If you were a bookie, who would you make favourite for the Ice Dance Olympic gold?

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by Maofan7, Oct 21, 2013.

?

If you were a bookie, who would you make favourite for the Ice Dance Olympic gold?

Poll closed Nov 21, 2013.
  1. Davis & White

    155 vote(s)
    72.1%
  2. Virtue & Moir

    58 vote(s)
    27.0%
  3. Other

    2 vote(s)
    0.9%
  1. volunteer

    volunteer Member

    Joined:
    Feb 28, 2013
    Messages:
    176
    Golightly, I admire your persistence, I don't know how many times you have patiently explained your views as to why you question the scoring of DW and VM, yet in doing that, you're being criticized for being too analytical and using politics as an excuse to dismiss DW.
     
  2. parapluies

    parapluies Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Dec 8, 2012
    Messages:
    996
    They eventually won the FD after a scoring mistake was corrected, but Scott fell in the SD, so I'm not sure what could have been done there?


    They had a lift deduction, or they would have won the FD as well.


    So you're saying that basically since the start of their senior career (2008 was only their second senior worlds) that everyone has been conspiring against them? Seriously? They won the Olympics (by a pretty healthy margin), they won two world titles and 4 other world medals.[/QUOTE]

    That's what I was saying even with fall, Scott and Tessa would've won because of hometown advantage if there is a people politicking hard for them. Even with 2010 and the lift deductions - If the Canadian fed was politicking for V/M, why wasn't V/M PCS inflated so they could've won FD also? Whatever politcking system for V/M everyone are talking about is either 1) Not functioning properly 2)does not exist. Recent trends have forced me to believe the latter.
     
  3. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    Fair enough. Those are the things you value and those are your opinions. I don't see anything wrong with D/W's lift execution (this season way better than V/M's), I don't get why upper body movement is a bad thing and I don't see the lack of lower body movement. But I'm not an expert. Dependence and partnering? Both awesome by D/W. Distance and posture is what we could discuss, although there are so many teams whose distance and posture is so much worse than D/W's. Is it better by V/M? Maybe, not necessarily.

    Being fast, having a great flow, making everything look light and effortless - is it not a part of skating skills? And Meryl and Charlie do change direction in their twizzles. And they have a more difficult entry. And Tessa and Scott have been insecure and sloppy on their twizzles lately, hence the lower GOE.
     
  4. Whitneyskates

    Whitneyskates Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 20, 2012
    Messages:
    1,009
    You are correct, Bourneandkraatzfan, and I apologize for any generalizations I made.
     
  5. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    This is what I was referring to:

    They didn't say they blame the SCORING SYSTEM, they said they could not understand why D/W's scores were so high for what they were showing on the ice. It was only later when they admitted they did get what D/W were getting the scores for, just overall didn't agree with what the system is rewarding.

    Now give me a break and stop treating me like I'm delusional. I'm not.
     
  6. centerstage01

    centerstage01 Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    May 25, 2002
    Messages:
    2,041
    Okay, here's my question. If D/W are having such issues and aren't following the rules, why wouldn't their coaches correct this? I mean, they've got the same coaches as V/M so it's not as though such things couldn't be seen especially as they train together. And the judges and coaches are almost always talking to each other so you know someone would have had to have brought it up. Or USFS officials? They know the rule book and if, during Champs Camp for example, these errors were so blatant, why not tell them? D/W are hard workers and I don't doubt would be specifically focusing on improving aspects that were pointed out, just as I'm sure V/M would do the same if their coaches or Canadian officials had problems with one or both programs.
     
  7. m_chenning

    m_chenning New Member

    Joined:
    Aug 5, 2010
    Messages:
    138
  8. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    Mia, I was actually comparing Carmen's twizzles versus ND's. Just to clarify. I conceded that this year, and at Worlds last season, twizzles were, indeed, sloppy. Again, it's on my previous posts. Upper body movement isn't a bad thing, it's the excess to hide the weaknesses in knee action what's a bad thing. It's the constant posing what's a bad thing. Dependence, Mia, is not a good thing in dancing. See, it's partnering what you need. You cannot depend on your partner, you have to work with him, which brings me to lift execution AGAIN. Since you don't like pictures, I will refrain from using them, but most of the time, White carries Davis like a sack, hunches his back, rotates her while she is off-center and off-balance, she doesn't provide enough core or strength to help her partner carry her weight. That results in Meryl often being at an angle while poor Charlie tries to right her. It is not pretty, but, they get the job done. They do the lift. But, those who apply a better technique should not be rewarded for it? That's when I criticize the GOE. Another thing, positions. There are teams who hold different positions during lifts, Davis and White do not. They hold just the one. Those other teams should, provided the execution is clean, get better GOE. Those teams with worse distance and posture aren't two-time World champions.
     
  9. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    Er, I wasn't aware I was doing that. Sorry if I did, though.
     
  10. walei

    walei Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2004
    Messages:
    1,330
    I'm not sure if this question is rhetorical...but lack of skating skills and element execution? Look at those various shoot the duck positions where Meryl shows no core strength and had to hang out to Charlie with her arm muscles for instance...

    Or are you trying to say those lack of features that Golightly and others pointed out are not mistakes or not a representation of poor execution so the judges shouldn't mark them down?

    ETA: I'm not saying Davis/White have no skating skills at all and shouldn't even be skating because they do have their strengths. I am saying compare to other teams at the top with not only V/M, it seems D/W are awarded with top scores when it's obvious their executions and skating edgeworks aren't top notch to receive those scores comparatively.
     
  11. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    Then I must have misunderstood what you meant by "dependence". I thought you have to depend on each other as partners. That's how I understood.
     
  12. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    Because these are not issues you can fix now. It's like your footwork. You cannot change it overnight. These are basics, these are things you learn when you are 7 and begin to skate or to dance. The sad thing is that with their power, they'd be incredible with better foundation, I have no problem saying that. I know Meryl has tried to use better posture, I have seen her try. But then, past minute one, they start running again and forget all about the details and focus on getting each element done. I am sorry, but that is not dancing. Yes, I am old school, maybe it is that, but that is not dancing.
     
  13. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    No, that's partnering. Dependence is a big no in dancing school, you always must be there with your partner. Even if he's tall and strong, you help him lift you, never left him do the work alone. That results in bad positions, transitions, and posture. For D-W, it is that LAST position what counts, that's they one they get. All the things that happen between the mount and that final position are NOT paid enough attention. That's lift technique. All I am saying is that those with better technique should be properly rewarded.
     
  14. parapluies

    parapluies Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Dec 8, 2012
    Messages:
    996
    :scream: Charlie always looks like He's about to drop Meryl everytime he lifts her its so scary. I would would be just as terrified a Meryl's face is in this screencap if Charlie was lifting me.
     
  15. ~tapdancer~

    ~tapdancer~ Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2006
    Messages:
    5,083
    I do want to bring up something...some of you were not around on this board back in 2007 when D/W and V/M came on the senior circuit. D/W got a pretty fair amount of criticism back in the day from non-ubers on here, some of it justifiable, some of it just downright mean. Time went on and D/W really began to address their weaknesses and the gold medals started to come. V/M came on to the senior circuit very strong and I honestly remember them being so smooth and lovely skating Valse Triste. That same year D/W did Polevetsian Dances. The differences were obvious then...V/M had smooth edges, lovely flow and a beautiful connection. D/W were fast (though definitely not as fast as they became) and had an exciting power to their skating. It really was apples and oranges at that time. What impresses me about D/W is how they worked on every aspect of their skating through the years and it is obvious to me that they have improved tremendously from then until now. While there are still non-ubers who don't feel that they are the best in the world, the criticism faded quite a bit over the years and most of the time, D/W's skating and improvement is appreciated. If things had not changed, if V/M had continued to be placed above D/W every time they skated against one another (which is how it was in the beginning), obviously things would be different. The rivalry would not exist and I don't believe that would have been a good thing for either team. I have enjoyed the rivalry and yes, I quickly became an uber for D/W and have enjoyed seeing them on top of the podium. Both teams have fought hard to be on top and I feel that its been difficult for the judges through the years, they recognize both teams' strengths and the fact that they went Gold and Silver in their first Olympics was really phenomenal and a testament to their hard work and also the direction that ice dance seemed destined to take. It hasn't made everyone happy but I think it's been good for ice dance. As long as D/W and V/M continue to keep their skating strong, there will be the rivalry and someone's got to lose. And that means there will be unhappy ubers. But trying to convince others who don't think the sun rises and sets on your favorite team seems futile to me and no amount of discussion about the technical/artistic/whatever aspect of their skating will change minds. Guess it can make good discussion but when you are passionate about a team...well, that doesn't work too well, does it?
     
    Kaffeine and (deleted member) like this.
  16. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    I am not trying to change anyone's mind as I am sure you aren't trying to change mine. We both agree that isn't happening. But we can both talk about the things we find problematic about the skating of opposing teams. In fact, these discussions should happen more. Often, everyone is in their own thread and we never get to talk. I think, for once, we are doing it, and frankly and without insult or snark (well, mostly). I think that's cool, after all we are all fans of the same sport. At the end of the day, as someone mentioned above, whatever happens, everyone will move on with their lives.
     
  17. iNap

    iNap Active Member

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2012
    Messages:
    184
    for the good of FSU it is better to stay in uber treads :D not all want to read this pages and pages of skating guru nonsense are you going to make new titles?:rofl:

    this tread turn in to throll parties :eek:
     
  18. walei

    walei Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2004
    Messages:
    1,330
    I don't think we want to convince you that you should like V/M more or vice versa. I can see why people find D/W are more enjoyable because their programs are dynamic and crowd pleasing. However what we are discussing is the scoring of a athletic sporting event and why we think or don't think, with our understanding of the rules, backed up by evidence, teams are getting the marks the deserve.

    So then I want to ask you tapdancer, do you agree/disagree/no comment on various analysis here on why D/W shouldn't be getting the highest GOE and PCS.
     
  19. dansk8ie

    dansk8ie New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 6, 2012
    Messages:
    1
    First and last post!
    Have some of these people seen Virtue Moir skate lately? They are clearly not the team they used to be in 2010. There is a lot amiss. It is getting quite easy to see their flaws as more time goes by. It was really conspicuous in the Carmen at World's. It started creeping in right after they came back from that break in 2011. Davis and White surpassed them in many aspects of skating. And then Shpilband left. Making twizzle errors, issues with step sequences, issues with lifts, spins. I've even seen some ubers say that the slow spins were choreographed by Virtue and Moir to demonstrate how tender he was being to her. If you don't want to see all this, go back and live in your happy world. In order to be ahead, you have to perform the entire program and just because one lift was great or if they got the twizzles right one time, it is not going to be enough to give them the lead. And yes, this is a sport, if it was art you would be watching exhibition programs all day where they can remove all the elements that give them trouble. At the end of the day, the uberness is getting in the way of acknowledging that Davis and White are a superior team.
    Watching and comparing snippets of videos and screenshots all day do nothing to help any argument, where the credential-less people involved are extremely biased and blinded by their own self-certified greatness. Bullying everyone into getting the response you want is not going to change reality!
     
    Last edited: Nov 8, 2013
    carolina and (deleted member) like this.
  20. ~tapdancer~

    ~tapdancer~ Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Jan 28, 2006
    Messages:
    5,083
    Couldn't have said it better myself, dansk8ie. That summed it up perfectly.
     
  21. walei

    walei Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2004
    Messages:
    1,330
    So we use those snippets of videos and screenshots to bring D/W's supposed superior ice dancing skills into discussion, and and instead of addressing those photographic evidences head on and tell us "no those are GREAT techniques because of X and Y", your rebuttle is V/M uber are blind, V/M makes mistakes on twizzles and slower spins than D/W. Nice deflection to avoid answering.

    You, tapdancer or any D/W fans don't have to say you agree, but then I would like to know why because time and time again us V/M fan are the ones labeled crazy and blind.

    In the end this is a really simple question for you to answer if it's as clear as day but still I see no one has tackle this question head on. Take V/M out of the equation then. In what way are those snippets of videos are screenshots showing good ice dancing skills from D/W to warrant +3 GOEs and high 9s and 10s in PCS? That's what we don't get and we must be crazy to not get it and because of that we want to discuss it with you who see D/W's being superior.
     
  22. rustyskater

    rustyskater Member

    Joined:
    Mar 8, 2005
    Messages:
    110
    One who can't see the forest for the trees has typically become so focused on details that he or she begins to ignore the overall situation.
     
  23. Susan M

    Susan M Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2004
    Messages:
    1,499
    This is not correct on several points.

    "Change of pose for lifted partner" is considered when assigning levels, not GOE, and there are different options for getting levels. A change of pose is a way of getting level 2 or 3 and pretty much necessary for Level 4. However, there is no reward for multiple position changes. The rules do not give more levels for more changes of pose after the first change. (ISU Communication 1677). Since Davis/White regularly get Level 4 on their lifts, I think they must be doing a change of pose.

    The guidance on assigning GOE does not mention position changes at all, so you are wrong to think multiple position changes are needed for high GOE on lifts.
     
  24. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    I never said they are needed, that is the problem. I said should get them more GOE. I already mentioned the things the system rewards and why I do not think that's is enough. I do not think COP is above critique? I think there are teams who are more ambitious and COP doesn't reward them for it. But since skating skills are part of the PCS, you would think certain technical attributes should be rewarded there. They are not.

    As for the bully comment above, dude. You say this is a sport, then people talk about specifics about the sport and you called them, what was it, "self-credentialed"? So only judges have the right to offer their take through the scoring? And no one has the right to ask questions about how the system works because if you do, you are... bullying? Alrighty then.
     
    Last edited: Nov 8, 2013
  25. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    If you look at GOE's marking guide, it doesn't say anything about whether the position is "pretty" or "balletic" or whatever you want the positions to be.

    Here's what GOE rewards:
    - entry/exit - it's not about whether it's pretty, but whether it's "controlled", "smooth" and "with ease"
    - ascent/descent - effortless, floating
    - stability
    - change of pose - again, "effortless", "smooth", "flowing". Not "pretty" or "artistic"
    - rotation technique - says it all
    - change of curve

    The last two are very technical and have nothing to do with the actual pose. Actually if you look at all of this, none of it has anything to do with the pose. GOE awards if the lift is effortless, smooth, if the rotation is flowing and fast, if the lift is solid and not shaky. Not if the poses are artistic.

    Thus, none of your screenshots actually prove anything regarding Meryl and Charlie's lift GOE.

    You can hate the system for it, but that's the way it is. I get the impression that many of you simply miss the oldschool ice dance and try to fit D/W into those standards, but that's not the way to go. Meryl and Charlie are CoP kids and you cannot blame them for making the most of it. i for one also miss the way ice dance used to be, but that era is over. You either deal with it and learn to enjoy ice dance as it is today, or you simply shouldn't bother at all, because all it's gonna do to you is cause your frustration.

    Having said all of that I believe Meryl and Charlie's lifts this season are beautiful and even if ND lifts had their moments of awkwardness, it's definitely not the case this season.
     
    Cyn and (deleted member) like this.
  26. Golightly

    Golightly Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2010
    Messages:
    1,232
    I believe they do. See below.

     
  27. Whitneyskates

    Whitneyskates Well-Known Member

    Joined:
    Oct 20, 2012
    Messages:
    1,009
    The only lift I have a problem with is their upside down lift. I feel some things could be cleaned up if they're going to keep it, like perhaps a new exit. I don't really like how she's sort of on his back
     
  28. mia joy

    mia joy New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 9, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    I actually like the exit so it's a matter of taste. I am actually more of a fan of the second position of this lift (when he rotates and she's in the split position :swoon:)
     
  29. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2002
    Messages:
    14,032
    Is it bullying to say skater(s) don't have transitions, or cheats their jumps, lacks unison in sbs spins, flutzes, has windmill arms, etc? During the early days of CoP there were lots of civil conversations about technik and even politiks.... Denkova and Belbin had ugly positions, Navka was all posing with no steps, DelSchoes were underrated for their transitions and basics, GrushGons were called itchy and scratchy...
     
  30. Subway

    Subway New Member

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2011
    Messages:
    348
    Another area where the sport is lazy or frightened is that VM are the ones who are raising the standard of ice dance by demonstrating what can be done with dance and skating. Playing with three different speeds on their twizzles, exiting a twizzle set with a sustained edge that they arrest in unison are just two examples. In the past, when a skater or skating team has raised the standard, the sport acknowledged this by redefining the highest level upwards. No longer does a triple toe loop merit the highest level in a jumping pass when a skater has demonstrated a triple triple is possible, or a triple lutz. The sport never said, very nice, but let's keep giving highest base value to that triple toe loop executed by itself.

    But that's what we have in ice dance. We have the equivalent of a clean triple toe loop getting valued as highly as a clean triple triple, with only the GOE setting one above the other. If the triple triple landing gets stuck on the back end, it gets a lesser score than the triple toe loop, even if, on top of this, the entrance to the 3/3 is more difficult than the entrance to the solo triple. And the fans of the skater who does the solo triple point and say the other skater is sloppy and the solo jumper is superior.

    The scoring system allows for this in ice dance, and that's one of the issues with ice dance's legitimacy today. The other problem isn't embedded in the system, but how it's applied. If a team is sloppy in multiple aspects of their skating, but they choreograph to make it a feature instead of a bug, the sport goes along with it instead of holding the team to account in the scores.

    Yes, and I believe this supports my analogy that in ice dance, unlike other figure skating divisions, elements that are manifestly less difficult are awarded the same base value as more advanced elements, and then it's just as if the person with a clean triple toe loop gets better GOE than a slightly wobbled, completed triple triple, thus getting higher scores, because the system rates both jumping passes the same.

    As to the poster to whom you've directed your remarks, you say bullying, and I'd add hit and run.
     
    Last edited: Nov 8, 2013