From Russia with love - Summer through Autumn 2013

Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by allezfred, Aug 18, 2013.

  1. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    I think what happened at worlds had to include their confidence not being too great because of almost winning euros but shot after hearing so much that they had the worst program ever done! That maybe that played into their euros loss and they lost all confidence and wanted the season to be over! What team since cop has almost won a major event like euros and then comes in 16th place in TES Out of 20 in the worlds? Their levels were remarkably consistent with none of the frequent level ones that would appear all the time in their free dances in 2010 and 2011. I think it may have been 2011 NHK they won the SD and then barely medaled after the free dance? So that is what I meant - that's way bigger than going down two points in base value!! They kept the quads in 2012! Their total collapse at worlds with a program considered the worst of all time and that they skipped the Wtt rather than do again showed how the confidence was shattered! So that's why I am surprised they didn't change coaches or even if that's not possible because of nikolai and Elena being involved then just Nikita giving up!
     
  2. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,371
    829
    113
    I disagree. They were doing very well until the worlds.
     
  3. zotza

    zotza allergic to brainless skaters

    539
    92
    28
    I guess the trend now is to only trash I/K and spread rumours about them,plus speculate about how they must be feeling about things. It's viral actually.But they should have expected it when they left Zhulin.See,B/S were trashed and the moment they got there they became the absolute darlings of those same people that trashed them.And nowadays, russian posts can be so easily translated from people that don't even know the language that these conceptions and rumours just travel in light speed.
    I/K had their best season until worlds, they have never finished 2nd in both their events before,never have done the final, they had never come so close to winning Euros.
    My two cents..their losing Euros in such a way made them more angry and determined than they should be in such an important event. Sometimes the will to show you're the best when you're not mentally or physically mature works against you.This is exactly what hapenned with B/S at 2012 Worlds,they had won the SD over P/B, went to Worlds determined, couldn't handle it, lost their focus and fell.And yes, the ice is slippery as well.

    Of course, gossip and rumours and speculations about things are much more appealing than mere facts...
     
    hanca and (deleted member) like this.
  4. Eislauffan

    Eislauffan Well-Known Member

    3,987
    1,222
    113
  5. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    1,034
    182
    63
    Morozov is only acting as a consultant for Dai this season.
     
  6. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,665
    352
    83
    Are there going to be any more test skates this week? Curious to see Volchkova's skaters as none of them have skated yet and they are unpredictable to begin with. Loved that picture with all of them though, so cute.
     
  7. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    Is your two cents based on things I/K said or just a theory? I doubt I/K were in such a total bubble that it never reached them that basically everyone agreed they had the worst program of all time! Especially by the time worlds occurred! And it being in North America.
     
  8. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    14,528
    1,881
    113
    I actually *wish* I could stop trashing I&K. I used to defend them, I really like them as people and skaters, but they're just not delivering on content nor choreography. I even loved their Euros FD skate despite the terrible program.
     
  9. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,371
    829
    113
    I am also curious to see Gosviani and Leonova. Which Leonova will we see? The one from the last season, or the one from two years ago? Is she back to landing jumps or does she still struggle?
     
  10. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,371
    829
    113
    I am glad you admit that you are trashing them. I don't think they deserve it though! If you don't like them, don't watch them, but why bother trashing skaters who put so much time and effort into skating? Some skaters I like, some I don't like. Someone's skating makes me happy/excited and someone's skating just doesn't do anything for me; sometimes I can't even explain why. But why bother trashing the skaters?
     
  11. allezfred

    allezfred Old and Immature Admin Staff Member

    44,075
    10,611
    113
    I don't see anybody "trashing" anything. Some people are saying they would like to see Ilinykh & Katsalapov skate better programmes. It's going to become a pretty dull message board if everybody just posts only about what they like. Nothing wrong with a bit of criticism and discussion.
     
  12. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    14,528
    1,881
    113
    But as I said, I do like them, very much. I would love to just give up on them and stop watching, but they always have flashes of brilliance to reel me back in. It's sad to see them in 9th place because I know they're better than that, but I don't see that the judges or some external forces are to blame. I used to defend them when Zhulin originally said they were lazy, but as that narrative continues and based on what I see in the skating, I find it hard to believe they are just victims of slander about their training habits. Just ask any Sandhu fan how they felt over the years.
     
  13. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    It's certainly possible that after they almost won euros I/k could have said they were there and didnt have to work harder or at all because they were doing well. There are just so few examples of the kind of extreme technical collapse I/k had at worlds in ice dance. Either they pretty much stopped training or didn't train hard or they totally lost confidence in an fd agreed to be the worst ever or the third theory that they just worked so hard they overdid it and exhausted themselves because they were so close at euros. Zhulin has said since they left him they hate training and he got validated tremendously by their 16th place out of 20 Tes at worlds.
     
  14. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,371
    829
    113
    There are many examples of skaters messing up competition. Kostner worlds 2009, Verner Olympics 2010, Gedevanishvilli Worlds 2010 and 2013, Czisny worlds 2012, Mao Asada had a bad season a few season's back, both Adelina and Liza messed up worlds 2013...

    I don't believe that I/K suddenly stopped working hard. I don't even think that it was about lost confidence. I think they had their best season, getting decent results and therefore they were too much aware that they could do quite well at worlds and sometimes when you put yourself under too much pressure, things just don't work. I think we keep forgetting the amount of pressure these elite skaters are under. And I think the better results you had, the better you expect from yourself and are putting yourself under even more and more pressure. I think exactly the same happened to Adelina and Liza. After successful Europeans they put themselves under too much pressure. And it is not only them putting themselves under pressure. It seems that suddenly everyone expects the results, so there is also the pressure from the people around them.
     
  15. Vash01

    Vash01 Fan of Julia, Elena, Anna, Liza, and Vera

    26,863
    4,050
    113
    I&K are still very young. I am sure that with time they will figure out how to deliver when it counts. Their skating is beautiful. It's a matter of time before they put everything together. JMO.
     
  16. analia

    analia Active Member

    172
    35
    28
    Technically speaking, I/K has a few flaws: her flexibility seems lacking; their lifts are year after year uninteresting, which I suspect has something to do with his upper body strength; their step sequences aren't as steady and big as the top 2 teams. That being said, they are a beautiful team and has stunning qualities (esp. speed) no other teams have, which is the reason why everyone had so much hope for them. But I've convinced myself that I/K isn't a "genius" team. They might just have to climb the ladder like everyone else.

    They need to go to Zueva post-Sochi. Zueva, not Shpilband. They need a woman to whip them into shape.
     
    Cherub721 and (deleted member) like this.
  17. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    I know there are plenty of singles skaters but dance teams? It's rare! Losing 5 points in Tes in ice dance is actually difficult to do unless you totally miss an element! Like what happened to p/b in 2011. They missed a whole element so their score dropped a lot but I/k were just absent from their fd. They had been to two previous worlds. Liza and Adelina have an excuse that it was their first worlds. they almost win euros and then they get so much overwhelming pressure by cant deal? B/s is the number one team with all the pressure. It's impossible for them to lose either a SD or fd at Russian nationals. It's impossible to beat b/s in Russia. They've been the number one team since worlds 2010. Every other team is just b/s backup. Sotnikova and tuktamisheva are actually close in fed support and are both under fed pressure but I/k is in such a second place with all focus and attention on b/s. A lot because of the non stop bashing zhulin and others heap on I/k. All the ice dance eggs are in the b/s basket.

    The expectation for people their age are much greater now. They aren't that young they can't medal at a worlds. The shibutani's did. Dance is getting younger and younger. Younger teams them could replace them on the team for Sochi.
     
  18. nuge

    nuge Well-Known Member

    4,113
    263
    83
    Yes like Stepanova/Bukin who are going to be on their heels very soon maybe even R/T heels too !
    So there's not that much time :(
     
  19. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    20,930
    3,798
    113
    The Shibs have been dumped, but more to the point, V/M and D/W jumped the queue when they were very young -- V/M even won the FD when the Del/Shoes won their WC title -- and the question every since has been whether this would be the trend for ice dance once most of the dancers had been brought up in the system, or whether they were more like Plushenko and Yagudin, successful as very young prodigies/outliers to whom everyone else's progress would be measured indefinitely.

    The Shibs, I/K, and C/P have shown that the judges are willing to give and take, and that teams who've done well in the past aren't held up as much when making major mistakes or being rusty from injury. I can't imagine that W/P or P/B would have dropped under C/L under 6.0, like Chait/Saknovsky didn't even beat Winkler/Lohse in the FD at 2003 Euros, even though W/L fell at the beginning of the FW sequence and pretty much lost the element.
     
  20. julieann

    julieann Well-Known Member

    3,686
    345
    83
    The Shibs have been eighth at worlds two years in a row and the one year they did medal was because P/B had a fall that gave them a two point deduction. Their medal that year was more of a gift than anything.

    I/K are very young and had a bad competition last year at worlds, it happens. They way ARE too young to be written off. They (she in particular) are one of the youngest top teams in the world.
     
  21. hanca

    hanca Well-Known Member

    3,371
    829
    113
    Rare? Let's look at dancers then. Last year Bobrova/Soloviev were 7th at worlds (didn't deliver), Shibutanis went from 3rd at worlds in 2011 to 8th at worlds in 2012 and 2013, Pechalat/Bourzat 6th at this worlds from 3rd last year (I know he was injured so they didn't have time to practice). Skaters are under pressure and sometimes they don't manage to skate their best, and that includes ice dancers.
     
  22. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    Yes I/k r/t should be really afraid of s/b! Either they could knock off both team and place second or just r/t they could really make a huge debut! Then there is also S/z too with their gp medal already.

    Seems like it's more wide open for sure! That v/m and d/w were the tip of the iceberg! S/s showed that even if they have been dumped because of their technical issues! First worlds 4th place in SD! Chock and bates already in line for a world medal.

    First worlds 4th place in SD for s/s so immediately they were seen as world medal quality.

    Yeah I/k were really only bad at worlds in 2012/2013 but it was one of those bad performances that turn people's heads! Especially with the program they had. So it was a double whammy of extreme awful!
     
  23. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    That's comparing years I was just thinking of the few weeks from euros to worlds!
     
  24. julieann

    julieann Well-Known Member

    3,686
    345
    83
    Who saw that? One good competition, even a world medal doesn't mean your skating career will amount to anything after that. Look at Artur Gachinski.
     
  25. misskarne

    misskarne #408

    6,430
    1,386
    113
    He is twenty years old and his career is far from over. Also, he won his European silver and a Nationals silver after that Worlds medal, thankyou very much.
     
  26. julieann

    julieann Well-Known Member

    3,686
    345
    83
    You've apparently missed the point, a world medal doesn't equal greatness in the future no matter if your 15 years old or 25 years old. That was the point in the previous posts. If someone wins a world medal doesn't mean someone can't get 8th or 18th for the rest of their career.
     
  27. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    Both of those medal wins in 2011 show that youth is no barrier to success and if they kept their form and didn't collapse technically they may have maintained their medal wins. They could recover their technical abilities and medal again in the future but at their young age they had the ability to medal at the worlds. When S/S and Gachinski placed 4th in their SP/SD and then reached 3rd in the FP/FD it showed first worlds young age meant nothing. So I/K being young is not an excuse for their failure not to medal at a worlds yet in 3 tries.
     
  28. julieann

    julieann Well-Known Member

    3,686
    345
    83
    Failure? Then what is the excuse for anyone who won one a medal and then fell off the podium? Including the Shibs and Gachinski? Do you know how many people have never medaled at worlds in three tries? Winning a medal doesn't mean you will ever win one again, especially in the case of the Shibs someone had to fall for them to medal and then just barely. Can they win another sure just like I/K can win, especially after Sochi.
     
  29. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    6,573
    276
    83
    The excuses for shibs and gachinski were their technical collapses! Him with quads and shibs with twizzles and steps! It's true that even if they had maintained those things they still may not had medaled in 2012 or 2013 and do have greater chances after Sochi. They can fail to win a medal but not be failures.
     
  30. julieann

    julieann Well-Known Member

    3,686
    345
    83
    THANK YOU! Remember that when you think of I/K!