Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by LuckyCharm, Jan 17, 2013.
that was neither good nor bad which does not invite quality snark
I don't know this song, or who this is. Generic white guy. Are they going to put through a bunch of boring guys through attempt to ensure a woman wins? Is "I won't give up" the name of a song? He's saying that a lot.
Eta: that was Johnny
Well, hello, this just got interesting. Androgynous guy performing Rumor Has It by Adele.
They probably won't put him through. But I'm just happy it was interesting.
ballad # 2 has a creepy stare
# 3 (sorry in advance peter but i dont know their names and my suggestion to wear name tags goes unanswered) is at least interesting and keeps me awake
FWIW, to me Paul Jolley is a dead ringer for Evan Lysacek.
And it's "Everything I Do (I do for you)" and it's kind of flat and awful.
For Peter, that was Kevin
buttah - finally someone with a name i can remember and share with peter and i have nothing to say about that song. i mean it happened but i cant say anything else about it.
Good God. I agree with Randy. I have to go die now.
I wish you could have done what I know you could do. WTH does that mean?????
he did not stand in good stead
Chris performs Sittin' on the Dock of the Bay. While I'm grateful it's not a ballad, it's kind of nasally.
But not boring, which is at least a +1 GOE
headband is not much more than his headband
but youre right, at least it was an awful mid tempo as opposed to an awful ballad
i think nicki is letting her vagina do the the talking
Devon the barista has a sob story. I'm predicting a ballad.....
YES! Ballad #4 some generic crap about chasing dreams or some crap. Is some of this not in English or is his enunciation really bad?
Interesting voice, but zzzzzzzzzzz
i thought DEVON's singing in the spanish part was weaker but on a lukewarm night, easily one of the better ones
Elijah brings us ballad #5
I don't know this song either. Something about talking to the moon.
elijah's high parts were weird, like a werewolf whose voice is still changing
but keith thinks his coat is the coat of a star
Is this the best Idol has got? He was off tune half of the song. At least the Voice has Adam Levine and Blake Shelton.
i think they eliminated all the boys who can sing so a girl can win. but i was underwhelmed by the girls too.
It really is starting to look like they chose a bunch of guys who would have almost no chance of winning. Even if they have some talent and are not completely weird, they must be forcing them to sing boring and forgetful ballads. They don't stand a chance.
This Elton John guy is no better than most people I hear singing at karaoke. What in the world did he do to get through? That should never have even gone to Hollywood.
I missed Charlie. According to Keith, I was the only person who wandered away from my tv. What did he do?
i think charlie has had stronger vocals in prev rounds. people who already like him wont care. i also think nicki has pms because i know it makes me say some weird stuff too.
Another ballad. I'm going to have to wander off again.
Robert Plant made a great record with Allison Krauss. Yes, randy, that's what he's most known for....
Curtis closes the night with a -wait for it! - generic ballad!
the phrase raised in the church makes me picture someone putting a cardboard box in the church basement and living off the remnants of the potluck suppers
oh I'm glad Charlie made it.. even though he looked very nervous - (I missed him).. he's quirky - I like quirky he looks like he gives a nice hug too
Which guys made it? I couldn't sit through another boring ballad by a socially awkward shemale.
Devon, Curtis, the guy who sang the first Keith Urban song, Charlie and some other boring guy.
I think so too!
Charlie! Charlie! Charlie!