PDA

View Full Version : Israeli federation objects to the new minimum TES scores



Pages : [1] 2 3 4

halfloopy
08-14-2012, 10:03 PM
Israeli federation protests the new minimum TES scores. They say they are set too high and are unfair to the skaters from the smaller federations.

http://www.iceskatingintnl.com/archive/commentaries/Minimum%20TES%20Scores.htm

misskarne
08-14-2012, 11:15 PM
Bit late now, isn't it? Why weren't they kicking up a fuss about this when it was coming in?

I mean, I agree with them, but why wait a few months before getting cranky about it?

allezfred
08-14-2012, 11:35 PM
Boris Chait is a stupid twat. He was warned that getting rid of preliminaries would result in restricted entries and he still went ahead with his campaign. He's responsible for this mess.

He could also learn how to spell Cinquanta's name correctly. :rolleyes:

misskarne
08-14-2012, 11:59 PM
Boris Chait is a stupid twat. He was warned that getting rid of preliminaries would result in restricted entries and he still went ahead with his campaign. He's responsible for this mess.

He could also learn how to spell Cinquanta's name correctly. :rolleyes:

So he dug his own grave and he's still complaining? :rolleyes:

2sk8
08-15-2012, 12:11 AM
Frankly, other than a mis-spelling, the letter seems quite reasonable and proper. Most on this board also thought the increases were excessive and arbitrary, precisely because it would so drastically reduce the numbers qualifying, thereby making it even more difficult for smaller federations to develop the sport and for figure skating in general to grow in popularity.
Good for him for saying what so many here think ;) - perhaps all the other similarly-affected federations should follow suit.

Vagabond
08-15-2012, 12:20 AM
I'm sure that Boris Chait is much more used to using the Hebrew and Cyrillic alphabets than the Latin one. He did spell "Cinquanta" properly in the body of the letter.

And as for the substance -- better late than never! The issue isn't going away.

Cherub721
08-15-2012, 12:22 AM
I find this ironic considering that Israel has stringent qualifications for who can go to the Olympics and will keep good skaters who qualified a berth via ISU procedures at home... but maybe that's the Israeli Olympic committee, not the skating federation.

The letter isn't that unreasonable; they don't seem to disagree with the concept of a minimum score, they just feel that the increases in the score are too much. I don't see what the ISU can do about it now, though.

kwanfan1818
08-15-2012, 12:47 AM
Boris Chait is a stupid twat. He was warned that getting rid of preliminaries would result in restricted entries and he still went ahead with his campaign. He's responsible for this mess.


He doesn't have a problem with restricted entries. He's asking that the minimum scores be set so that there are the same number of competitors in the SP/SD after preliminaries (30 for singles, 25 for Dance, and 20 for Pairs).

2sk8
08-15-2012, 01:58 AM
I find this ironic considering that Israel has stringent qualifications for who can go to the Olympics and will keep good skaters who qualified a berth via ISU procedures at home... but maybe that's the Israeli Olympic committee, not the skating federation.


Yes, that is the Israeli Olympic Committee, not the skating federation - and Chait was not pleased when they would not allow Katz to go to the Olys, so I see nothing inconsistent with his positions.

SamuraiK
08-15-2012, 01:59 AM
Twat or not, I hope other federations follow.. If they were strong enough to get rid of QR they need to get together and force the lowering of the minimun scores.. Its not too late for some damage control.

Jemestone
08-15-2012, 04:58 AM
Twat or not, I hope other federations follow.. If they were strong enough to get rid of QR they need to get together and force the lowering of the minimun scores.. Its not too late for some damage control.

Hmmm, allezfred summed up my feelings exactly.

You either have QR and lower the minimum scores, or you have no QR and raise the minimum scores. You can't have it both ways. Getting rid of the QR would have consequences, a fool could have seen this coming. And why should the host nation be responsible for the skaters hotel fees and stuff? Was that one of the reasons the smaller feds got rid of the QR in the first place? Tell the smaller feds to pay for all their skaters and lower the minimum scores or STFU and deal.....or just reinstate the QR, whichever is easier.

aliona22
08-15-2012, 05:18 AM
I'm surprised we haven't heard from Israel sooner... were they even able to send a representative to Kuala Lumpur to participate in the ISU Congress? Kind of unfair if they didn't get to participate because the meeting was held in a country that prohibits entry of Israelis... :shuffle:

misskarne
08-15-2012, 05:39 AM
I'm surprised we haven't heard from Israel sooner... were they even able to send a representative to Kuala Lumpur to participate in the ISU Congress? Kind of unfair if they didn't get to participate because the meeting was held in a country that prohibits entry of Israelis... :shuffle:

Wow. I didn't even know that. I mean I know there are some countries that prohibit the entry of Israelis, but I didn't know Malaysia was one of them. If that's the case, then that's really unfair and the ISU should have their butts kicked.

Zemgirl
08-15-2012, 05:48 AM
Frankly, other than a mis-spelling, the letter seems quite reasonable and proper.

I'm sure that Boris Chait is much more used to using the Hebrew and Cyrillic alphabets than the Latin one. He did spell "Cinquanta" properly in the body of the letter.
Do you think he wrote that himself? I'm not sure, to be honest, though telling Cinquanta to stop messing with the smaller federations suggests that he came up with the spirit of it. Anyway, Chait lives in the US, his English is probably better than his Hebrew.


I find this ironic considering that Israel has stringent qualifications for who can go to the Olympics and will keep good skaters who qualified a berth via ISU procedures at home... but maybe that's the Israeli Olympic committee, not the skating federation.

The letter isn't that unreasonable; they don't seem to disagree with the concept of a minimum score, they just feel that the increases in the score are too much. I don't see what the ISU can do about it now, though.
That's how it came across to me, too - that minimums are fine, but they are currently set too high, something many here have also argued. Isn't there a loophole in place that allows the ISU to change this in-season? I thought that was part of the decision that was passed. But in that case, lobbying in private should be much more effective than trying to embarrass Speedy.

Re qualifications for Israeli athletes, as 2sk8 noted, those are NOC crtieria, not something thought up by the national federations - they would probably love to send anyone qualifying to the Olympics. I've seen suggestions that Israel's relatively poor performance at the London Olympics may have been due in part with athletes chasing the (rather stringent) qualification standards set for them instead of properly training up to the Olympics. But sometimes you have to look at it as a learning experience for the next Olympics and to develop the sport.

Although it must be said, skating in Israel faces bigger problems than the current minimum scores.

Vagabond
08-15-2012, 06:24 AM
Do you think he wrote that himself? I'm not sure, to be honest, though telling Cinquanta to stop messing with the smaller federations suggests that he came up with the spirit of it. Anyway, Chait lives in the US, his English is probably better than his Hebrew.

Zemgirl, the problem isn't with his English, it's with his Italian. :P

It's not that easy to sort out spelling rules in the third alphabet you've had to learn, especially when it comes to a word in a language you don't know.

Let's cut the guy some slack.