New York Drivers - insurance question

Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by oleada, Aug 16, 2011.

  1. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    Hi all,

    I recently moved to Brooklyn. I've lived in New York for over a year and had my car stored at my uncle's, but due to changes in circumstances, I've brought it to where I live. Parking isn't really a problem. I'm a safe driver and have never had a ticket or car accident. For the moment, I mostly drive to get groceries, visit friends/family in Flushing, LI or NJ, and in the fall, I'll hopefully drive it to my internship. Other relevant data: I'm 23, female, single, renting, yada yada yada. Car is an 2009 Nissan Sentra.

    I'm looking for new insurance. Before I lived in OK, and had pretty good insurance. However, it's regional, and I don't believe this company would cover me if I live in NY. I pay nearly $250 a month, and that's always been expensive compared to others I know. However, that seems cheap compared to the rates I'm getting now! I've looked at Allstate, Progressive, Geico, Mercury, Travelers and Farmers, and the rates I'm getting are astronomical. It's, like, over $600 a month, which I definitely can't afford.

    So my questions are:

    a.) What insurance company do you have? (especially if you live in New York) How much do you pay, if you don't mind me asking?
    b.) Is insurance generally this expensive in New York City?
    c.) Would I get better rates if I call rather than do online quotes?

    Thanks. I'm just having such a hard time believing that car insurance is this expensive! And here I thought that I was always way overcharged...:shuffle:
     
  2. Karina1974

    Karina1974 Well-Known Member

    2,662
    228
    63
    A) I have Traveler's. I was with Progressive for a few years, but I was able to get the exact same policy with Traveler's for half the price. My premium is $91.50/month. I also get a discount because I take the AAA definsive driving course every couple of years, which will knock your premium down a bit. It lowered my premium by $37 last May.

    B) I wouldn't know. I live upstate, just outside of Albany (see my location).

    C) Again, I'm no help. I go through an insurance agent, Schenectady Insuring, and they are actually the reason I switched from Progressive to Traveler's, because I had been a client in good standing with a clean record, so they offered to find me a better rate.
     
  3. Aceon6

    Aceon6 Get off my lawn

    6,665
    1,127
    113
    - I sent an email to my nephew in Brooklyn who insures an older model Subaru. I'll PM you when I get a response. I believe it's around $2,000/year, but I'll double check.
    b.) Is insurance generally this expensive in New York City?
    - Yes, for three reasons. Due to congestion, the odds of an accident are MUCH higher than they are in less congested areas. Second, some parts of Brooklyn have drivers with less than stellar records so your actual zip code is important. If your neighbors are bad drivers, this carries over to your quotes. (btw, Park Slope is cheapest.) Finally, there is a very high auto theft rate. If your car is old, you may look for quotes on liability only and just purchase the minimum collision and comprehensive. Warning, this means you are self-insured if the car is stolen or damaged by someone else. Check your car's wholesale value on a site like Edmunds and do the math.
    c.) Would I get better rates if I call rather than do online quotes?
    Possibly. Ask someone to introduce you to their independent insurance agent. Also, ask you employer if help with insurance is part of their employee benefits program. Another option would be to call your current insurer and ask for a referral. Regionals sometimes affiliate with other regionals just for this scenario.
     
  4. GarrAarghHrumph

    GarrAarghHrumph I can kill you with my brain

    16,414
    2,332
    113
    I've always paid more when I live in an urban area than when I live outside of one. You also tend to pay more if you're under age 25, so you can't necessarily compare the rates you're getting quoted at age 23 with those of others on this board in that area of the city who are older. And yes, car insurance in NY State tends to be more expensive than in many other regions of the US.

    Are your parents available to you? Does their insurance company cover NY State? If so, you might be able to go on their insurance plan, getting the advantage of their multiple car discount.
     
  5. Badams

    Badams Well-Known Member

    5,038
    1,217
    113
    We go through Farmers and we pay less than $100 a month. At least that's what the last bill said. I live in NY, but in the boonies compared to the city.
     
  6. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    Thank you so much for the info, guys.

    Thanks for the info. I live in the Slope, so I guess that's good.

    I wish it were an option :( We just got our green cards, but my parents are still in Colombia. The only other person in my family with a US driver's license is my younger sister.
     
  7. Aceon6

    Aceon6 Get off my lawn

    6,665
    1,127
    113
    Given the situation, getting a referral from your current carrier or getting introduced to an insurance agent is probably your best bet.

    Another thing to look into is discounts for things like belonging to AAA, affiliation with any university, that sort of thing. An insurance agent should help you figure out what discounts you can get.
     
  8. znachki

    znachki Active Member

    774
    75
    28
    I'm not in New York, so I don't know if this applies, but, have you asked about, or indicated that you aren't using the car for commuting? If you only use the vehicle for "recreational use" which it seems you do, it could be less. You may have to indicate that to them. Just a thought.
     
  9. Cheylana

    Cheylana Well-Known Member

    4,982
    967
    113
    Maintaining a car in NYC is outrageously expensive, due in no small part to the insurance premiums. That's why most people here don't bother with cars.

    I do have a friend in Brooklyn (Williamsburg) who used to live in Pennsylvania. I believe his car is still registered in Pennsylvania so he can pay a lower insurance. As far as the insurance company knows, he's still living in PA, but he's actually been living in Brooklyn for at least a decade. I do not recommend you try this method. :eek:
     
  10. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    I agree. I wouldn't have my car here if I had somewhere else to keep it, but I don't. :( As for your friend....that's kind of where I'm at right now. :eek: And what I'm trying to change.

    I don't get why I'm such a risk. I mean, I do, single, young, license for less than 3 years, but "high risk" (as an agent from a company referred to me) - really? :drama:

    I'm trying to contact a college friend who lives in MO, and has more accidents than I can count to see where she gets her insurance.
     
  11. Scintillation

    Scintillation New Member

    2,727
    542
    0
    Okay this is kind of sort of off topic, but I have a question since I'll be moving to NYC in May for school--whats your cost of living per month like? I've been doing some calculations but I'm not sure how accurate they are.
    Also a very talkative cab driver told me that to insure one car in NYC it could cost as much as $4,000 a year. I was shocked.
     
  12. Ajax

    Ajax Well-Known Member

    3,302
    139
    63
    You should definitely get a AAA membership if you don't have it already. I get a 5% discount on my auto insurance thanks to that so the membership basically pays for itself, and you get free roadside assistance and a bunch of discounts for hotels, event tickets, car rentals etc on top of that.
     
  13. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    I PM'ed you.
     
  14. Karina1974

    Karina1974 Well-Known Member

    2,662
    228
    63
    I second that. If he ever gets in an accident your friend would be in some deep shit.

    http://www.nydmv.state.ny.us/resident.htm

     
  15. Karina1974

    Karina1974 Well-Known Member

    2,662
    228
    63
    Why would you ask someone living in MO??

    http://www.nydmv.state.ny.us/insurance.htm

     
  16. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    Because she might have a nationwide plan, and I know she's hard to insure, so perhaps she can refer me to someone who gives good rates.
     
  17. Karina1974

    Karina1974 Well-Known Member

    2,662
    228
    63

    What a "nationwide" plan?
     
  18. milanessa

    milanessa engaged to dupa

    18,917
    2,870
    0
    It's been suggested by others up thread so I'll piggyback. You need to contact an independent insurance broker - let them do all this leg/phone work.
     
  19. GarrAarghHrumph

    GarrAarghHrumph I can kill you with my brain

    16,414
    2,332
    113
    I don't know what a nationwide plan is. There is no such thing. There are insurers who operate in multiple states including NY, like State Farm. But each plan would be specific to the driver and the driver's state.

    I'm thinking Oleada is hoping that if her friend, who is a "troubled driver", is able to get a good rate in MO, that if she uses the same company in NY, her rate may be decent.

    Oleada, others have said that you need to contact an independent insurance *broker* in New York. I will emphasize that. An insurance broker doesn't work for any one insurance company, so they will give you a bunch of plans and prices to choose from, all applicable to you, your age, your driving history, your car type, your neighborhood.
     
  20. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    Yeah, that's what I meant. I'm definitely contacting an independent broker, and I'm also planning to take an online defensive driver course to lower my rates.