Corrected thread- Best pro male skater

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by Vash01, Jul 14, 2013.

(corrected) who is the best male pro skater?- Pick 3

Poll closed Oct 12, 2013.
  1. Brian Boitano

    37 vote(s)
    20.6%
  2. Scott Hamilton

    23 vote(s)
    12.8%
  3. Paul Wylie

    13 vote(s)
    7.2%
  4. Brian Orser

    8 vote(s)
    4.4%
  5. Kurt Browning

    122 vote(s)
    67.8%
  6. Viktor Petrenko

    16 vote(s)
    8.9%
  7. Ilia Kulik

    25 vote(s)
    13.9%
  8. Alexei Yagudin

    27 vote(s)
    15.0%
  9. Jeff Buttle

    26 vote(s)
    14.4%
  10. Stephane Lambiel

    42 vote(s)
    23.3%
  11. Toller Cranston

    10 vote(s)
    5.6%
  12. Other (Specify)

    15 vote(s)
    8.3%
Multiple votes are allowed.
  1. aliceanne

    aliceanne Well-Known Member

    2,344
    475
    83
    There are, but they usually don't win international medals because they focus on dance instead of jumping. Sarah Kawahara, Belita, and Katherine Healy for example. A lot of the "artistic" men mention in their biographies that they were discouraged from going into dance - not so for the women.
     
  2. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    Okay, I will try to ask again - what does "diverse", or not "diverse" has to do with one's looks and physique (because Lambiel seems "soft" and "fragile" exactly because of his looks and physique)? I think it has more to do with the style, idea, mood and choreography of the programs. If those are diverse/versatile, then the skater is diverse/versatile. Also, Stephane can look fragile, but is he really that fragile if he can do programs that are not physically easy (because programs that are filled with choreo and steps are not physically easy even without jumps)? Besides, judging by the muscles on his slender arms, he spends quite a lot of time in gym (actually, as a fan I know he does) :D.

    As for what you call "feminine" - yes, there are very few male skaters who use their arms/hands as beautifully and gracefully as Lambiel does. It's one of those things which make him unique, so I can't view that as a minus, even though some people think that it's feminine.

    I don't know if you read my previous response to you (with examples of programs). If you read it, and still think that Lambiel is just a "nice guy", and not diverse, then I have only one conclusion - a male skater has to dress in women's clothing, baby clothes (or both at the same time :D), or in fake muscles costume for you to think that he is diverse ;) :lol:. Sometimes it can be fun, but I am so glad that Stephane will never do that :cool:. Jokes aside, it seems that our ways of thinking and our perceptions are just too different. A few years ago I too thought that Stephane is a beautiful, elegant prince and a dandy who will probably never be something else, but over those past few years I have changed my mind completely, as Stephane continues to surprise me again and again. He has done at least several things that I thought he will never do. Not so long ago I was watching videos of his exhibition programs, and was almost daunted by how different he can be, and even more by the thought of what his body of work will look like in five or so years, as I don't believe that his creative mind will run dry soon. Yes, perceptions are very different.
     
    Last edited: Jul 30, 2013
  3. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    You emphasize it like other skaters on this poll are not athletic. I think that all skaters who do programs that are physically difficult are athletic, no matter if they are tall or short, broad shouldered, or not so broad shouldered, really "manly" looking, or more of the feminine type. And by physically difficult I don't mean just filled with jumps, but also filled with choreography, moves and steps - such programs are difficult even without multiple jumps.
     
  4. t.mann

    t.mann New Member

    256
    11
    0
    Helpful answer.
    Thank you.

    Anyway, men who have entered into this sport with artistic ambitions seem much more than ladies, IMO.
     
    Last edited: Jul 30, 2013
  5. unicorn

    unicorn Member

    274
    22
    18
    No, not everyone was as athletic as him. :lol: Seems someone's feminine comment touched someone's sensitive spot, hey, that has nothing to do with my posts :lol:
     
  6. reut

    reut Active Member

    734
    163
    43
    Of course, nothing to do with your posts, you even posted just recently Cousins's program which is a good example of something people might call feminine in men's skating. :)
     
  7. unicorn

    unicorn Member

    274
    22
    18
    Really, I saw lots of fans proudly called some skaters balletic in men's skating. ;)
     
  8. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    You wrote your post some time before that comment. I responded to the posts in reverse order, but that doesn't mean that I read them in that order ;). Anyway, that is what I truly think - the thought that anything else than the difficulty of the programs could define whether a skater is athletic or not seems laughable to me. And I think that all of the skaters in this poll are athletic enough - actually, it's difficult to imagine someone among successful skaters who is not, otherwise they would not be successful.

    Is that necessarily feminine? Men dance in ballet too ;). But reut is right - there are people who think otherwise. In their opinion male ballet dancers are feminine as well.
     
  9. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    I had no time to watch, I just respond . For me he is too busy on ice, he did too much movements, annoys me,and he lacks of strength. Stef is a bit overact that he is very artistic, he is too much for me. This is matter of taste.
    I also liked better Robin Cousins's skating. I went crazy for him, when I was a very very young girl :)
    ----------

    Alexander Godunov wasn't feminine, and I also don't think that Tsiskaridze was too feminine on stage.
     
  10. VarBar

    VarBar Well-Known Member

    1,253
    211
    63
    Maybe reut felt that comment had something to do with your posts though because you praised Cousins earlier for his manly interpretation of a program - as one of his great qualities I suppose - but then shared here another program of his where he hardly epitomizes masculinity in figure skating.;)
     
  11. unicorn

    unicorn Member

    274
    22
    18
    Oh, in that post, I mean, another person's comment has nothing to do with my posts. That's his/her opinion, I never said anyone was feminine. I praised Cousins for his manly interpretation, does it automatically mean other skaters on the list are feminine? Curious, my posts really look like that?
     
  12. lily

    lily Active Member

    375
    38
    28
    Woohoo how this thread turned into a Lambiel dispute thread :watch:
     
  13. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    I understand that you had no time to watch, but I described what characters/images he is portraying in those programs - those are not "bad guys", but they are definitely more than just "nice guys".

    You mean he has too much choreography ;)? Anyway, "too much movements" is funny coming from someone who's favorite skater in many people's opinion moves his arms way too much, and also does footwork that often looks too busy and frantic ;). I didn't write that to put him down - I too think that sometimes he overdoes with those things, but I still like and respect him, and also think that those arm movements and footwork is a part of his style. I was just surprised with your comment about "too much movements". As for strength - I can't agree. Stephane has a more fragile body type (the top half at least :)), but in his programs he often does things that are physically difficult and tiring.

    Yes, part if what you said is a matter of taste, but not everything - not about "strength" and "fragile", not about "not diverse", and not really about "nice guy". That is my opinion.

    That comment was not about you. I just know that there are a lot of people who think that both figure skating and ballet are feminine as a whole - they are ignoring the athletic part of it.
     
    Last edited: Jul 30, 2013
  14. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    Originally that was not my intention. I just wrote a comment about Yagudin's skating in some particular shows, and it all started from there :rolleyes:. Unfortunately, I am just one of those people who can't keep silent when other people misunderstand me, or when they say things about my favorites that I don't agree with.
     
  15. lily

    lily Active Member

    375
    38
    28
    I actually read your posts with interest and like that you analyze and argue your statements and don't give only such arguments as "I just like/don't like", "it seems me", "I respond without watching" or :lol:.
     
  16. DarrellH

    DarrellH New Member

    4,763
    375
    0
    Have to go with the crowd on this one...Kurt Browning
     
  17. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    This is my opinion. You have also opinion on my favorite. You must to accept mine. Lambiel isn't the best skater, only is your favorite. You are biased like me. He has some good qualities. And if you are a real fan of Stef, you know they are very good friends and they respect ech other.
    And yes, my favorite is a real man on ice, he has masculine power, like Joubert's.
    http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?f...3577989.169139.497666860283735&type=1&theater
     
    Last edited: Jul 31, 2013
  18. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    I know that you have your opinion, and I have mine. But I don't have to accept your opinion if I don't agree with it, especially if your "opinion" is based on very superficial things. I am biased too, of course, but that's not how I form my opinions. Or I at least try not to.

    Actually I wouldn't even call your opinion an "opinion" - it's more just your taste. You like more "masculine" skaters than Lambiel, and that is fine. But you could have just said so from the start - there was no need to write that he is not diverse, and that all his programs are "similar" just because he is not in your taste, and because you haven't paid attention to the many things that are different in his programs. But okay, I think we can simply agree to disagree.

    I wrote what many other people think about your favorite skater - that was not my opinion. Although I partially agree, unlike those other people I also see other things in his skating that I like. And I know very well that Lambiel and Plushenko respect each other - I respect Plushenko too.
     
  19. matti

    matti Active Member

    378
    29
    28
    Fanny Cradock
     
  20. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    I respect Lambiel too!!!!:respec: He is among my top ten favorite skaters. But for me this is the diversity http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqUBlz5a89s , http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vURTGSsm4oo , www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-7c-9GqE3Q and so on...
     
  21. falling_dance

    falling_dance D. Murakami's Newest Fan

    23,579
    4,390
    113
    nm
     
    Last edited: Jul 31, 2013
  22. VarBar

    VarBar Well-Known Member

    1,253
    211
    63
    It really has to do with personal preference for a style because I don't see Plushenko's range of programs being more diverse than Lambiel's.

    I honestly thought this thread was about who's the best PRO skater in terms of variety/complexity/quality of programs (skating & movement) rather than this style versus that style.
     
  23. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    I understand you. Plushenko does dramatic programs, lyrical/romantic programs AND comical programs. Stephane doesn't really do comical programs - he does light and fun programs instead. He has one funny program ('Rigoletto') and funny parts in some other programs ('A Chorus Line', and 'William Tell' which is not a show program), but his approach to comical is - how to say it - not so direct, more sophisticated. I won't be surprised if Stephane will make more funny programs in future, but I also suspect that he will never dress in baby clothes/female dress or in acid colours for a program :D.
     
  24. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    If you're talking about the Asissai program, then all you say that is one of the fanniest,the most surprising, original, thus the best EX program ever in figure skating history. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzZCc5nQ8-E

    You are right, but probably if we are not arguing with Lauravvv, then this thread would have gone down. Otherwise I voted for Kurt. His pro skating without a doubt is the best. Many skaters have good programs, but Kurt has many unforgettable and brilliant programs.
     
    Last edited: Aug 1, 2013
  25. unicorn

    unicorn Member

    274
    22
    18
    I don't think Patrick Chan is simply working with Kathy Johnson for skating &movements. Body carriage is always a part of figure skating, someone call it style. Actually, I do feel Plushenko and Lambiel have certain similarities, they both have that flamboyant stuff.
     
  26. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    hi Unicorn! ;)
     
  27. lala

    lala Well-Known Member

    2,118
    200
    63
    .
     
    Last edited: Aug 1, 2013
  28. VarBar

    VarBar Well-Known Member

    1,253
    211
    63
    Oh yes, you're right, unicorn, that the carriage is often deemed to be part of a person's style. But I was rather thinking along the lines of a more masculine look versus a more graceful/feminine one or an extroverted performer such as Browning or Petrenko or Yagudin versus an introverted one such as Robin Cousins. I always felt that Cousins skated in his own world.
     
  29. lauravvv

    lauravvv Well-Known Member

    1,477
    127
    63
    Yes, that one :D. But I didn't mean anything bad. I do think that generally it's an easy trick and an easy way to be funny if a male artist dresses in female clothes, but because of that it's even more difficult to make it truly funny and special, and Plushenko (and his choreographer) managed to do that. Good acting, and I am glad that he didn't just skate his program in ordinary female clothes from start to finish, but made it more interesting - and this is a really inventive costume. I have nothing against that sort of funny programs - in fact, I even like them. I just think that there are also different ways to be funny that don't involve funny costumes/clothes.

    I also agree that it is probably one of the (many) best exhibition programs, but I don't think it's the best ever - especially because it's too difficult to compare it to more serious exhibition programs.

    By the way, if Plushenko gets to skate in the Sochi gala show (which is very possible even if he is not in top five), it would be really great if he would skate that kind of funny program - especially if the show will be a parade of serious and lyrical/romantic programs which is very probable too. That would be fun indeed :D!


    Yes, although some people call it style, it is a part of figure skating that is even included in marks (or it should be, according to the PCS rules).

    I must agree that both Plushenko and Lambiel have their flamboyance indeed - only Lambiel's flamboyance is still more sophisticated and, often, more toned down than Plushenko's.
     
    Last edited: Aug 1, 2013
  30. shine

    shine Well-Known Member

    4,467
    555
    113
    Thanks for posting those. I really liked Yags when he was competing and was happy that he won in 2002. Totally loved his 2001 SP. But I've come to expect more from pro/show skating and want to see a higher level of originality, style, musicality, sophisticated/well constructed/clever choreography. He had eligible programs that played to his strength (power and passion), but I do think he has always been rather one-dimensional and used the same formula in terms of program choices. That's fine with eligible skating but not so much with pro skating. I don't see him nearly as versatile (especially when compared to quite a few on the list) to be a good pro skater. The programs above IMO are like many of the gala programs that we see from competitive skaters: kind of thrown together with rehashed moves. You also don't see him moving differently from the flamenco to the blues. The thing is I think he's first and foremost an athlete and doesn't take show skating that seriously anyway nor does he see show skating as an art form, which is totally fine. Many great champions retired without ever pursuing a pro career. Not meant to bash, my point is really just that one of the best pro skaters he's not.
     
    Last edited: Aug 3, 2013