Julia Lipnitskaya's momentum ?

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by love_skate2011, Oct 26, 2013.

Can she medal in Sochi ?

  1. Yes

    201 vote(s)
    75.8%
  2. No

    32 vote(s)
    12.1%
  3. 4th place

    32 vote(s)
    12.1%
  1. kuzytalent

    kuzytalent Active Member

    489
    90
    28
    OK Gold has no presentation or anything that goes beyond strong jumps and ok spins. She may improve but right now the USFSA must be paying some good dough to get those PCS for her, even when she mistakes as well.
     
  2. RFOS

    RFOS Well-Known Member

    2,437
    624
    113
    How do you define "artistry" (I'm interested in any opinions)? The word "artistry" isn't in the PCS criteria but I think the areas that people consider "artistry" probably are captured somewhere (likewise "maturity," which I argued wasn't a judging criteria, but I think people use it as code for certain areas that could be reflected positively in the PCS. However, a certain "immaturity" or youthful exuberance can be fun to watch and interpret certain types of program better than "maturity" would, and valuing "maturity" in and of itself seems biased against younger or young-looking skaters. I don't see how "artistry" could be a negative, or even "not positive" in the PCS though).

    I disagree with those who say Gracie doesn't have good presentation though. She's not flawless or up with the all-time greats in that respect by any means at this point, but I think her presentation is generally quite good.
     
  3. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    Gold has improved her posture and her arm movements are much softer. Both of her programs have a lot of upper body movement throughout and some transitions also. Her basic skating is very decent as well.

    It's a weasel word which means everything and nothing. That's precisely the problem.
     
  4. Dr.Siouxs

    Dr.Siouxs Well-Known Member

    8,518
    1,767
    113
    Well she's 18. Angela Nikodinov, Joannie Rochette, Brian Boitano, Shizuka Awakawa were all rather bland and awkward skaters at that age as well.
     
  5. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    1,124
    102
    0
    Fortunately? I would love to have some kind of an "artistic impression" score in the judging. Subjective, I know, blah, blah, but without it, we end up with dull or simply dreadful programs like V/T's JCS winning medals and titles. You can interpret or "sell" a terrible program convincingly, but that doesn't make that program artistic in any way.
     
  6. Robeye

    Robeye Curiously curious

    411
    76
    28
    I would put it somewhat differently. Artistry is an architectonic word in skating, fundamentally necessary, without which most of the PCS program becomes an arbitrary grab-bag of unrelated features that has no internal logic and coherence, no fundamental justification or ground whatever.

    What "artistry" is not, however, is an operational criteria which is directly applied by judges in PCS scoring. That happens at a higher level of granularity, as represented by the component definitions and bullet points.

    IMO, any serious reading of the IJS bullets shows that the only thing that gives meaning and sense to a very large proportion of the bullets for P/E, I, and C is the concept of artistry (and specifically as a second cousin of dance, in the way that whales are taxonomically related to hippos).
     
  7. Marco

    Marco Missing Ziggy

    11,566
    1,407
    113
    I am warming up to her after Skate Canada. Not even the short program music bothers me.

    The choreographic sequence though, shows exactly what she lacks - maturity and attention to detail.
     
  8. Marco

    Marco Missing Ziggy

    11,566
    1,407
    113
    Weren't we this excited about Sot and Tuk about 3 years ago? Time will tell.

    I would love more competition from Osmond, Gold, Cesario, Edmunds, Chen, Li etc. Some of the Japanese and Korean juniors look promising too. Dominance can't be exciting.
     
  9. giselle23

    giselle23 Active Member

    623
    166
    43
    Yu Na had 2 mistakes in her long program in 2011--the singled flip and also, she popped the second jump on her 3sal(?)-2t combo. This, by the way, is my favorite performance by Yu Na, despite the mistakes.
     
    Last edited: Nov 1, 2013
  10. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    I see what both of you are saying.

    My point is: There are words with more precise meanings relating to the 'presentation' aspect of programs. To give a few examples: Coherence, concept, purpose, creativity, originality. If you use one of those words, it puts you on a similar page and you can then make arguments for and against, facilitating discussion.

    If you say 'artistry,' I don't even know what you mean.
     
  11. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    You are right, I forget the singled double salchow at the end of the combination. So that was a 3rd mistake, albeit seemingly minor. Ironically given the margin of defeat that almost certainly cost her the gold medal too.

    Artistically it was my favorite LP of hers ever probably, although I also really liked Miss Saigon in the 07-08 season. My favorite programs of her overall are her 06-07 Tango short program and her James Bond short program though.
     
  12. cbd1235

    cbd1235 Well-Known Member

    754
    284
    63
    Julia Lipnitskaya should soar onto the Sochi podium if the panel is like this weekend's Rostelecom panel. On my HD TV I could very clearly see her underrotated first triple lutz and first double axel (the axel in particular left a full 180 degree mark on the ice), both of which were not called < but were called clean. Very disappointed.

    It is also clear she is being anointed based on her very large PCS for a very flawed FS. The PCS jump from SC to COR with a strikingly similar SP is also alarming.

    ETA: it's not just the calling on Julia's FS that was out of whack. There were all kinds of underrotated triples in the ladies event that were called clean. And very questionable calls across all events. Seriously the worst judging I have ever witnessed in the entire COP era.
     
    Last edited: Nov 23, 2013
  13. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,396
    839
    113
    Well, it seems that Julia actually climbed over Kostner's level. ;)
     
  14. elif

    elif Active Member

    532
    240
    43
    There is a stupid rule about 1/4 cheating is allowed for jumps. :scream: They didn't downgraded Mao's jumps because of this rule too.:rolleyes: I can understand maybe 1/8, but this 1/4 just so much. :scream:
     
  15. shine

    shine Well-Known Member

    4,467
    556
    113
    Really? This is Joannie at 17: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAIbF0d51fE Gold's presentation has a way to go compared to this IMO.
     
    Last edited: Nov 23, 2013
  16. cbd1235

    cbd1235 Well-Known Member

    754
    284
    63
    I agree, Mao has been credited with one or two badly underrotated Triple Axels this season. Disappointed. But the worst judging was Rostelecom. Everything else all season was not bad, just a few blips of madness like Mao's axel calls. Then this event went haywire...
     
  17. elif

    elif Active Member

    532
    240
    43
    Some other triple jumps of Mao should get < too. You can watch her NHK skate and see she is just turning on the ice like Lipnistkaia at COR. Why we have ''you can cheat 1/4'' rule? :wall: Skaters already getting benefit of doubt -rightfully-:confused:
     
  18. lahaa968

    lahaa968 Active Member

    181
    48
    28
    Hmm, Kostner scored 68 for PCS, Lipnitskaia 63 (controversially so)...that's a 5-point margin.

    More subjectively, there are dimensions between Kostner and Lipnitskaia. Kostner has the speed, flow, maturity, musicality, and choreography that you just can't convey as a 15 year old, and Lipnitskaia may have flow, but she doesn't have Kostner's speed and not near the level of interpretation. Even then, Oksana Baiul was a wonderful performer who became the music, but Lipnitskaia is certainly no Baiul and especially no Kostner. This is ladies figure skating, not "little girls".

    To think the 2013 World Men's title was won by a point or so...
     
  19. IceAlisa

    IceAlisa Épaulement!!!

    31,195
    4,434
    113
    No doubt, Kostner does have speed, maturity, etc. but choreography? Where is choreography in her free skate? I was looking and didn't find any? Where are the transitions?
     
  20. Blondie12

    Blondie12 New Member

    402
    25
    0
    Julia's body will change in a year or two just like Elizaveta's did, she is fortunate in that she is peaking right at the right time, Elizaveta's is a year late

    That said, I am not sure how much a factor Julia will be in the future. She has a great chance to medal this year but will this turn into a Carolina Zhang situation where her body changes and she can't do those jumps? I suppose Caroline had bad technique to begin w but I think managing the transition from being pre teen to being a women is tricky. For some it never struck me that the body changed that much (like Rachael flatt) while for others like Elizaveta's or Caroline it was a very obvious (and sometimes quick) change. And we all know how that turned out,
     
  21. Cheylana

    Cheylana Well-Known Member

    4,982
    967
    113
    Not necessarily. Julia reminds me of Cohen - tiny, skinny, bendy. Cohen never seemed to hit puberty, Julia could follow the same path.
     
    hanca and (deleted member) like this.
  22. koatcue

    koatcue New Member

    75
    5
    0
    That's what Tarasova said! The 1st time she saw her was in 2011 and she said then that Julia had a unique body type she only saw on Cohen
     
  23. IceAlisa

    IceAlisa Épaulement!!!

    31,195
    4,434
    113
    Here's hoping.
     
  24. Marco

    Marco Missing Ziggy

    11,566
    1,407
    113
    Extreme flexibility often leads to instability in jumping - think Cohen and Czisny, or even Nagasu and Zhang. And it's not like Lip had such good technique to begin with. I don't think she will grow a lot, but her technique will likely go to whack when she gets nervous (like at COR).
     
  25. Vash01

    Vash01 Fan of Julia, Elena, Anna, Liza, and Vera

    26,863
    4,052
    113
    I find these negative predictions rather amusing, particularly comparisons with Caroline Zhang. How many GPs did Caroline win? It takes more than flexibility to win, and Julia has already shown that she is a competitor. Nobody can really predict what will happen in a few years. I would like Julia to skate two great programs in Sochi just to silence the critics. I don't want her to win the OGM because her motivation may not be as intense as it is now, but any other color medal in Sochi will be great.
     
  26. Sasha'sSpins

    Sasha'sSpins Well-Known Member

    3,762
    328
    83
    Sonja Henie. :D
     
  27. t.mann

    t.mann New Member

    256
    11
    0
    Watching the COR judging, [Russia at Sochi : team(gold), pairs(gold), men(bronze), ladies(silver), dance(bronze)] results do not look unrealistic.
    Putin & RSF seem to want an all-discipline(event)-podium.
     
  28. VarBar

    VarBar Well-Known Member

    1,253
    211
    63
    :lol:

    Whatever Putin wants, Putin gets, make no mistake about it.:sekret:;)
     
  29. dinakt

    dinakt Well-Known Member

    3,903
    818
    113
    I think a Russian on podium in Men's is not realistic ( the rest would have to make major mistakes). The rest, doable; though Ladies' Bronze is more likely.
    As for Lipnitskaya momentum- I had my doubts early this year, but yes, she got it. If she is on podium on GPF ( very likely), and even bigger one. If she wins GPF, then sky's the limit.
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2013
  30. KimGOAT

    KimGOAT Active Member

    759
    47
    28
    I think a Russian mens bronze is possible. Other than Chan everyone has been inconsistent so far this season. I wouldnt favor a Russian man for a medal now (whoever that man is) but could see a surprise medal potentially all the same.