PDA

View Full Version : Skaters you want to like



Pages : 1 [2] 3

t.mann
10-08-2012, 06:29 AM
Buttle. zzZ

(But he was awesome at this Japan Open.)

victoriaheidi
10-08-2012, 06:40 AM
Julia Lipnitskaya (liked her better when she first appeared at Russian Nats 2011 than I do now)
Polina Edmunds
Yuna Kim
Angela Wang (sort of)
Adelina Sotnikova

Oda (I've always been a Kozuka girl myself)
Patrick Chan
Plushy

Volosozhar and Trankov (I never completely forgave him for the way things ended to Masha, and I had a hard time adjusting to them)

Virtue and Moir
Lynn and Logan (don't want to butcher their last names. I like them, but I have a hard time really loving their skating)

There are others, but I can't remember all of them right now.

essence_of_soy
10-08-2012, 10:23 AM
Elena Liashenko.

Only because she is still setting up for that triple lutz she started in 1995.

spikydurian
10-08-2012, 01:30 PM
NONE, too hard to try. Just like what I like.

michiruwater
10-08-2012, 01:36 PM
Michelle Kwan :shuffle:

Mafke
10-08-2012, 01:43 PM
Elena Liashenko.
Only because she is still setting up for that triple lutz she started in 1995.

Well she first has to finish that one she started in 1994 first. You can't rush these things.

arakwafan2006
10-08-2012, 01:51 PM
Elena Liashenko.

Only because she is still setting up for that triple lutz she started in 1995.

LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That was the worst lutz take off ever. Then that weird stroking. :scream:

danceronice
10-08-2012, 04:49 PM
Abbot. Does nothing for me.

I wish I appreciated Weir more consistently. (This seems partially related to his coach tinkering with his jumps.)

love_skate2011
10-08-2012, 04:53 PM
hay people the Title is Skaters you want to "Like"
not skaters you like to hate :confused:

wouldn't mentioning Buttle or Lysacek be reduntant ?

Braulio
10-08-2012, 04:56 PM
Tuktamisheva
Sotnikova
Plushenko
Yu-Na Kim
Evan Lysacek
Stephane Lambiel
Amodio

Frau Muller
10-08-2012, 06:04 PM
I can't warm up to the younger Russian ladies. I admire their jumps and spins but they seem bored/disinterested/robotic in their deliveries, especially Lipnitskaya, Radianova and Sotnikova. Leonova is a huge exception to the norm, as she is full of energy and excitement.

essence_of_soy
10-08-2012, 06:44 PM
I can't warm up to the younger Russian ladies. I admire their jumps and spins but they seem bored/disinterested/robotic in their deliveries, especially Lipnitskaya, Radianova and Sotnikova. .

They're kind of like having one doll with three interchangeable heads.

yossalu
10-08-2012, 06:44 PM
I always wanted to like Buttle, I really did. I can't even fully explain why I just never could get into him. Partly it might be because I clung to my favourites and did not like it when he beat them--I knew he was a better skater than Joubert in most ways, but he couldn't excite me the same way that Brian does (no, it's not just his arse). I always wanted Sandhu to have the kind of success that Buttle enjoyed, and though Sandhu was only ever in his own way I somehow couldn't love another national competitor the same way. So I hated to see Buttle get those great National, World and Olympic placements over them even though I didn't like that it bothered me so.

I started out loving Chan and liking Lysacek. Over time my enthusiasm for both of them waned and when I read posts from their biggest fans I could truly appreciate their talents and understood why people would defend and adore them. I agree with most of their placements over the years. I realise that my reasons for being turned off by them off-ice would not be turn-offs for me from another skater (once again, I use the example of Joubert). But they will never mean to me what an Abbott or a Takahashi mean, not close. This is even true for Yu-Na Kim and Virtue & Moir--they are amazing, but it is Mao and Davis & White that I adore.

I am embarrassed to admit that I do not always get into Volosozhar & Trankov. Last year's short program did not work for me, and though I forgive this sort of thing in Savchenko & Szolkowy I could not get past it for them. This can often be true as well for Pechalat & Bourzat, I only really root for them when I love their current programs. City Lights, love. That clock program, not so much.

I will say I do seem to have a great talent for finding the also-rans, the runner-ups and the headcases early on in their careers. Now I can only hope that some of my newer favourites don't end up in those categories and break my heart all over again.

flipforsynchro
10-08-2012, 07:04 PM
Skaters who have artistry as their best quality

lauravvv
10-08-2012, 08:22 PM
Skaters who have artistry as their best qualityYes, we know :lol:. For myself, sometimes I do enjoy watching skaters from lower groups who are not that technically good, but try to express something and be artistic, but that really can't be compared to how much I enjoy skaters who have both the technique and artistry. Because only skaters with very good technique can fully express their artistry on ice.

True, jumping technique may not be so important for artistry, especially when it comes to exhibition programs where skaters can do less and simpler jumps/throws (although good jumps can look beautiful too). In competition programs it's a bit different - simpler jumps/throws that are done cleanly won't spoil the impression, but numerous falls (or even one) and/or really bad landings can spoil the impression even with the most artistic skater. Beautiful and well executed lifts really add to the impression with pairs skaters/ice dancers. But, for me, skating skills are the most important part of skater's technique that really helps to express the artistry - especially with singles skaters and ice dancers. Sometimes even skaters with just okay skating skills can jump pretty well, or do really complicated lifts - but only in rare occasions that is just as artistically appealing to me as something that skaters with excellent skating skills could do. And really slow and/or ugly spins don't help with the artistic impression either :lol:. To sum it up - I do love skaters who's main quality is supposed to be their artistry, but only if their technique is on par, or almost on par with it (like Lambiel ;) - his jumps may not be the best, but they weren't/are not the worst ether, and his triple jumps and double axel look beautiful when well executed, but his skating skills and spins were/are just wonderful). But all the technique in the world won't help if I don't see enough artistry in a skater, or if a skater just doesn't excite me.

Sorry for that huge off-topic, but I just couldn't keep from answering.


Back to the topic: Yes, it's also Chan for me. But I am starting to like him slowly (those SS, and, as for artistry/performance - he's trying :)), although most likely I will never love him. Hanyu - last season it seemed so close, and I thought: "Here's a skater for me to watch in the future.". But, unfortunately, his programs for this season are a bit disappointing for me. I can't think of any other current skater whom I would want to like, but couldn't. Rather, there are some separate programs that I want to like but just can't. Weaver/Poje's new programs, for instance. I see that their FD is really good and beautiful, but it just doesn't do it for me (actually, one of the reasons is that, although the movements in it are beautiful, there is not enough of them, in my opinion). And this can happen with favorites too - I am far from ecstatic about Takahashi's new programs, although I want to like them very much. That has become a trend with Weir's programs. Sometimes I don't particularly like some program of Buttle. Now I almost dread seeing Abbott's new programs. And so on.

As for older skaters - I must say that I haven't seen everything that Berezhnaya/Sikharulidze have done, but from what I have seen I don't like them nearly as much as I feel I should. Probably I am forgetting someone else.

Fortunately, there's very little that I really, really dislike, and no one/nothing that I hate (imho, it's absolutely childish to hate a skater or a program). I either love it, like it, am okay with, or quite indifferent to it (except those cases when I don't like a favorite's or otherwise likeable skater's program as much as I want to like it - then I dislike my inability to get excited about the program more than the program itself :lol:).