Irina Slutskaya's triple-triples video

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by bartek, Dec 29, 2010.

1. bartekMember

243
22
18
Hi, last year I posted link to my video with Irina's triple-triples. I found some new combination, added them to my video and upload it again. Here is the link http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxFjlJpi5MY

Please watch, comment and share. Hope you like it. If you know some other combos of Irina's please let me know so that I can add them to the video. I know she attempted 3sal-3loop at 1996 Lalique though I can't find the video.

Tomorrow I will probably upload two new videos: one with Miki Ando's triple-triples and second one with all her quads attempts.

2. DomshabfanA proud P/C fan

6,869
1,917
113
In the video, before each jump combination you have calculate the points for each jump combination, is that actually correct base value since I think each jump combination actually get 10% bonus added to the sum of each jump done alone.

ETA: my bad, there is no bonus for combinaton it seems, but i some how seems to remember reading that among several approved proposal at the last congress

Last edited: Dec 29, 2010
3. HisWeirnessTAT-wannabe

11,876
1,829
113
ISU Rule 353:

Jump combinations are evaluated as one unit by adding the base values of the jumps included and applying the GOE with the numerical value of the most difficult jump.

Jump sequences are evaluated as one unit by adding the base values of the two highest value jumps, multiplying the result by 0.8 and after that applying the GOE with the numerical value of the most difficult jump.

The 10% bonus for combinations has been proposed, but never passed into the rules by the ISU Congress.

4. DomshabfanA proud P/C fan

6,869
1,917
113
Thanks, i relasied that when i went through GP protocols. anyway that would have been a fair thing to do

5. bartekMember

243
22
18
I didn't know how to call her combo from Russian Nats 2002-2003. It would be 3S+3L+1L+2S so base value would be 11,20, more than for 3Lz+3L but I think that four jumps combinations are not allowed under IJS so my question is, wether whole combination would be counted as an invalid element or just last jump - 2S?

Last edited: Dec 29, 2010
6. smarts1Well-Known Member

2,362
411
83
The whole thing is invalid.

7. robinhoodActive Member

796
227
43
thanx for the video!
Irina was a great jumper, probably the best European lady ever but more than half of those attempts wouldn't be ratified today

8. pinky166#teamtrainwreck

17,140
5,085
113
I love Slutskaya. Adelina jumps just like her, it's exciting!

9. all_emptyWell-Known Member

1,514
533
113
Triple-triple combos with loops on the end can cause terrible hip injuries if over-trained, but Irina attempted them throughout her entire career.

I thought her cleanest attempts came in 1997 and 2006 - an impressive 9 years apart.

As varied as Irina's combinations were (3S+3Lo, 3T+3T, 3Lz+3Lo), I think Miki Ando has landed more *different* types of triple-triples (3Lz+3Lo, 3F+3Lo, 3T+3Lo, 3T+3T). Not sure she's ever landed a 3S+3Lo, but she likely has.

10. ExcidraWell-Known Member

1,518
164
63
I love Irina.

11. bartekMember

243
22
18
Miki landed 3S+3L at 2004 Skate America (in the free skate) but it was so severely underrotated it looks almost like a double, it was like Kwan's attempt at 3Lz+3L. I included this 3S+3L in my video with Miki's triple-triples but since it's very long (10 and a half minute) it takes long time to upload it. By tomorrow it will have been uploaded.

12. NekatiiviWell-Known Member

1,354
97
48
I am actually shocked how bad most of those second triples were. There were not many which would have been ratified nowadays.

13. judgejudy27Well-Known Member

13,907
1,061
113
Yeah I tend to agree. Although in fairness to her in the early years of COP she had everyone of her triple-triples ratified.

14. ScreenieActive Member

908
78
28
i think the biggest difference between hers and mikis are that mikis are more rotated more often. but i prefer someone who tries 3/3's to those who don't. so major props for doing it and winning worlds along the way.

15. wonderlenNew Member

600
22
0
Mikis triple triple are definitely more rotated and has better landing and flow out of them and look way more impressive and explosive. Irina jumps come to almost completely stop after the Loop, but her attempts at the latter years of her career improve alot (2005 World, 2005 COR). Kudo for both of them for pushing the technical bar. Isn't Irina is the first lady to land the 3Lz+3Lo???

16. Sasha'sSpinsWell-Known Member

4,238
928
113
ITA. Also, Irina often 'telegraphed' her jumps which was the only thing I could not stand about them. Other than that I LOVED her athleticism. She truly was an awesome jumper for her day.

PeterG and (deleted member) like this.
17. taf2002Gardening maven

17,819
8,150
113
I never saw one of hers that was rotated on the 2nd jump.

18. bartekMember

243
22
18
2005 Worlds was rotated enough to be counted as a triple-triple and Russian Nats 2000-2001 could have been rotated as well though I can't really tell because of the ankle.

19. briancoogaertWell-Known Member

12,910
1,892
113
Yes, at 2000 GPF.
Her combo was not perfect, but was considered as the first 3Lz/3Loop ever ratified.

20. DreamSkatesWell-Known Member

1,372
579
113
Interesting video. I remember her as a better jumper than I now see in the videos. But Kudos to her for going after the hard jump combos. Some looked successful, more often not fully rotated on second jump or a fall. She was a fierce competitor!

21. MarcoWell-Known Member

12,905
3,228
113
In hindsight, if she had stuck with just the 3toe3toe, I believe she could have been even more successful at the world championships.

22. judgejudy27Well-Known Member

13,907
1,061
113
She probably would have won the 2000 Worlds with just a 3 toe-3 toe since that panel was clearly wanting one of the Russian ladies to win, and Butyrskaya had already mucked up her performance. The 2001 Worlds? Not sure really, only if the overall performance was much better than it was that night.

2002 and 2006 Olympics she probably should have gone in with that plan. That is all she would have needed to win, if that.

23. bartekMember

243
22
18
That's right but she was more ambitious and went for difficult combos with loop at the end. It's likely that the judges would have given her the gold at 2001 Worlds just for 3S+3L+2T but again she was more ambitious and wanted to land two very difficult 3+3+2 combinations! There aren't many ladies who could even dream about 3Lz+3L including Yu-na Kim and Mao Asada.

24. pinky166#teamtrainwreck

17,140
5,085
113
^^ Um, Mao did 3f-3lo regularly in her jumping prime, so I'm sure she was capable of 3(f)lz-3lo as well, especially considering her 3f really looks like a 3lz due to the way she preps for it. Right now, no, I don't think she could pull it off, but a few years ago she most certainly could.

25. all_emptyWell-Known Member

1,514
533
113
Correct, when she first burst onto the scene her jump layout was 3Lz+3Lo, 3F, 2A in the short, and 3Lz+3Lo in the free.

In regards to Slutskaya, I think I remember her saying loop combinations came earlier to her, similar to Miki Ando.

26. El ReyWell-Known Member

1,872
323
83
Maybe. But her reputation could also have been hurt. She was probably helped by being known as the great athlete that attempted very difficult triple-triples. If all she ever had planned was the same jump content as Michelle, would they have gone with Irina if they both landed the same jumps? IMO, without the triple-triples, the only thing she did better than Michelle was skater faster.

27. robinhoodActive Member

796
227
43
She was a far better spinner, too. And her jumps, had double the size of Michelle's. Sorry, but at their best I find Irina much more exciting to watch than Kwan IMO. Kwan didn't have any standout choreography after 98, and that was supposed to be her advantage over someone as "sloppy" as

28. bartekMember

243
22
18
Technically Irina was far superior to Kwan in their prime. Her jumps were way higher and more powerful and this was what built Irina's reputation as sensational jumper, beside her difficult triple-triples. She had some difficult transitions before some of her jumps too, e.g. before lutz and loop, or axel in SPs. Irina was also far better spinner, some of her 6.0 spins could be given higher level than 1 under CoP what is rare for 6.0 spins. Quality of her spins was better as well. Irina was also faster across the ice than Michelle. The only techinal thing which Michelle did better was spirals. Of course artistry is another issue but for me Irina's exuberance was her artistry.

29. judgejudy27Well-Known Member

13,907
1,061
113
It is difficult to say I guess. However at the peak of their rivalry in 2000-2002 Irina tended to be given higher technical marks than Kwan even when they landed similar (on occasion even less for Irina) jump content and/or made similar mistakes. Whether that was deserved or not is open for debate but that tended to be the case. So I think Irina could definitely outscore Kwan on the technical mark with just a triple toe-triple toe if that is what both did. Whether she would be able to win overall combined with the presentation mark with both doing the triple toe-triple toe is another issue.

I think at the 2000 Worlds even though Kwan's performance was amazing and should have been virtually unbeatable in the long program phase atleast, the judges were expecting to place Irina and Maria in the top 2 and Michelle 3rd (it was a very Eurocentric panel and Kwan didnt have the momentum at that point either). So if Irina had done the triple toe-triple toe only that year but skated cleanly she would have won for sure IMO. Well as long as Maria also didnt skate cleanly in the long program that is which of course she didnt.

At the 2001 Worlds I am not nearly as sure. I think that is a harder call to what the judges would have done. As someone else said if she had stayed the course after just landing the triple salchow-triple loop-double toe (a harder combination than Michelle's) she probably had a good chance though, but then she tried for even more and messed up her performance somewhat and lost.

30. El ReyWell-Known Member

1,872
323
83
How did Michelle and Irina skate at their first head to head during the 1999-2000 season? It seems like they both skated at Skate Canada and Irina won. Did Michelle skate badly? If that was one of Irina's first competition during her comeback year, and if they both skated well then that could probably tell us how the judges would have marked her without a reputation as the more technical athlete.

I say that IMO the only thing that Irina did better, without any debate, is that she was a faster skater.

They both had good ice coverage.
Irina was a faster spinner and had some interesting spins, but Michelle was not an inadequate spinner either and she had great positions. Irina had the Bielmann spins, but they tended to travel. Michelle was able to show off her flexibility with her Y-spin.

Irina had awesomely huge jumps, but she also tended to telegraph and come to a stand still on the landings. Michelle had beautiful landings and flow out her jumps.