2012-13 U.S. JGP Assignment Predictions/Speculation/Discussion

Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by Sylvia, Jun 1, 2012.

  1. Jun Y

    Jun Y Well-Known Member

    1,141
    291
    83
    Moeller is hardly the first junior skater to copy Abbott's Muse FS last season. I saw another junior skater at Liberty who also used the same music. Moeller is clearly and intentionally imitating Abbott's movements, down to the entry to his 2A jump and a lot of the arms and expression. Although "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery," I personally find such detailed and vivid imitation slightly disturbing and would rather see younger skaters try on their own styles that are appropriate for their age.
     
  2. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,491
    4,865
    113
    Spencer Howe (N3) has replaced Lukas Kaugars (J5) at the JGP in Lake Placid (ETA: I've cross-posted this update in the JGP Entries thread in Kiss and Cry). I'm told Kaugars is dealing with an injury (likely the main factor in his subpar performances at Glacier Falls) and I assume he should be able to get a later assignment once he is fully healed.

    Howe's highest competition total score this summer was at L.A. Open in July -- 158.42 (109.67 FS) and he finished 4th in Junior Men at Glacier Falls earlier this month.
     
    Last edited: Aug 17, 2012
  3. oleada

    oleada Well-Known Member

    29,018
    3,877
    113
    I don't understand why the USFS isn't investing in younger skaters with good summer seasons such as Long and Edmund; instead sending older skaters like Cesario and skaters with much poorer summer seasons like Baga or Jiang, just because they placed higher at Nationals, which was like 8 months ago. I know this conversation happens every year, but it's still so :wall:

    IMO, the Senior B circuit would be a good place for skaters like Lam or Cesario, and letting young promising skaters like Long, Miller, Edmunds etccompete in the JGP.
     
  4. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,100
    634
    113
    The only way I can see skaters like Edmunds in the early JGPs is 1) if USFS decides at some point to put a cap on how many JGP seasons an age-eligible skater can do or 2) USFS somehow manages to lobby ISU into giving senior Bs more weight (like counting seasons best)

    None of that will happen this season of course (but perhaps for the next Olympic cycle?). But if nothing is done, the JGP crowding will get worse and worse each season because the GPs are harder to land and no JGP-eligible skaters want senior Bs . :(

    OF course, USFS can also put all these skaters into one summer comp and let the results determine JGP assignments, but I don't see that happening any time soon either. :(

    On a different topic, Spencer Howe :cheer: (Bummer for Lucas)
     
    Last edited: Aug 17, 2012
  5. skfan

    skfan Member

    404
    20
    18
    they haven't assigned jiang yet. i'm saving my indignation for a fitting occasion :lol:

    ooh... or maybe... just to forestall anger over a) jiang being skipped over for keiser, or b) jiang being assigned ahead of barbie long, USFS will assign barbie long and mariah bell to the next JGP? bell at least beat edmunds in glacier falls Jr ladies final! :p this way they can avoid the ire of the people who might be up in arms over jiang vs. keiser. although the edmunds folks will be at their door with the pitchforks :rofl:
     
  6. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    The Canadian system, which is being used this year, makes much more sense.
     
  7. mgobluegirl

    mgobluegirl Well-Known Member

    2,053
    153
    63
    Yes, but Canada also has far fewer skaters to spread the wealth between. I'm ok with how assignments have gone so far. I hope Edmunds gets one eventually because I think her development will really benefit from it, but I'm still of the mindset that she will get one. And so far no one has been assigned who has shown that they are clearly not ready, the way Daniels looked last year going into her JGP (just as an example, not to pick on Daniels specifically. Speaking of which, where has she been this summer? Is she skating?)
     
  8. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,491
    4,865
    113
    Last I heard, McKinzie Daniels has left Colorado Springs and returned home to Springfield, IL. I don't know what her plans are. She hasn't competed yet this summer, which is likely why Yasmin Siraj, who placed behind Daniels at Nationals and already has competed this summer, is listed as a JGP alternate ahead of Daniels (in response to skfan's question above).
     
    Last edited: Aug 17, 2012
  9. skfan

    skfan Member

    404
    20
    18
    ^ thank you Sylvia. it all makes sense now.

    there's a lot i like about mckinzie daniels' skating, so i would be happy if she continued, but whatever path she chooses, best of luck to her.
     
  10. sammyf

    sammyf Well-Known Member

    2,259
    182
    63
    Well since the reserve team has been updated, Leah Keiser, Nina Jiang, Shotaro Omori, Kaitlin Hawayek & Jean-Luc Baker have all been added, so that's 99% your team for JGP Turkey since skaters are only added to the reserve team after getting an international.
     
  11. skfan

    skfan Member

    404
    20
    18


    wow. very impressive deductive powers! ^__^ i never would have expected jiang to get a JGP before barbie long. :cold:

    when it becomes official, it'll prove that jlai is clairvoyant when it comes to USFS! :) jlai said jiang would likely get one because USFS won't upset the apple cart by giving keiser one without giving jiang one.

    now jlai, if i may venture a question, how much will ice network cost us the 2013-14 oly season, and how much coverage can we expect? :p
     
    Last edited: Aug 18, 2012
  12. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,100
    634
    113
    I'm not clairvoyant. I'm a frustrated fan seeing the same thing every year. :wall:

    Long and Edmunds so deserve an early assignment. :blah:

    Icenetwork subscription next season is about $40 if you are not a USFS member and $20 if you are. There's a thread about that http://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/showthread.php?t=84517&page=7. Don't know about Oly season
     
    Last edited: Aug 18, 2012
  13. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,100
    634
    113
    It's USFS tradition to send jr ladies who ranked 4th and 5th at US nationals to something, so USFS may very well send Long and Bell to the 5th JGP, leaving fewer second assignments for the pool. But that will still leave Edmunds without one.
     
  14. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,491
    4,865
    113
    Not sure what you mean about "tradition" since I can think of one 5th place finisher not that long ago who didn't get anything.

    At least Barbie Long and Mariah Bell did get to compete at Gardena Spring Trophy in Italy this past April.
    ETA: In retrospect, I wish USFS also could have sent Polina Edmunds - I recall they sent 3 Junior men to Gardena several years ago.
     
    Last edited: Aug 18, 2012
  15. Jenna

    Jenna Well-Known Member

    7,139
    313
    83
    The fact that Jiang has been assigned before Long, Bell, or Edmunds is, IMO, absolute bull****. Nina didn't have ONE good competition this summer, and she also bombed her FS at Nationals. So, we're assigning her to a JGP event based on one good short from January? Absurd. ABSURD. :mad:

    Long and Edmunds, especially, have had incredible summer competition results, both landing 3-3 on several instances, while Jiang struggles to land 3Lz alone.

    Bell has had her rough outings, but she's also had a few good ones. Nina has not.
     
  16. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,658
    351
    83
    Nina at least attempted difficult content at Skate Detroit, but she had lots of falls so it doesn't mean that much. I guess that they are holding off sending Long, Bell, and Edmunds with the theory that they can always be sent next year. Senior ladies (really up to around 15th or 16th at Nationals) have generally been given priority for JGP assignments along with the 1st-3rd place finishers in junior, REGARDLESS of summer competition results. Then after that, summer comps come into consideration. This isn't really a new trend, yes it sucks and you would think after what happened with Lindsay Davis, Lauren Dinh, McKinzie Daniels, etc. and then Vanessa Lam and Gracie Gold winning golds they would reconsider, but they haven't and I guess that's the way the cookie crumbles.
     
  17. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,100
    634
    113
    I guess I didn't phrase it quite right. :eek: In the past, USFS usually went with nationals ranking and in turns of JGP assignments, went down the junior ladies list and stopped usually halfway or more than halfway through the 12-14 junior ladies who competed at nationals (with some exceptions)

    But now with fewer JGP and GP assignments available, who knows who will get an assignment? :(

    ETA: Come to think of it, it's just as likely Long gets one in the 5th JGP along with a girl with a second assignment.
     
    Last edited: Aug 18, 2012
  18. skfan

    skfan Member

    404
    20
    18

    by the time USFS selects for JGP#5, will they have results for both JGP1 & JGP2--or only JGP1 results-- in hand?


    Sylvia, may i ask who was the recent 5th place finisher who didn't get anything? what were the circumstances that year? and will the later JGP's over lap with the dates for US regionals?
     
  19. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    I don't agree with Baga getting an assigment before Long and Edmunds.

    She was 10th at US Nationals, which isn't a fantastic result and she's a skater doing 3toe/2toe in her SP whilst Long and Edmunds are both capable of landing 3lutz/3toe IIRC.

    And now it looks like Jiang - whose Summer outings have been very disappointing so far - is getting an assigment as well. :rolleyes:
     
  20. pinky166

    pinky166 Well-Known Member

    10,658
    351
    83
    One thing I am thinking of is that there are now only 6 spots at the JGPF so maybe only skaters who place 1st, 2nd, or 3rd in their first events will be assigned to a 2nd, as the odds aren't great for someone placing 4th in one event to qualify. In the past, 4th place finishers were usually given a 2nd event, and last season even 5th and 6th place finishers, so this season, if they change that up, more girls could get sent meaning there would be space for Long, Edmunds, and Bell to all get assigned.

    Also is it possible Nina and/or Leah might be getting assigned to a senior B? They do skate as seniors nationally, after all, and the team for Nebelhorn is usually announced around this time.
     
  21. Marco

    Marco Missing Ziggy

    11,556
    1,399
    113
    How did Long and Edmunds place at Nationals last season?
     
  22. johndockley92

    johndockley92 New Member

    474
    22
    0
    I also disagree with Baga getting any assignment (she hasn't showed much promise in awhile), but I think Nina has earned her first assignment. She's done well in the past and I think would do easily better than Bell. Whether she'd do better than Long or Edmunds is questionable, but her second mark will hold up better internationally than those two.
     
  23. haribobo

    haribobo Well-Known Member

    6,635
    615
    113
    2012 Nationals

    SENIOR
    8 Angela Wang 158.66 16 6
    9 Vanessa Lam 157.62 7 9
    10 Kiri Baga 149.38 14 10
    11 Nina Jiang 146.42 8 12
    12 Leah Keiser 145.55 10 11
    13 McKinzie Daniels 140.42 15 14
    14 Joelle Forte 139.82 17 13
    15 Yasmin Siraj 138.83 11 15

    JUNIOR
    1 Gracie Gold 178.92 1 1
    2 Ashley Cain 155.48 3 2
    3 Hannah Miller 149.68 2 4
    4 Barbie Long 144.57 5 3
    5 Mariah Bell 136.90 6 5
    6 Polina Edmunds 134.06 4 6
     
  24. her grace

    her grace Well-Known Member

    1,116
    197
    63
    The reduction of senior GP spots has contributed to this squeeze of the second tier American seniors staying on the JGP. In the past, Lam and Cesario would probably have been assigned to the GP. Now there's not room for them (or the political will to put them there: Both have higher SB scores than Gao).

    Can you blame them for not wanting to do senior Bs? Senior Bs aren't the second-best place to compete. Clearly, JGPs are. Competing in a JGP gets one the all-important season best score and a better shot at world standing points since points are given below 5th place. I can't imagine Lam, Cesario, Baga, et. al., wanting to be sent to the third-best place to compete while being eligible for the second tier.

    The federation also wants to reward the skaters who placed the highest at nationals. It's no wonder that the top-tier finishers get the GP, the next-best seniors get JGP and medalists from juniors get JGP. I do think USFS should deviate from strict national results after the top 3 in juniors and top 10 in seniors, but I can agree with them that performing well at the pressure-packed nationals ought to give one priority for the best internationals the next season.

    All the skaters assigned thus far have reached the 130 score that Canada set as their required minimum score.

    For not being as "promising," Baga has beaten Jiang at nationals as a novice, junior, and senior, has better international results, and put up a higher summer score this year than Jiang. I agree that Jiang has lovely basics and components. So does Baga, and on every objective standard, Baga is more deserving of an assignment. Of course, this is neither here nor there since both have been assigned.

    What I wish USFS would do, would be 1) to use summer monitoring to ensure readiness [everyone assigned thus far seems ready] 2) to use summer monitoring to re-rank athletes after the top 10 seniors and top 3 juniors, including those who were injured e.g., Hicks and Cesario and/or didn't qualify, e.g., Gold last year, and 3) to use senior Bs as a C level competition and assign the girls who get squeezed out of the JGP after re-ranking. If it was up to me, this is where I would put Jiang, Siraj, and possibly Bell. As it is, USFS barely assigns any lady to a Senior B, probably because the only athletes they consider are GP ones or ladies who've aged out.
     
    Sylvia and (deleted member) like this.
  25. jlai

    jlai Title-less

    9,100
    634
    113
    ITA! A question, however:

    Isn't there a new rule about skaters who have competed at seniors not being able to go back to JGPs or junior worlds? (Or did that rule pass?) If so, I can see age-eligible skaters not wanting senior Bs either if that keeps them from having JGPs further down the road.

    The big federations need to pressure ISU to give incentives for JGPF and junior world medalists (e.g. Yan Han?) to move up, IMHO
     
  26. Sylvia

    Sylvia On to Nationals!

    32,491
    4,865
    113
    At least Polina Edmunds has been added as an official JGP alternate at last! :D She and Jordan Moeller are the 2 new listed U.S. alternates.

    JGP #4 (Istanbul, Turkey) entries were published today (ETA: link & full roster are posted in the "JGP Entries" thread in the Kiss and Cry forum) and Team USA consists of:
    Nina Jiang and Leah Keiser; Jason Brown (provisional 2nd assignment) and Shotaro Omori; Kaitlin Hawayek/Jean-Luc Baker and Lorraine McNamara/Quinn Carpenter (provisional 2nd assignment) in dance.
     
    Last edited: Aug 20, 2012
  27. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    That score is totally irrelevant for US Ladies, though. There is much more depth in the US.

    Stealing Sylvia's list, those are the highest Summer scores of JGP eligible skaters (I am combining Senior and Junior and I don't know some of the names, some skaters might be too old):

    172.30 Vanessa Lam (Hidden Valley Open) - JGP France
    170.06J Polina Edmunds (Broadmoor Open combined final round scores) - JGP alternate
    168.48 Hannah Miller (Skate Detroit) - JGP Austria
    168.42 Leah Keiser (All Year FSC comp.) - JGP Turkey
    167.36 Angela Wang (Colorado Championships, Jr.) - JGP Lake Placid
    158.23 Samantha Cesario (Liberty) - JGP Austria
    157.93J Barbie Long (Broadmoor Open SP Only & FS qualifying scores added together) - JGP alternate
    146.25 Yasmin Siraj (Cranberry Open) - JGP alternate
    145.10 Ashley Cain (Cannon Texas Open) - JGP France
    144.23 Courtney Hicks (L.A. Open) - JGP Lake Placid
    142.56J Maria Yang (Liberty) - not in ISP
    141.80J Mariah Bell (Glacier Falls) - JGP alternate
    139.24 Kiri Baga (Skate Milwaukee) - JGP Lake Placid
    138.87 Haley Dunne (Liberty) - not in ISP
    134.05J Selena Zhao (Glacier Falls) - not in ISP
    132.83 Nina Jiang (Cannon Texas Open) - JGP Turkey
    131.76 Carly Gold (Skate Milwaukee) - not in ISP

    As you can see Edmunds is second on that list. She would be first if she'd have had the extra element you perform in the Senior routine.

    There's over 38 points between her and Jiang's best scores and 30 between hers and Baga's.
     
  28. Lara

    Lara Well-Known Member

    13,794
    1,471
    113
    Ouch, I didn't know just how much poorer Jiang had performed this summer. :( :wall:

    Surely Edmunds will get a JGP, I just hope they don't leave her to the end as with Gracie last year.
     
  29. Ziggy

    Ziggy Well-Known Member

    20,569
    1,599
    113
    Looks like it. :/

    Given there's only 6 spots in the JGPF now, I really hope that USFS does not assign a lady to a second spot unless she medals in her first one.
     
  30. sammyf

    sammyf Well-Known Member

    2,259
    182
    63
    Even if they only assign ladies who medal in the first one, 9 ladies have been assigned and there are only 6 spots left. Long and Bell will probably be assigned first, I think her odds of getting one are pretty small.