Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by MINAM, Oct 9, 2012.
I guess she was way more depedant on Morozov than I haver ever thought.
So is she now retired? It says 2013 is her last season. Or is she going to still make a run at Sochi? I can't see her skating next season but not trying for the Olympics.
According to the latest article, Miki said she wants to compete at 2013-2014 Japan national championships so far. She takes half a year off and then prepares for the domestic block competitions to be qualified for Japan nationals. She hasn't given up competing at Sochi, either. Anyway next season is next season. We have to wait to see what she says next autumn.
Not unless you mean tonsil hockey.
I wish Miki health and happiness, whatever she decides to do.
I can't see her being a factor if she takes this season off. That will make it over two years before she competes again. Add in factors like her age and the tough competition in Japan i think maybe she needs to just retire for good now. By the time Japan Nationals roll around in December of 2013 she will be 26 and rusty.
rusty ? isn't that a bit ageist
look at Suzuki or Leonova who are both turning 28, they are still doing good
Are you sure? Here is the GP Announcement
I only find this restriction in Section 3.4, where it only applies to seeded skaters (those who finished 1-6 at 2012 Worlds).
I'm don't know if there is an actual definition for Senior B, but qualifying scores can be posted at any international event. Looking at the ISU calendar, I counted 7 international events at the senior level between now and Japanese Nationals, but the entry deadlines are already passed for the first four. Golden Spin is probably not a practical option because it is so close to Japanese Nationals, but I don't understand why Dortmund or Merano are not options.
Oct 24-28 Cup of Nice (France)
Oct 30-Nov 4 Crystal Ice (Brasov, Romania)
Nov 6-11 IceChallenge (Graz, Austria)
Nov 15-18 Warsaw Cup (Poland)
Nov 16-18 Merano Cup (Italy) - "each National Association may entry up to two (2) competitors for the Junior and Senior categories... Entries must be sent by October 15th"
Dec 5-9 NRW Trophy (Dortmund, Germany) - "Each ISU Member has the right to nominate 3 competitors for each single event ...The entries by name should reach the organizer not later than November 4th , 2012."
Dec 13-16 Golden Spin of Zagreb (Croatia) - "Each ISU Member may enter one Competitor for Ladies and Men ...Entries must reach the Organizer not later than November 16, 2012."
IMO, it is doable if someone really wanted to make it happen. Because of all the smoke and misinformation, I'm beginning to think perhaps the real issue is that she just can't get ready in time. (It makes sense. If she can't be ready to compete at Trophy Bompard Nov 16-18, then does another week or two make much difference?)
I hope she finds something in life to interest/excite her again, whether it is skating or something else.
Leonova will only be 22 next month.
Suzuki is doing very well for her, easier to do when she was never that great to begin with. Her high is probably the last year, I doubt she will be a big medal factor by Sochi but should be on their team.
Leonova is not anywhere near 28 years old, she is much younger than Ando, but that said she will be hard pressed to even make her own countries Olympic team for Sochi.
Ando would be 26 and having not competed for over 2 years. She is no Plushenko, and even Plushenko went from dominating the Olympics to losing to Evan freaking Lysacek after taking a few years off at that age.
Jammers is right but it is pretty obvious she is easing into retirement anyway. Probably one final token appearance at the Japan Open or maybe even her own Nationals next year to wave goodbye.
Section 3.4 of the GP Announcement defines a "seeded" skater as anyone listed in paragraph 2.1, which includes:
2.1.a: Placed 1-6 at last year's World Championships
2.1.b: Any skater/team moved to a seeded position because of vacancies
2.1.c: "Come-back" Skaters/Couples previously seeded and taking the automatic two option, like Ando
3.4 states, "If any seeded skater/couple elects in advance of the Grand Prix Period not to participate in their assigned events (for whatever reason) they will not be permitted to participate in any other competitions, shows, and exhibitions during the Grand Prix Period. In addition, depending on the circumstances, these seeded skater/couple may be subject to sanctions in accordance with Rule 136, paragraph 6, of the General Regulations..."
That leaves NRW (5-9 Dec) and Golden Spin (13-16 Dec) as the only two Senior B's, i.e., international competitions including seniors. (Santa Claus Cup, also 5-9 Dec, only includes juniors and novices.)
I don't know what the qualification rules for Japanese Nationals are: five of six regions that Sylvia listed are either in progress or over. Ando did not compete in her national championships last year after winning two seasons ago; I don't know if they have byes, and, if so, if the bye criteria extend past one season.
Rule 136.6 speaks of sanctions, but isn't specific. The GP Announcement says the sanctions "may be in the form of monetary penalties" but doesn't limit them to money.
I noticed the last part of the headline, which I had missed initially. Has Miki announced that 2013 will be her last season? Why not go to another Olympics? Is it burnout/injuries? If it's not that, I don't think finding another coach would be a problem for her.
It is not like she can just choose to go to another Olympics at the last minute. She is Japanese, not Canadian. : The Japanese team is very deep, and based on 2010 they choose their teams based on performances of the last 2 years, not just the Nationals (the reason Miki herself even made the 2010 team despite placing a distant 4th at Nationals). If she even had a hope of making it she would need to skate the whole 2013-2014 season and produce great results, and then skate great at Nationals too. As it is the only GP she would even be eligible for next season probably would be a host pick.
Plushenko, though, thought he was a show skater and was in pretty bad shape, given the technical requirements, when he attempted his comeback for Vancouver, and took a crash approach in too little time. Had he had another six months, I think he would have regained his speed and taken the title.
I doubt Ando will get that badly out of shape, and the technical requirements for a top women, at least over the last few years, are not comparatively as difficult, especially with the younger Russian skaters going through growth spurts.
i don´t think so.
to be honest, miki is the only real shot alongside asada for a medal in sotchi.
she is a two time world champion and has left the scene on a very high note with a dominating season (forgetting about Japan Open afterwards).
Artistically she surely improved more and more (as it is seen in the shows); so the japanese federation would do what they can do to bring her to the olympics, if she goes for it.
surely they cannot make the same 'failure' like in 2006 but i think, they will go for her, as long she is in 'ok shape'.
I know this is off topic but I'm interested to know who the hockey player is and where you got this information.
Anyone know why Miki took last season off to begin with? Taking even one season off is not a good way to try to make it to another Olympics.
Because she won Worlds and pretty much everything else that season and wanted to rest? And a tsunami had just ravaged through her home country and likely affected much of her family and close friends?
AFAIK, Japanese federation chose their 2010 Olympic team based on the result of either 2009 Grand prix final or 2009 Japanese Nationals. (NOT the performances of the last 2 years.) Miki made the 2010 team because she was the highest among the Japanese qualifiers at 2009 Grand prix final, despite placing 4th at the Nationals.
I'm surprised to see her so affected by Morozov not coaching her. Her "pro" programs of the last 12 months or so were beautiful, some of the best she's ever done. I don't think he was involved in those, so I'm wondering why she's not more confidant to continue on without him.
I seem to recall that Morozov recommended that she take the time off? Which in hindsight...
please, come on. 10 consecutive years of international competitions.
3 junior worlds medals,
2 world titles + 1 world bronze
+ 3 more worlds top6 finishes.
she needed to take breathe and this was wisely of morozov, especially after her world title.
we knew what happened the season after her last world title 2007 ending with the drama in gothenburg. she seemed to carry a big burdon throughout the whole season.
thne, after 2011, miki surely was mentally stronger (of course because of morozov) but i think it was the right time to give her time to breathe .
if she would have come back this season, there would be no problem regarding to olympics.
but let´s face it, we can be glad to see her in one more competitve event, and that´s it
Maybe it could be the Pro-Am Medal Winners Open
oh, this would be kind of sad, there she can take part all the coming years, please, one more great free skate
At this point I'm not even sure what one event that would be.
If she is really serious about taking a run at the 2013-14 season, it would be a good idea to get Japan to send her to the team event next spring. That would give her a chance to post a qualifying score and/or a top 75 seasons best and a shot at a GP event next year.
If we don't see her ready to compete there, then I think, like so many former champs before her, she is just making sad noises about resuming her career while she copes with the idea of being done.
Separate names with a comma.