Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by PeterG, May 18, 2010.
Good job from Lee, no great shakes, voice off key in a couple of parts.
Damn. Lee picks tonight of all nights to not totally suck.
For all the goin on I kinda figured this was gonna be a trainwreck but I thought this was actually a really good job. He came alive for the first time.
Lee sounded amazing? I mean, he was okay? Off pitch less than usual? So that's amazing. Huh.
And Ellen is bugging me tonight for some reason. Of course, Kara makes her seem way less annoying.....
Honestly, I don't think it matters at this point how the contestants perform. I'd be shocked if Lee and Crystal didn't make the finale.
...And a chorus of thousands echoes the same thought.
LOL. so true.
I haven't voted all season but I may have to tonight. That's OK Casey. If you put out a blue/rock album, I'll buy it. I probably won't buy anything of Lees or Crystals unless she changes her style.
Damn, I hate this song.
Vulnerable side? Give me a break. He needs to show his sexy side you twit. That was sabotage.
Um, Kara? If Casey would rock out like we know he can, his audience would include a lot of dudes.
If I were Casey, I'd just commit hari kari on my guitar. Because this isn't going to go well.
Primary returns are more exciting than this.
Kara's choice of Daughters pretty much put Casey right in front of that rolling bus.
If I were the Idol producers, I would kick Kara off the show even if I had to buy out her contract. She is so freaking annoying.
I don't think Casey has sounded very good the past few weeks, and this song does suck....too sappy for AI.
Randy and Ellen like it.
yeah, it is a double creep. John Mayer and "daughters" lyrics. And Casey does ok with it, not blowing it out of the park, but ok
Of COURSE Randy applauds the song choice on Casey . He and Kara selected the fcuking song .
I started clipping my toenails during that performance. That pretty much sums it up for me
ETA: for Simon blaming Randy/Kara for selecting the wrong song for Casey. Good for him.
I hope it backfires, I havent voted all season but I may throw him a vote or two for being subjected to this bile
The sad part is that I think she really buys this B.S.. All season she's been encouraging him to get away from the jamming and show how "vulnerable" he is. Apparently, with Casey, she doesn't really believe there are No Boundaries.
When Casey was singing, I was thinking it's actually kind of pretty if you can ignore the dumb fcuking lyrics.
Damning with faint praise. Simon calling out the others on song choice.
I hate Daughters....
Poor Casey, having to sing John Mayer's embarrassing "Daughters". It doesn't matter how well you sing that song, you're still saying those lyrics. Reminded me how much I can't stand John Mayer.
Well I was impressed that Casey toned down the goat a bit for the second song, but what a crap choice from Randy & Kara. PML that Simon called them out on it right in front of their faces.
I never realized those lyrics bothered so many people. How the hell did it get so popular, then?
Yep. I still can't believe Mayer won a Grammy for "Say, Say, Say."
Mayer is good at guitar. So is Casey. So, if they were insistent on giving Casey a Mayer song, they should have given him one that really allowed him to show his stuff on the guitar.
John Mayer is such a mumbler, maybe people couldn't understand him. I know it took real effort for me to make out anything besides "fathers be good to your daughters."
yeah Casey was just ok again... I'd be shocked if it was anyone but him goin home
NOOOOOOOOOOO!!! Paul McCartney?
Epic BLEAH. Hate hate hate Paul M. and Wings
Kanye West is popular (as far as selling music, not personally of course) and he rhymed "caspers" with "NASA."
You're probably right. Thank you, Casey, for exposing that song for the tripe that it is.