at 1996 Skate America, her SGP debut). I don't know what Vogel would have accomplished if her career hadn't been derailed by injury. I certainly hope that Gold doesn't suffer injury - there has been a fairly strong link in the past 15 years between female skaters practicing triple-triples/3As and incurring serious injury - but after what I've seen and experienced in this sport, my main hopes for Gold are that she loves as much of this experience as possible, for however long she enjoys it, and that she eventually walks away without regret and with wonderful friends, memories, and experiences; and that she can walk in 20 years without pain. Lest you underestimate the latter, I'm on my way to dinner with a skating friend, at which we'll discuss her latest knee surgery, my next surgery, and compare the efficacy of various anti-inflammatories and pain relievers. Unfortunately, I'm not kidding.
     
  12. RD

    RD Well-Known Member

    3,966
    155
    63
    I was referring to debut on the SENIOR level, actually.
     
  13. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,665
    352
    83
    I tend to think she will get an assignment. I don't think skaters like Cesario, Baga, and maybe even Lam will do JGP again even though they are technically still "age eligible". Polina will be assigned before any novice medalists are as well. Gracie is doing senior GP. So that means Cain, Miller, Long, Bell, Wang, would be assigned before her (Lam too if she goes back to JGP). Then she's in a group with the likes of Nina Jiang, Leah Kesier, Yasmin Siraj, McKinzie Daniels and unlikely but possibly Kiri Baga (I assume she will focus on pairs) and Samantha Cesario (believe she is starting college in the fall, really old for JGP as is). Her chances of getting an assignment are probably better than the girls in this second group I mentioned, especially if she skates well over the summer. So no, it's not a garuantee, but I think she will likely get at least 1 JGP assignment this fall. She almost got assigned last season after finishing 7th in junior and there were more senior ladies doing JGP.
     
  14. Stephanie

    Stephanie Well-Known Member

    1,751
    78
    48
    Baga plans to do both singles and pairs and already has her singles programs choreographed. Based on her nationals placement, I can't see her not being offered a JGP.

    As for Lam, she's only 26th on the season's best list, so unlikely to get a senior GP, so it's almost certainly back to the JGP for her also.
     
  15. mgobluegirl

    mgobluegirl Well-Known Member

    2,053
    153
    63
    Well, yes, seeing as none of them are listed in the ISP as of now (Karen Chen is by far the most compelling of them, and she's too young).
     
  16. RD

    RD Well-Known Member

    3,966
    155
    63
    Responding to this comment from "judgejudy27" in the now locked Czisny thread:

    True, its easy to say these ladies would be all on top of the world if they could just hold it together, but really, the evidence says otherwise. Flatt at 2009 Worlds, Nagasu at 2010 Olympics, Czisny at 2011 Worlds, even Wagner this year- they were at or close to their best and not a single medal from any of them, even with relatively weak competition the past couple of years. I think the US ladies have lost so much ground in such a short amount of time that it's incredible, really.
     
  17. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,101
    636
    113
    Many successful lady skaters seemed to peak technically at senior level.

    I have been wondering about the same. Between 1993-1997, Tara was the only junior lady nationals medalist to make the senior podium at US nationals.

    Between 1998-2001, there were a few more--Sarah Hughes, AP were junior ladies champ; Sasha, Kirk, Czisny and Nam were all junior medalists and they all eventually placed top 4 at senior nationals. Only Sarah, Sasha and Kirk medalled at a senior ISU championship though (Must mention here that Czisny won a GPF, a big win though not an ISu championship).

    Then in 2004, Meissner and Taylor won and placed 2nd in junior ladies and they both placed top 4 at US nationals subsequently and won ISU championships at a senior level.

    Then there's Flatt in 2006 (placing second in jr ladies). The year after that, Nagasu, Zhang and Wagner in jr ladies. In 2010, Agnes.

    I remember some talk about the jr lady champ jinx until Sarah Hughes broke it. So I guess the trend pre-Hughes was that girls did fairly well at the lower levels but peaked technically at senior competitions (probably due to luck, timing, body changes, etc.) With the ISU age rule, girls not ISU-championship eligible agewise are better off staying jr unless they are so good they can place top 6 in senior anyway (e.g. Flatt in 2007 US nationals), so there'll be more girls staying jr longer. That said, I do wonder when girls decide to skate senior at nationals. You don't want to skate senior at nationals until you are technically ready (or you get lost in the middle of the pack fast); on the other hand, you don't wanna stay jr any longer than you have to, because the window for a US lady is short, so when you are skating well, you wanna have a shot at landing the big championships, and that means moving up to seniors. You don't wanna do your best stuff in your career at jr level and win "lesser" titles.

    :yikes: (Now worried....)
     
    Last edited: Apr 29, 2012
  18. chipso1

    chipso1 Well-Known Member

    9,012
    671
    113
    Cross posting this here. I must say, I am truly impressed with the improvements Gracie has made to her artistry!! Her skating skills, jumps and spins were fab as always too, but she performed amazingly.

     
  19. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,521
    4,924
    113
    Thanks for sharing your impressions, chipso1! :)

    Plus there's Courtney Hicks IF she has recovered fully and monitors well this summer.
     
  20. Jammers

    Jammers Well-Known Member

    4,082
    421
    83
    Of all those skaters who could have been on the podium at Worlds or the Olympic was Mirai at Worlds 2010. Even with just a decent skate in the LP she would have been on the podium. She had the most potential and talent and could have actually been a World champion. Rachael even at her best was never going to be on a podium at Worlds and Alissa and Ashley were not as good as Mirai when Mirai was focused and on her game.
     
  21. Polymer Bob

    Polymer Bob New Member

    2,667
    159
    0
    I haven't read every note in this thread, but the general theme seems to be that we ( in the U.S. ) are waiting for a savior-ess to fly in like Mighty Mouse and save the day.

    I don't know who or when, but I will guess she will arrive eventually.
     
  22. icellist

    icellist Member

    421
    25
    18
    i'm not completely sold on the gracie bandwagon yet but i still look forward to the moment when the US has 3 ladies spots for Ashley Wagner, Mirai Nagasu, and Gracie Gold
     
  23. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,101
    636
    113
    I'm not sure there will be such a person. I don't think you'll see consistent skaters like Kwan in the COP era, because programs that are supposedly clean pre-COP are probably dinged for URs/spin rotations in the current system. I'm beginning to think skaters like Flatt are about as consistent as you're likely to get in the COP era. I mean, even with a serius injury, she could do 3 triples in the world championship. Looking back this is impressive.

    With the upcomers, you risk having them crash and burn if you promote them too soon; OTOH, you risk them getting an injury or having passed their peak if you let them wait their turn.
     
  24. smarts1

    smarts1 Well-Known Member

    2,103
    135
    63
    I can guarantee had Alena skated last at Worlds this year instead of Makarova, Ashley would have been on that podium.
     
  25. Polymer Bob

    Polymer Bob New Member

    2,667
    159
    0
    You may be right, but we need ladies who can win medals regardless of skating order or other factors.
     
    skateboy and (deleted member) like this.
  26. RD

    RD Well-Known Member

    3,966
    155
    63
    True, Nagasu did have a legit chance in 2010. The real kicker is she may never get that close to a World championship again...(let's see if she can pull it together next season)

    Woulda, coulda, shoulda. Perhaps if she skated exactly the same but was in that last group to get higher PCS she would have been 3rd too. Point is, we need someone who is ALWAYS in the mix, not just in it when top skaters make mistakes.

    :eek: Wow, big words! (gush gush, hype hype! ;) ) Anyway, thanks for sharing your report.
     
  27. chipso1

    chipso1 Well-Known Member

    9,012
    671
    113
    It's not hype, it's the truth. Gracie's jumps are the best of any female skater currently competing. You have to see her live to truly appreciate them. Her technique is so perfect it's just crazy!
     
  28. smarts1

    smarts1 Well-Known Member

    2,103
    135
    63
    True. This has been a breakthrough season for Ashley, so we'll need to see if she can pull through with the momentum for the next season. If she does, she'll definitely be a medal contender at Worlds (well depends on if Yuna and Miki both decide to skate next season, which means that it'll be much harder for Ashley to medal).

    But on top of that, Alena was way overscore on PCS in both the SP and LP. It was a joke that she got higher PCS than Akiko and Mao in the SP, and that she pretty got the same PCS as Mao and Akiko in the LP.
     
  29. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,665
    352
    83
    Yes but in terms of placements in seniors vs. juniors, it's a toss up over who will be assigned first. Lam with her international experience would likely be assigned before Polina if she choses to do JGP, but Polina could feasibly be assigned ahead of the likes of Kiri, Nina, Leah, etc.
     
  30. Theatregirl1122

    Theatregirl1122 Well-Known Member

    18,765
    3,272
    113
    Not to mention that, if Ashley had ACTUALLY skated her best (specifically a clean SP) then it is very likely should would have medaled. So it is inaccurate to say she skated her best and didn't medal when she didn't skate her best at all in the SP which left her out of the last group and probably held her PCS down.