Nagasu- can she win or medal at the Olympics if she skates her best

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by KimGOAT, Jul 18, 2013.

  1. KimGOAT

    KimGOAT Active Member

    759
    47
    28
    I know some might laugh at this but I really think if she skates her best Mirai Nagasu could win the Olympics in 2014 or atleast medal. Her spins and spirals are better than Yu Na Kim and Caroline Kostner. Well maybe not spirals for Kostner, but spins for sure. She has all the jumps when she is at her best. Her artistry is also quite good. It is just a matter of putting it all together. It saddens me to see her beneath far less talented skaters like Wagner and Gold. Gold is really talented for the future but right now is all jumps. Wagner has nothing special about her skating. At the very least I want to see her back as U.S #1 where she belongs and top 5 in the World.
     
    PeterG and (deleted member) like this.
  2. KimGOAT

    KimGOAT Active Member

    759
    47
    28
    With her 2011 Four Continents performance Nagasu would have won gold at the 2011 Worlds. Ando did not skate as well at Worlds as she did at Four Continents, neither did Asada, and Kim didnt skate good at all at Worlds. With those performances, or her 2010 Olympic ones, Nagasu would have also won the 2010 Worlds, won silver at the 2012 Worlds, and won silver at the 2013 Worlds.
     
  3. HVS

    HVS Active Member

    204
    29
    28
    Well, if Mirai skates her best, she could medal or even win the Olympic next year

    ... AND all of others have to BOMB for that happen :lol:
     
  4. Skater91

    Skater91 Member

    118
    14
    18
    She needs to make it to Olympics first.

    But Mirai at her best is still just off the podium around 4th or 5th again.
     
  5. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    It would depend how everyone else skated. However in a totally clean Olympics (which will never happen) the #3 U.S skater will probably finish 12th or 13th behind Kim, Kostner, Asada, Gold, Wagner, Suzuki, 2 Russian girls, Murakami, Osmond, and possibly Li and/or Korpi, in roughly exactly that order too. Maybe Nagasu with how she can really shine could do better than that but only with no URs, truly sparkling out there, and a solid 3-3.
     
  6. FunnyBut

    FunnyBut Well-Known Member

    4,401
    762
    113
    Nagasu is a better spinner than Kim, but Kim is a much better jumper than Nagasu, with better skating skills and presentation. There is pretty much no chance she would beat a well skated program by Kim. She would likely not challenge a decent Kostner either, the gap in PCS is too wide. I suppose if Asada had a bad day or Kostner crumbled, Nagasu could medal.

    I still would have given the Bronze to Nagasu in Vancouver, I know that is not a popular opinion. Joannie is a better skater, but Nagasu did so much more in terms of jumps and spins, plus Nagasu skater error free and lights out, with 5 different triples (well, one of them was a flutz), and a 3-3.
     
  7. Susan M

    Susan M Well-Known Member

    1,542
    215
    63
    Well, the premise was "if she skates her best" which means no URs, none of those silly mistakes she seems prone to make on spins, and a full arsenal of triples. If she could do all that, I would place her above any other American, really, anybody but a similarly clean Kim, Kostner and Asada. When Mirai is on, she skates with a command, speed and pizzazz that none of the remaining skaters listed can match.

    Sadly, I fear most of those verbs should be in the past tense. I don't know if she will ever reach that level again.
     
  8. Jammers

    Jammers Well-Known Member

    4,082
    421
    83
    The problem is you have to continue to improve to stay relevant and Mirai not only didn't improve after 2010 but she's regressed. She's not as fast and her spins are not nearly as good as they were back then. Add the fact that you now have to have a 3-3 to be competitive and Mira doesn't have a solid 3-3 she needs to make big improvements this season just to be competitive in the US.
     
  9. olympic

    olympic Well-Known Member

    7,138
    615
    113
    I think 'regression' is the key. Mirai has not been amongst the best in the past quadrennial to set herself up for a medal at Sochi. Thus, it will take some serious attention grabbing via technical fireworks throughout the Fall to get back where she was in 2010 - speed, sparkle, and solid jumps with a 3-3 in both the SP and LP. Additionally, she will have to work hard to get on the Olympic / Worlds team at nationals. That means beating any 4 of Wagner, Gold, Czisny, Gao Zawadzki and I'm sure there will be a newbie in there somewhere, perhaps Hicks.
     
  10. munow

    munow New Member

    99
    3
    0
    No.
     
  11. Susan M

    Susan M Well-Known Member

    1,542
    215
    63
    The US gets 3 ladies. I have my doubts that Czisny will be a factor next year and Gao has been kind of a mess the lst few years. If Nagasu is skating well (which I also have my doubts about), it would likely come down to her and Zawadski for the third spot. If it's close, I don't think US judges would be inclined to send a young newbie skater to the Olympics who has not been to Worlds, unless she really impresses at her GP events. Right now (with one TDB at Skate America) the only other US lady with a senior GP assignment is Zhang (who I guess no one sees as a factor).

    Gao is an interesting case. Young as she is, she has already finished 5th at US Nationals for 4 consecutive years. Her only senior international performances of any note came last year - a 2nd place at Skate America and 4th at 4CC (5th in the FS). So, maybe she is gaining some consistency, or maybe she, Zhang & Nagasu can all get together and commiserate about the puberty monster and how good they were in their early teens.
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2013
  12. Skittl1321

    Skittl1321 Well-Known Member

    12,059
    1,399
    113
    My opinion is that if Czisny is healthy and skating remotely well, they are going to give her the 3rd spot; she's been the USFS darling for too long, and it is a wonderful recovery story.

    I just don't know if she'll be healthy.


    I don't think it is likely Nagasu takes the spot. Which makes me sad. She was so promising in the last Olympics.
     
  13. bardtoob

    bardtoob Well-Known Member

    8,229
    1,287
    113
    If Mirai has put in the work to get between the TES base of Wagner and Gold, then I think the competition for the 3rd spot will be between her and Zawadzki, with Zawadzki having the advantage, although Mirai can get better PCS from International judges. Cziny is a lovely skater and Gao is a consistent skater recently, but neither have capability any better than 6th place TES base.

    ... Mirai, on the international scene, really has the dark horse advantage. When you watch her skate, you would think she has won more.
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2013
  14. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    I actually agree with the poster who said if Czisny is in good shape and skates reasonably well they will go with her. I am not sure how likely that is, but she has nothing to lose this year so it could happen. If she isnt they will go with Zawadzki (who I dont even consider possibly skating reasonably well in the LP, I mean with her usual 3 or 4 triple performance). Unless one of Nagasu or Gao is lights out and/or Zawadzki skates even worse than usual.

    That is not what I want to believe. Ultimately I want it to go to whomever skates best at Nationals, but in general I would rather see Gao or Nagasu at the Olympics than past her best before date Czisny or Splatadzki.
     
  15. OKAERINKO

    OKAERINKO New Member

    11
    0
    0
    She can be on the podium if.....

    1.she goes GPF and get gold or silver medal at USnational next season so that judges give her more PCS
    2.she skates cleanly like 2010OG or 2011FC
    3.not everyone of Kim or Kostner or Asada skates cleanly
     
  16. sk8ingcoach

    sk8ingcoach Active Member

    460
    36
    28
    She doesnt have the momentum. Unless she places at the final, wins nationals and podium at 4CC there is no way she is coming close to olympic podium.

    We all know that she has the capability to do a program with no falls, but those jumps have to be clean. Without the momentum she will not get the PCS and without clean jumps she wont get TES.
     
  17. euterpe

    euterpe Well-Known Member

    11,908
    1,152
    113
    Mirai hasn't been "on" in a long, long time. For the past two years, she's been skating as if she were on autopilot.
     
  18. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,669
    352
    83
    I don't think so, her training situation and body have changed a lot since 2010 Olympics and even 2011 4CC when she was skating really well, and the field is deeper now than it was when she was 4th in 2010, so I just don't see it happening. Her jumps aren't the best quality and she's either lost speed or isn't using it to the best of her ability in her programs which is why, coupled with her PCS not being that high, I don't think she could do it, even though her spins are fab.
     
  19. query5

    query5 New Member

    672
    64
    0
    no
     
  20. kwanatic

    kwanatic Well-Known Member

    2,041
    476
    83
    So much of skating is about reputation and momentum and right now Mirai has neither. She has never reached the GPF and hasn't been on the podium at nationals since 2011 (3rd).

    Momentum and rep aside, I just don't think she's at the level she was back in 2010. I agree with FunnyBut in regards to Vancouver. I'm glad Joannie got the medal b/c of her situation...but Mirai outskated her in that competition. After Vancouver the door was wide open for Mirai to waltz her way to the top of the sport but she never did. Not even close. She showed two flashes of brilliance in that next season (SP at nationals, FS at 4CC) but that was it. She's had decent performances since then but none have come close to capturing the magic she had back then.

    Mirai is in the running for that 3rd spot to Sochi but I see her at the bottom of the selection pool right now. I think Agnes, Christina and Alissa all have a better shot at getting that spot right now. Agnes is the US bronze medalist for the last two years (despite her mediocre skating everywhere else), Christina is on the upswing after last season, and if Alissa is semi-decent I feel like the judges will boost her to give her that 3rd spot. The only way Mirai will leapfrog all of them is to kick ass in her GP events and light up nationals like she did back in 2010 minus the URs. She'd have to leave zero doubt in the judges' minds that she's the one for that spot.

    At her best, I do think Mirai would be a top 5 finisher in Sochi this year...but it's been so long I just don't see it happening. I really hope she proves me wrong. I'm always cheering for that girl...I've just given up on expecting greatness from her.
     
  21. AxelAnnie

    AxelAnnie Well-Known Member

    6,130
    1,045
    113
    Totally agree, and I don't see that changing. Could she win gold? Sure...all kinds of things could happen....the top ten ladies could not skate, she could fix her UR's, get some motivation, be that young bright eyed girl we all fell in love with. She veered off course somewhere. Way too many things would have to fall her way, and she would have to find her joy......and I don't see that happening.
     
  22. olympic

    olympic Well-Known Member

    7,138
    615
    113
    ^ I will say in defense of Mirai that she was working hard last year and I think her LP at Nationals was affected by illness. Even then, she didn't give up and splat in that LP (just a mess with UR's) which was par for the course the year before
     
  23. kuzytalent

    kuzytalent Active Member

    489
    90
    28
    She was also undermarked sort of. If you take away the questionable UR calls didnt she have less mistakes as far as stumbles/falls than Ashley. I think she had 2 and Ashley 3. Ashley had some jumps that looked more UR than the ones Mirai was called in but hers werent called and Mirai was.

    Gao was also very undermarked at Nationals. Judges definitely played favorites even if the top 2 and World team was probably right. I hope next years Nationals is more fair even if it means a shocker and having to leave one of Gold or Wagner at home if they dont deliver and all the others do.
     
  24. Susan M

    Susan M Well-Known Member

    1,542
    215
    63
    I think part of that is that she has made some fairly bad music choices. The right music brings out the best a skater. A lot of skaters make a mistake when they think a music selection will be good because another skater used it effectively. IMO Nagasu makes a mistake in trying to interpret softer music that obviates her strengths. She needs music that sound like it could score an adventure/action film.
     
  25. icellist

    icellist Member

    421
    25
    18
    I totally agree. I think she can benefit from Hans Zimmer's William Tell Overture from Lone Ranger or Sorcerer's Apprentice.
     
  26. kwanatic

    kwanatic Well-Known Member

    2,041
    476
    83
    ITA. I thought her SP last season was definitely a step in the right direction. Mirai was able to skate with personality and energy. She looked like she was having a little bit of fun. Unfortunately, they didn't carry that over into her FS and she ended up with yet another snoozer. It was better than Spartacus but it still wasn't a good program.

    I do think she'd benefit from bigger music, especially in the FS.
     
  27. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    Who does Mirai's choreography right now?
     
  28. kwanatic

    kwanatic Well-Known Member

    2,041
    476
    83
    Susan Austin did both of her programs last season. IDK who is doing them this season...

    I wonder when she is going to announce her music for this season?
     
  29. RockTheTassel

    RockTheTassel Well-Known Member

    1,152
    156
    63
    I don't know. I really enjoyed the first half of her Pirates SP (the Fragile Dreams part), which was a bit softer and slower. Her Memoirs of a Geisha program was also softer and lighter than a lot of her other programs, and she managed to have at least one good outing with that at 4CC. I wouldn't attribute many of her difficulties to music choice because I definitely think she's capable of using softer music. Also, some of her attempts with the more dramatic numbers haven't been successful either. Even though I personally liked it, I remember tons of complaints about her Witches of Eastwick SP. She also didn't really sell her Symphony No. 3 program last season even though it was a bigger piece. When she performed it at Nationals she had so many bobbles and most of the transitions were significantly weaker than they have been in the past. Her artistry has certainly declined, but I think her actual skating has taken a bigger turn for the worse.

    That being said, I agree that her real strength lies in the programs with more action and more concentration on creating a character instead of just trying to look pretty (such as her 2010 programs). Perhaps returning to something like a more dramatic film score would be a good choice for her this season.
     
  30. Amy03

    Amy03 Member

    252
    24
    18
    Mirai will have to pull herself together in the two gp assignment she got, and really deliver, if she wants USSF to even consider her as a serious contender for the Olympic team. she really has what it takes, she only needs to keep it together when it counts.
    but she has gotten some real harsh assignments this season, which of course isn't going to make it easier for her to medal, but one can still hope.