Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by PeterG, Jan 16, 2014.
I can't warm up to Malaya....
she irritates me
i dont really know. her slurry diction is part of it. she's also overly energetic in a way i'm not articulating well at all. she's probably nice, i dont think she's mean or anything.
I was just curious. She irritates me too and I couldn't put my finger on exactly why.
Its getting harder to eliminate! CJ did better this week but I still find him to be the weak link. Malaya, too, just doesn't impress me most of the time. Her duet with Sam was rough, not a patch off the originals! Jena and Calab are still my faves and I loved Alex's original song. Dexter was great tonight, he's an awesome country singer. Really enjoyed Jessica and Caleb's duet, they did a great cover of that song.
Jessica - "Blue-Eyed Lie" - great original song & she sounded great. This was her best performance. A-
CJ - "Soulshine" - much much better re singing on key. He was really connected. I loved it. B
Sam - "Lego House" - meh. The singing was ok but no personality behind it. C-
Malaya - "Ain't No Way" - She has a good voice but she is very inconsistent & this song was too big for her. The faces she makes when she sings are very off-putting. C-
Dexter - "One Mississippi -this was the 1st time I've enjoyed Dexter. This is the kind of song he needs to sing, not big anthem songs. He just can't pull them off so he ends up sounding like a karaoke singer. Best he's done. B+
Jena - "Rolling In The Deep" - I wish Jena had auditioned with an original song because I'd like to hear the one from Hollywood week again. But I loved what she did with Rolling in the Deep. Very original. A
Caleb - "Chain of Fools" - he did it well but I guess I'm just tired of him singing all these oldies. He doesn't come off as very current. B
Alex - "Fairytales" - I thought this was a great original song & I loved the way he sang it. A+
Sam & Malaya should be at the bottom with one of them going home. I can't predict who else will be in the bottom. I didn't rate the duets because they were all pretty bad. Jessica's & Caleb's was probably the best; Dexter's & CJ's was the worst.
As an aside - Harry needs to shave. That scruff looks awful.
i think dexter is creepy. but i think part of it is that i associate his name w a serial killer.
does the lego co get royalties from lego house?
PS: I was fangirling over Alison Iraheto. What a voice! Her record company were idiots for letting her go. They should have given her better material & promoted her better. Her hair is hideous though - the color and the black roots.
Those braces affect her diction I think.
For me, Malaya has puppy dog enthusiasm, which I find annoying.
I'm not surprised that Caleb and Jess had the best duet. They're older and have much more performing experience.
Me too. I like her tone but I rarely like her music choice (too big or too mature for her) & her diction is not pleasing.
In re of a criticism I read, FWIW I don't think Jessica is a Stevie Nicks wannabe. I think she just naturally has that voice.
I like her enthusiasm - the younguns have that it seems. But her braces affect her enunciating.
Can anyone tell me what happened? The result show was pre-empted for a weather report. Apparently Fox thinks a tornado watch is more important that AI.
So glad the judges saved Sam! Malaya and CJ will be the next two to go. Well maybe Sam, too but here's hoping he will step it up more since he's still in it. What a great voice he has.
I find it annoying that they didn't use the save on Majesty, but used in on Sam. Yeah, save the sweet young WGWG even though he's shown virtually no creativity, improvement, or connection to his music and has been overrated since the beginning. I'll be even more annoyed if one of the better singers gets the boot next week because there is no save left.
am i to believe they keep confetti in the ceiling all the time?
Ick...I was hoping Sam was the bottom vote-getter. So my wish came true but they saved him?
Allskate, I agree. I thought the save should have been used on Majesty who has TONS more potential than Sam. At least she has a pulse.
Sam was the bottom vote getter? I find that amazing considering he was winning the under 21 vote and those typically dominate in the totals. Maybe the limited voting is really changing things? I watched a few performances last night and Caleb blew me away. I remember reading that he comes off less than ideal but his voice is incredible. I want a duet on a song like he did last night (rock infused soul) with Kelly Clarkson. He is like a male version of her!
My rankings for Wednesday:
1. Jessica solo - what a way to start the show!
2. Jessica and Caleb - I think Jessica out-performed Caleb??
3. Dexter - WTF??? How am I ranking Dexter so high? I hate Dexter!! But he was as good on Wednesday as he has been with ALL of his previous performances combined
4. Jena solo - hated her version, but the vocal was flawless
5. Sam solo - boring as ****, but a good vocal
6. Jena and Alex - Alright, but not great.
7. CALEB - CHAIN OF FOOLS - STOP YELLING AT US ALL THE TIME!!!!!!!!! Harry is right, Caleb just keeps doing the same thing over and over and over. He needs to diversify.
8. Malaya solo - perhaps her worst vocal so far??
9. Alex solo - same as Caleb, he's starting to sound the same week after week
10. Sam and Malaya - they needed more rehearsal time on that one!
11. C.J. solo - really bad...
12. C.J. and Dexter - in the history of television, has there ever been a more horrifically horrible musical number performed?
different seasons but teen beat got a save and daughtry didnt, if my memory is correct. that's wild.
Didn't Daughtry compete before they had a save option?
quite possibly but in my head it is going down as a great wrong anyway
Just watched DVR Idol from Wed. PML at Harry (with JLo right next to him) telling CJ the reason he tells him to work on pitch is because if/when he gets a record contract, if he's not in tune the record company will autotune him 'and suck the life out of your voice'!!!
I think Malaya is very much a free spirit and unfiltered. We've all been taught to "behave" in various ways throughout our lives and for those of us who found those "life lessons" to be too restrictive can feel irritated when someone crosses our path who totally rejected all those "rules". Not sure if this is true for any of us, but I'm sure there are a lot of viewers who are put off by Malaya for this reason.
I like Malaya, and for 16 I find her music skills and vocal abilities pretty sound. Maybe I just identify with nerds too much?
to the judges for saving Sam though. I think they feared the ratings might tank farther if they tween-heartthrob was eliminated though. He's a cute kid, very marketable, but his music screams coffeehouse not ampitheatre.
I STILL think she'll be a better singer when those stinking braces come off.
They saved Sam...you gotta love the teen idol demographic.
The teenage demographic drives the music industry, on every level; so, it's little wonder he was saved!
Separate names with a comma.