Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by LuckyCharm, Jan 17, 2013.
zonette's vibrato brings all the goats to the yard
Speaking of goats:
And she's so dramatic.
I get the feeling that Julianna will be fantastic in a year or two. Still, I'm slightly shocked that they didn't put her through.
Candace has a really good voice; she reminds me of the R&B singer Kelly Price
Not surprised they axed Jet. Lovely voice, but I don't think she's what they are looking for this year.
Thanks .. I needed a good laugh tonight.
ETA: That last note of Zoannette's was incredible! In a good way AND in a bad way!
And she makes it through .. the craziness continues!
What the hell just happened? They put through the country blonde girl...Janelle? She had the WORST vocal of any of the girls, both this week and last. It was god awful.
But golly gee whizz she wants to be like DOLLY!!!
The other country girl was so much better, as was the 15 year old with the guitar. Tonight's talent pool was a lot better than last weeks, it's ridiculous. I really wish Ameriker got a say in this. That's what sets American Idol a part from the other reality singing shows where the judges have more power. The previous formats for semi finals were a lot better.
To me Candice was the only one who was a clear choice to go thru. However Christobel is one of my favs & I thought she deserved it over some of the others. I didn't like either Aubrey or Breanna & putting Zonette thru was a joke. I liked Jenelle at first but she's been acting awfully entitled but not sounding her best & I agree Rachel was better tonight. BTW Zonette seems very popular with the others & she strikes me a person whose personality I would like but she doesn't have a very good voice. I'm not disparaging her or Aubrey & Breanna, just their singing ability. Overall it was a pretty dismal night.
I can't be bothered to remember names, but I don't get the fawning over that pageant performance by the girl in the gold dress singing Beyonce. So phony and disconnected. God these girls make me miss Jessica Sanchez, and I thought she was a bit pageant! I can take Zonette in small doses...I agree with her going through if only because she wasn't a total snoozefest.
Now that's just wrong.
Oh yea ... tonights AI.
I think Zoanette is a hot mess. I couldn't believe they put her through with her original audition. She's a superstar? She can't be gone soon enough for me.
I agree that Rachel was better than Janelle. I guess she's this year's blonde country singer.
Not a good night. I think they're choosing people based on personality and looks and target audiences far too much.
i have a hard time believing zonette is 20 unless they use different numbers in liberia
She may be older than 20, but I'm looking forward to seeing what she looks like when the stylists get to her. For that alone, I'd have put her through. It's not like they've left winners out of the final group.
Jett was my favourite of the night. She did not make it through.
She was my #2 choice for the night. She did not make it through.
In my opinion Zoanette was the worst of the night...and she made it through...
Janelle was close to being my least favourite of the night. She did make it through.
Amen, to the above.
What are they looking for this year?
They may not have left winners out but they definitely did leave people out who deserved top 20 more than some of those chosen. So potentially a more deserving person may have hung on long enough to go on tour & make a boatload of money. These top 20 will get at least one more week of exposure, which IMO should have gone to some people who were eliminated. So it's not too much consolation to those people that they wouldn't have won anyway. And I predict that Zoanette will go on tour because if nothing else, VFTW will vote for her.
I also felt like I was listening to a different show and watching a different show. Zonette going through was a joke. It was a clever music choice based on her life experience etc but to me that isn't why someone should go through. She also sang terribly. She is a hot mess in every way. I also was surprised that they didn't put Julianna through. I loved her and she was so different. I would have kept Julianna and got rid of Zonette and got rid of Breanna and chose Rachel. Julianna was a breath of fresh air to me because she wasn't about some big voice. I honestly am over the big voice thing. I just want someone who is unique and emotionally connected to the songs. Janelle was damn lucky they saved her. Because she wasn't good last night. Although she has been in the past. I liked Rachel but she has to find a little bit more depth if she wants to be a true artist. She comes off very Miss America. I liked Aubrey OK. But I think she made it through based on the whole package thing rather than her voice to be honest. She is good but I wasn't blown away. But the saddest thing to me is that all these girls were better than the boys last week. They should just stop picking the singers based on gender and just pick the best talent. Some may argue that it is rigged for a girl to won this year. Maybe so. But the guys were so awful last week. the " best " guy didn't hold a candle to any of these girls this week.
I have to disagree there. Elijah has something special, just wait, you will see some good things coming from him I think. What he put out last week wasn't fantastic, but somehow I still loved it. It reminds me a bit of the first time I saw Blake Lewis or Kris Allen. The vocal was a bit shaky but there was some spark there that kept them on my mind and then a few weeks later they are putting out amazing performances week in and week out. For me last night, there was zero spark for Jett, Cristabel, Janelle, and Melinda. Aubrey and Breanna were rather dull, and Rachel while enjoyable came off pretty amateur. Juliana gave me goosebumps and I'd have put her through FOR SURE, but she's gone now. Zoanette was fun, I get putting her through for the spectacle- and she does have skills, she just needs a TON of vocal coaching. So that leaves us with Candice, who was great in a way but the song was a bit dull and dated (and she didn't quite do what Kelly Clarkson did to it), and she can and will do way better things in the future. So when you put the 5 who went through against an Elijah, I see him outlasting most of these girls. And Tenna, Amber, and Adriana too. We'll see what the guys tonight have in store...
I think that they see another Fantasia in her...I don't.
Idol has me baffled this season.
What is up with Nicki? Have the producers told her to be an obnoxious beeyotch who focuses on things other than the vocals? She was just downright mean to David Willis and Bryant Tedeo who, IMO, sang justr as well or better than some of the singers she has raved about. And what does hurricane Katrina, losing weight, and getting out tha 'hood have to do with whether someone should advance?
Even Lazaro himself realized he didn't sing well, but I guess the judges (or producers) didn't care. He stutters and is cute, so his backstory trumps his vocals.
I saw enough of Zoanette last night. I didn't need to see her again tonight. I don't think I can keep watching if this season is going to be the Nicki and Zoanette show.
I think Lazaro was better than Vincent and Burnell. I thought Bryant was the only one who was robbed tonight but no one really knocked it out of the park. I didn't particualarly like Cortez's song but I thought he did the best of all of them. I would put Nick#2 & Bryant #3. I didn't have a #4 or #5. The rest all sucked IMO.
And I mean that in a bad way...
Even Lazaro himself knew he didn't sing well.
Here's Melinda Doolittle's tweet about Lazaro: "Ummm ... you know I love Laz right? I think that's all I wil say right now."
I think I would have sent Lazaro home. He mumbled most of his song and held the microphone to close to his mouth. And I'd have kept the Singh guy - I liked his voice and the fact that he was an untraditional American Idol. I can't believe they let that hipster guy with that awful hat and weak vocals stay at all.
I wasn't a huge fan of David's song choice, but he still did something interesting with it, and he's a true musician, so I liked that about him. I just don't understand why he got hosed while some others who were quite mediocre got a tounge bath. I definitely would have put him in over hipster hat guy.
I love Laz, but last night was shaky. Normally I would think he doesn't deserve to go through, but it's not like anyone else was that impressive.
The problem here is that the judges are putting people through based on their body of work (and obviously producer biases) and it's not fair to America when we haven't seen everyone's body of work, just glimpses. Some contestants have gotten more screen time than others during Hollywood rounds, so it adds to the confusion. At this stage of the game America should be deciding.
They sent that one guy home who not only sang well, but wrote his own song, "I'm Better With You". I really liked him, and they sent him home. Nicky Minaj is already on my nerves.
I liked him too Rex. I didn't LOVE the song, but it was cute, and I liked that he was showing exactly who he is as an artist. But he was TOO cute, and too many girls would have voted. Can't have another WG win!!!
WG? That must be one of the seasons I missed. Who's that?