PDA

View Full Version : Sophie Moniotte and Pascal Lavanchy



Pages : [1] 2

VIETgrlTerifa
08-08-2012, 05:21 AM
Ok, I'm going to admit to being a pretty bad ice dancing fan and say that I just recently discovered that there was another no. 1 French team with admirable world standing before Anissina/Peizerat (and after the Duschenays).

I never even heard of Moniotte/Lavanchy until I looked up results for the 1997 World Championships and watched the final flight of Lilehammer.

My question is that how can a team who were 5th at the 1994 Olympics, 2nd at those Worlds, 3rd at Worlds the year after, then 4th (over Anissina/Peizerat) in 1997 plummet all the way down to 11th at the next year's Olympics. There was no COP to account for the plummeting, so it must have taken a lot for them to fall so hard under 6.0.

Did injuries and whatnot really affect their skating that badly in one year that the judges had no choice but to place them so low or did politics play a big role?

I haven't been able to find videos of their Nagano performance so I can't visually compare them in 1998 to them in 1997.

I'm seriously curious about this.

I also like to know what the general consensus on this team is. Do people just view them as a transitional team that had success while better teams were developing then peaked correctly for Nagano or do people really think they had the goods to medal in Nagano? Their style seemed a lot more ballroom in nature than say Anissina/Peizerat and Grishuk/Platov and they seemed more into that style than venturing out. I wonder if their style hurt their reputation among ice dance enthusiasts when they are personally ranking memorable ice dance teams.

I also read that Sophie Moniotte certainly believed that politics killed her and Lavancy's chances in Nagano and gave up the sport in disgust. She didn't have kind words for Anissina/Peizerat.

judgejudy27
08-08-2012, 05:31 AM
I thought their performances at the 98 Olympics were really weak. The injuries and lost training time definitely showed. Ever since their peak in 94-95 they had struggled with injuries, missed the whole 95-96 season, and even though they were 4th at the 97 Worlds had clearly lost ground to the next generation of teams already, only coming that high mainly since A&P had an awful FD that year. However they were much stronger at the 97 Worlds than they were at the 98 Games.

While I agreed with the ultimate podium there was definitely bloc judging at the 98 Olympics dance event. Various stations even outlined the ordinals and it was fairly obvious. It probably impacted many teams, Moniotte & Lavanchy were probably sacrificial lambs to ensure A&P medaled, but their skating their was weak enough to justify it while barely going unnoticed.

berthesghost
08-08-2012, 05:47 AM
All of the above. Even at their peak, their style seemed old fashioned compared to the field. Then they had some pretty serious injury issues and during their time away felt they lost their federation's support and were sacrificed.

VIETgrlTerifa
08-08-2012, 05:51 AM
It was pretty clear even back then that Anissina/Peizerat clearly had that "it" factor and needed time to fully gel, while Moniotte/Lavanchy probably hit their peak prior to Nagano, so it was smart for the French Fed to back Anissina/Peizerat over Moniotte/Lavanchy (ala Davis/White over Belbin/Agosto in Vancouver despite B/A being reigning World silver medalists). It's just hard to fathom that M/L would place as low as 11th though without actually getting to see their Nagano performance. To me, that just stuck out.

Bournekraatzfan
08-08-2012, 06:20 AM
I loved M&L--so charming! I just adore their 1994 FD:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C90alK6nt4M&feature=related

I would love some recent news on these two, if anyone has any.

VIETgrlTerifa
08-08-2012, 06:54 AM
Sophie Moniotte looks like the precursor to Shae-Lynn and Tanith.

casken
08-08-2012, 08:19 AM
M&L's 98 FD
(http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XMjgxMTUxMzQw.html)
The quality is kind of crappy, and you may have to sit through two Japanese commercials too, but it's there.

I actually preferred M&L's Riverdance to B&K's as I thought the choreography was more developed and complete. It was nice to see some different connections and steps going around in curves instead of all of them being straight line like B&K's.

They clearly weren't at their best shape, but the performance was still pretty solid and I felt that they were at least better in the FD than Winkler/Lohse and Romanova/Yaroshenko.

The probably should have finished 8-9th, so it wasn't a huge robbery though. I always thought they were *slightly* overrated anyway.

PashaFan
08-08-2012, 11:12 AM
It's my birthday today & what a lovely gift to be talking about Moniotte & Lavanchy.
I loved their 98' FD. I thought when they skated it at the Europeans it worked better. The slow section in the middle was beautiful.
Yes, they were old fashioned but that was part of their charm. Their 95' Worlds OD & 97' Europeans FD still stay with me even now.
I just wished Sophie would have worn her hair different now & then to give their programes a better look.
Sophie Moniotte was a real lady. It's a pity injury got in the way.
Anyone remember their Gala routine at the 96' Lalique?. So lovely :)

paskatefan
08-08-2012, 12:12 PM
I always liked this team, and miss them to this day.

pani
08-08-2012, 01:34 PM
http://s013.radikal.ru/i322/1208/38/339506cc3508.jpg

http://s51.radikal.ru/i134/1208/2f/51066263d2ac.jpg

VIETgrlTerifa
08-09-2012, 09:34 PM
Their 1998 FD was actually enjoyable (don't know I was expecting different). Those presentation scores were quite telling, I thought. Even if they were deserved, it sure was a difference from their scores in 1997.

Blair
08-09-2012, 10:42 PM
I just wished Sophie would have worn her hair different now & then to give their programes a better look.

I used to dream about giving her a hair makeover. All she needed to complete her look were Mom Jeans.
http://www.kewego.com/video/iLyROoaftIgp.html

Bournekraatzfan
08-10-2012, 06:33 AM
http://s013.radikal.ru/i322/1208/38/339506cc3508.jpg

http://s51.radikal.ru/i134/1208/2f/51066263d2ac.jpg

thanks!

and thanks for the link, casken. I really enjoyed their take on Riverdance, and couldn't find their FD on any of my tapes. I think they showed it in only one of the broadcasts. anyways, glad it can be found online now.


It's my birthday today & what a lovely gift to be talking about Moniotte & Lavanchy.
I loved their 98' FD. I thought when they skated it at the Europeans it worked better. The slow section in the middle was beautiful.
Yes, they were old fashioned but that was part of their charm. Their 95' Worlds OD & 97' Europeans FD still stay with me even now.
I just wished Sophie would have worn her hair different now & then to give their programes a better look.
Sophie Moniotte was a real lady. It's a pity injury got in the way.
Anyone remember their Gala routine at the 96' Lalique?. So lovely :)

Happy belated birthday, PashaFan!

PashaFan
08-10-2012, 11:59 AM
thanks!

and thanks for the link, casken. I really enjoyed their take on Riverdance, and couldn't find their FD on any of my tapes. I think they showed it in only one of the broadcasts. anyways, glad it can be found online now.



Happy belated birthday, PashaFan!

Thank you Bournekraatzfan :D
I used to have their 98' Euro & Olympic FD on tape but they got lost when I moved home :(
I remember Sophie looking a little slow on the CD at the Europeans that year.

PishPosh9
08-10-2012, 05:49 PM
Ooh la la! I used to love them and Rahkamo and Kokko. Pascal was really just the cutest thing. :kickass: