Figure Skating Champions SURVIVOR: Ladies SEMI-FINAL

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by SamuraiK, Jul 13, 2012.

Who is the weakest link among these past champions?

Poll closed Jul 18, 2012.
  1. Michelle Kwan

    63 vote(s)
    15.7%
  2. Irina Slutskaya

    205 vote(s)
    51.0%
  3. Yuna Kim

    134 vote(s)
    33.3%
  1. attyfan

    attyfan Well-Known Member

    7,480
    812
    113
    I did the same ... and for the same reasons.
     
  2. flipforsynchro

    flipforsynchro New Member

    272
    8
    0
    Kim because even though she was able to keep it together at the most important competition, she gave away like three WC.
     
  3. DimaToe

    DimaToe Well-Known Member

    2,460
    378
    83
    Wasn't Michelle 8th in her 1st worlds?
     
  4. TripleWallie

    TripleWallie New Member

    98
    14
    0
    She gave away 2010 and 2011. But in 2007 and 2008 she was badly injured.
     
  5. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    Even injured she didnt have to miss the triple lutz 4 times. If she missed only 1 of them both years she would have won both times.
     
  6. TripleWallie

    TripleWallie New Member

    98
    14
    0
    This is an off-season battle of ubers/popularity contest! Vehree seeryus stuff!
     
  7. Zokko!

    Zokko! Comansnala?

    2,318
    306
    83
    Miracles just happen - for the very first time ever ... I've voted for ... Kwan ... :shuffle: :lynch:
     
  8. berthesghost

    berthesghost Well-Known Member

    4,891
    585
    113
    Really? I could have swore you voted for her in both the "skater I have the most irrational hatred for" poll and the "Skater you'd most think ran over my puppy, I hate on so often" poll. Huh. My memory must be slipping. :lol:
     
  9. dawnie

    dawnie Active Member

    362
    58
    28
    The first few rounds were fun but it's been clear for a while now that Kwan is going to be the sole SURVIVOR. Next game!
     
  10. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    14,518
    1,865
    113
    I voted for Kwan last time but this time I had to go with Slutskaya. She just doesn't beat either girl head to head.

    With Kwan vs. Kim, it comes down to how much you weigh the OGM against multiple world titles and how you view dominance under the 6.0 system vs. CoP. Slutskaya loses against Kim because she lacks the OGM, and loses against Kwan because she has less world titles. Slutskaya did very well under both systems, but didn't dominate in either. I think her career would have been very different had CoP come about earlier.

    But anyway, even though I voted her out, I will never forget her win at Moscow Worlds. That was one of the greatest moments ever, and I give her huge props for 2004 Worlds also. I just couldn't believe she made it through that competition and finished in the top 10, with all her health problems. I'm glad she at least waited to retire until the day when pants were allowed, because she rocked them and they enabled voidier programs. :D
     
  11. Excidra

    Excidra New Member

    1,502
    126
    0
    Surya Bonaly the multiple world medalist and technically strong skater and Chen the world champion and twice Olympic medalist. Whether her basics sucked or Chinese federation lacked influence doesn't deter from the fact that both ladies were world gold contenders during their days.

    And as fars as Ando and Kostner go, yes they are wc, but they were never a competition for Yuna when all skater clean.
     
  12. shady82

    shady82 Active Member

    473
    31
    28
    I don't think we should be comparing Slutskaya to Bonaly and Chen. During the period these three were competing together, Slutskaya wasn't competing for gold because she wasn't a top-level skater yet. Only from 99-00 on was Slutskaya in top shape and could contend for gold.

    Irina really only had to compete against one skater at a time when she was contending at the top. From 2000-2002, Kwan was the only major skater she had to worry about. Butyrskaya, a bit, but she was like an Ando or Kostner for Kim. Then for two seasons Irina had various hardships, and came back in top shape for 04-05 and 05-06. During this period, Irina's only main rival was Sasha, if even. Shizuka was a factor one time only because Irina skated unusually poorly in Torino.
     
  13. Cheylana

    Cheylana Well-Known Member

    4,982
    967
    113
    Voted for Slutskaya but I was tempted to vote for Kim. I'm swayed in large part by the fact that Kim got OGM on her first try, and under crushing pressure from the entire South Korean population at that, whereas Irina underperformed and came up short in three tries. Irina's extra World gold doesn't make up for that.
     
  14. sk8ingcoach

    sk8ingcoach Active Member

    460
    36
    28
    This is stupid..... Yuna should win this easy, but there are too many kwan fans even though her technical ability is crap
     
  15. Badams

    Badams Well-Known Member

    5,038
    1,217
    113
    You should totally BOYCOTT!!!
     
  16. berthesghost

    berthesghost Well-Known Member

    4,891
    585
    113
    :lol:
    Nah, I suggest a jump-off between the 2 Ks. Whoever landed the most 3Rs in competition wins! :p
     
  17. bartek

    bartek New Member

    241
    16
    0
    Whoever landed the most triple-triples in competition wins! And we don't even have to consider their difficulty! And the fact that one of them landed one 3T-3T per year and the other one 6 3F-3T or 3Lz+3T per year with superior height and flow :lol:
     
  18. sk8ingcoach

    sk8ingcoach Active Member

    460
    36
    28
    so true
     
  19. magnolia

    magnolia New Member

    361
    37
    0
    This is a popularity contest, not a jumping contest!

    If it were the former, then Midori would win no question about it.
     
  20. judgejudy27

    judgejudy27 Well-Known Member

    13,704
    787
    113
    Dont be too sure, on FSU I wouldnt be surprised if Kwan even won that. :lol:
     
  21. falling_dance

    falling_dance D. Murakami's Newest Fan

    23,580
    4,390
    113
    How soon did we all forget that Trash Can elimination game from late 2008 in which Midori Ito--not Kwan--had the highest score after 1,000 posts!
     
  22. jatale

    jatale New Member

    51
    4
    0
    I think Kim is the best overall technical skater ever in female skating history so far, and also very high on the artistic content side. I certainly don't buy the argument that she has competed against a weaker field that the skaters before her. (Mao is an incredible talent, certainly among the best female skaters ever, and as top-notch a champion and rival as ever existed in female figure skating.) As with every sport, in figure skating the skill levels and competitive depth gets better overall with each passing year. That is the way of things and records will continue to fall. Within ten years the women might be doing quads....
     
    Last edited: Jul 14, 2012
  23. kwanette

    kwanette Fetalized since 1998

    2,677
    1,000
    113
    True, outta reps for U.
     
  24. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    14,518
    1,865
    113
    And when having actual transitions in her program, doing more difficult footwork and spins, skating faster, and having at least equally good skating skills. :lol: The only thing Kwan has skating-wise over Kim is the spiral sequence, IMO.
     
  25. flipforsynchro

    flipforsynchro New Member

    272
    8
    0
    If Kim was so good, she should've been freakin able to be more than 1 time WC. everyone knows Kim has harder, better jumps, but Kwan was able take what she had and become 5 time WC and two time OM.
     
  26. michiruwater

    michiruwater Well-Known Member

    9,256
    1,946
    113
    Kim hasn't even been old enough to go to two Olympics yet, you know. Kwan won 5 times out of 12 at the WCs. Kim has won, yes, only once, at 5 WCs, and I doubt she'll do another seven, but she's only 21 still.
     
  27. berthesghost

    berthesghost Well-Known Member

    4,891
    585
    113
    yes, but we went over this.

    in 5 years:
    Kim: OGM, 1WC, 2 silver, 2 bronze
    Kwan: Oly Silver, 2 WC, 2 silver
    Irina: No Oly medal, no WC, 1 silver, 1 bronze

    Irina's clearly the weakest by far.
     
    RunnersHigh and (deleted member) like this.
  28. Cherub721

    Cherub721 YEAH!

    14,518
    1,865
    113
    Kim has more medals at this stage of her career than Kwan did. Contrary to what was posted above, Kwan did not medal in first two appearances at Worlds. In 5 years, she achieved one gold and two silvers at Worlds, and one silver at the Olympics. Kim won bronze her first two Worlds (better than Kwan's non-podium finishes), then a gold and two silvers, but she also won the OGM. So they both had two major titles by this point.
     
  29. berthesghost

    berthesghost Well-Known Member

    4,891
    585
    113
    Seriously, do we need to agree on parameters before making simple comparisons? Kwan's first two worlds were at 13 and 14, an age that Kim surely would have competed at had she been allowed to had the rules not changed. Would it make you feel better to make up finishes Kim would have probably made had she been allowed at 05 and 06 worlds? :rolleyes: Or shoudl we just bring Mao back as the probably 06 OGM? :rolleyes: Or, I know, let's pretend that Kwan was allowed to skate in Lillehammer and just say she came in 13th at her first Oly's while vastly more talented Kim won gold on her first. :lol:
    I also tried to even it out for fairness by starting the comparisons at the beginning of a Oly cycle. Or do you have some complicated formula for figuring out bonus points for finishing behind medalists about to retire, etc..? :p
     
  30. bartek

    bartek New Member

    241
    16
    0
    Irina got her medals later in her career and it's actually very admirable that she won her second world title at the age of 26. She was dominating ladies figure skating while being 25, 26 and 27. This is much harder to do when you're that old than when you're still in your teens like Kim did. We will see the level of Yu-Na's skating now when she's older. It's not so sure she'll be as good as she was in the past when she won her titles.