PDA

View Full Version : Should I buy Nook or Kindle (or something else)?



Pages : [1] 2 3 4

Vash01
04-09-2012, 06:27 PM
I am so tempted to buy Nook right now, because every time I go to Barnes & Noble, it's the first thing I see. OTOH Amazon has Kindle, and it seems the books will be cheaper on Kindle, compared to hard copies.

If I buy Nook, does it mean I cannot use the books meant for Kindle?

I would prefer a color version, rather than B&W, but does it really make a difference if I am only going to read books on it?

P.S. I vaguely remember that last year there was a thread about this, but I can't find it.

taf2002
04-09-2012, 07:08 PM
I am so tempted to buy Nook right now, because every time I go to Barnes & Noble, it's the first thing I see. OTOH Amazon has Kindle, and it seems the books will be cheaper on Kindle, compared to hard copies.

If I buy Nook, does it mean I cannot use the books meant for Kindle?

I would prefer a color version, rather than B&W, but does it really make a difference if I am only going to read books on it?

P.S. I vaguely remember that last year there was a thread about this, but I can't find it.

I just got a color Kindle Fire & am loving it. It has books, magazines, music, video, movies, apps like Words with Friends and other games, & full internet access. I won't have to carry my computer to skating competions anymore. It will be so easy to post from the arena because the keyboard is much larger than my iPhone & the kindle is so much lighter than my mini-Dell.

If you buy books for Kindle, you can't access them on Nook & visa versa. We bought my kindle at Best Buy & it was on sale for $169. The cover I bought has a built-in stand ($25). I can't stress enough how necessary that stand it. If you have to hold your kindle all the time it makes your hand cramp.

One of the nicest things is that I was able to load all the music from my computer, both the iTunes & the Amazon purchases, which I'm not able to do on either my iPhone or my MP3 player. You can play it by Artists, Songs, or Albums & of course it will shuffle & it has a headset plug-in. The charging cord doesn't come apart & let you plug it into your computer. I was able to use my husband's smartphone charging cord in order to download my music but of course you can buy the extra cord.

Bonita
04-09-2012, 07:15 PM
I love my Kindle Fire. I call it my "toy" because otherwise I have an 8-year-old PC, a cell phone that makes only phone calls and is held together with tape, and a Generation 1 IPOD. I'm not into technology at all, but I love my toy. It is so easy to use and the video quality is great for watching skating.

I was generally against reading books on the thing (I just wanted it to surf the web at home and at the rink), but I actually love reading the books.

There are tons of free games you can download that are really fun (I recommend Crazy Casino, all the fun of gambling without the losing $$ part).

I can't say enough about the Kindle Fire, love it!

Skittl1321
04-09-2012, 07:16 PM
We have the kindle keyboard and it is fantastic. I have played on the Kindle fire, but it is more like an Ipad- to me, it is for a lot more than reading books, and that isn't what I want. I want a no-glare, "digital ink" reader, and the Kindle is perfect for that.

I also like that I can sync my Kindle account with the kindle app on my smart phone, so I can read when I don't have the Kindle on me (but the screen obviously isn't as good.)


My only regret is we paid more for the "no offers" version. I wish we hadn't. The offers only appear on the screen saver, and in no way effect the reading experience.

It is not color- and it does effect reading books with illustrations, or pdfs (like knitting patterns...). But for 99% of what I want to read- it is perfect. Not many books have color.

Zemgirl
04-09-2012, 07:23 PM
I have a Kindle keyboard, and didn't consider a Nook because it isn't sold internationally. My understanding is that both have their strong points, and you have to figure out which are more important to you. As an aside, I don't believe there are any color e-ink devices at the moment, and don't know if reading on a Nook Color/Kindle Fire is as comfortable.

Kindle: I find it very user-friendly, and if you're based in the US, you will get good prices on many e-books (curses on the international delivery fee!). Customer service is excellent; I have heard this from others and can also base it on my own experience. The Kindle reads AZW files (Amazon's proprietary format) as well as non-DRM'd MOBI and PDF. It does not read EPUB files, which are the industry standard; this means that if you want to shop elsewhere, you will need to convert your files (using Calibre), and if you want to do that to books with DRM, you will have to strip it, which isn't quite legal.

Nook: I've heard that's it's good but haven't tried it. Nook takes EPUB files, which means you are not limited to B&N. I have heard that their customer service is so-so.

Sony: AFAIK it's also a good option, thought maybe more expensive? Sony takes EPUB files.

If possible, I'd suggest testing whichever readers interest you and returning whichever ones you dislike.

I love my Kindle; it's allowed me to read a lot more than I did in the past and to access books I wouldn't be able to otherwise. Happy reading!

modern_muslimah
04-09-2012, 07:23 PM
I am so tempted to buy Nook right now, because every time I go to Barnes & Noble, it's the first thing I see. OTOH Amazon has Kindle, and it seems the books will be cheaper on Kindle, compared to hard copies.

It depends on the books. If you're buying books from any of the "agency 6" (the big publishers like Random House, Harper Collins, etc.) then usually the print copy costs more but sometimes not. For instance, some paperback copies from these publishers are actually higher than e-book copies of the same book.

In general though, e-books are cheaper than p-books.


If I buy Nook, does it mean I cannot use the books meant for Kindle?

I would prefer a color version, rather than B&W, but does it really make a difference if I am only going to read books on it?

P.S. I vaguely remember that last year there was a thread about this, but I can't find it.

For the first question, it depends. Normally, you would not be able to read Nook books on the Kindle and vice versa. However, if you're willing to do so, you can get around this and convert the e-books to the format of your e-reader and read away. Of course, you have to consider whether this is is ethical and whether you're comfortable doing this. :shuffle: However, I don't think this would really be an issue since both bookstores have a similar selection. There are few books that are only available at one bookstore or the other.

If you're only going to read books like novels, then there really isn't much different between the e-ink Nook and Kindle and their color counterparts.

modern_muslimah
04-09-2012, 07:32 PM
Sony: AFAIK it's also a good option, thought maybe more expensive? Sony takes EPUB files.

In the US, the new Sony model is around the same price as the Nook. Outside the US, I think the Sony is more than other e-readers. I have the previous model of the Sony Reader and love it. It also takes e-pub. Beware though that you can't read e-books from B&N unless you strip the DRM (which might not be legal).


If possible, I'd suggest testing whichever readers interest you and returning whichever ones you dislike.

This! Best Buy as all of the readers (Kindle, Nook, Sony) on display. So you can play around with them.


I love my Kindle; it's allowed me to read a lot more than I did in the past and to access books I wouldn't be able to otherwise. Happy reading!

Same with my Sony. E-readers really allow you to read so much more don't they? :)

Zemgirl
04-09-2012, 07:42 PM
Same with my Sony. E-readers really allow you to read so much more don't they? :)
Oh, yes - all those cheap books and freebies, and authors publishing their backlists, not to mention instant availability... e-readers are certainly wonderful for people who read a lot!

AxelAnnie
04-09-2012, 08:06 PM
I am a loyal Kindle user. I read 2-4 books a week. I looked into the Kindle fire, but read that if you do more than a couple of hours reading at a time, the e-ink is much easier on the eyes.

And, with the other than e-ink, you can't read in the sun........deal breaker for me.....what would I read by the pool?

I have been perfectly happy with my various models of Kindle.

Vash01
04-09-2012, 08:16 PM
Great info. Thanks everyone.

Dumb question: Would I need a wi fi to read this?

Zemgirl
04-09-2012, 08:24 PM
Great info. Thanks everyone.

Dumb question: Would I need a wi fi to read this?
To download books? Well, not necessarily; some models are 3G, and you can download stuff to your computer and then transfer it to your device.

You definitely do not need wifi to actually read your books; in fact, I believe it's recommended that you turn the wireless off when you don't need it, in order to prolong battery life.

If you want some more technical information, I'm a regular reader of Dear Author and found their e-book posts really helpful. You can use this one (http://dearauthor.com/comparison-table-of-ereading-devices/) as a starting point.

Prancer
04-09-2012, 09:43 PM
Past threads on the subject:

http://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/showthread.php?t=79474

http://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/showthread.php?t=81007

AxelAnnie
04-09-2012, 10:11 PM
Definitely get the 3G. Then you can download books from anyplace......with the WiFi only, you are restricted. One of the things I like best about the Kindle is that if I am reading a book, and realize I have selected a book that is part of a series, I can stop reading and download the first one...,...etc.

I am sure they all do that, but the WiFi only limits you some.

modern_muslimah
04-09-2012, 10:52 PM
I think only the Kindle offers 3G at the moment. The Nook, Sony Reader and Kobo (none of us mentioned them yet :P) all have WiFi models only. I don't think it's a big deal. My reader doesn't even have an internet connection. I download ebook files to my computer and then sync them using a program called Calibre (Zemgirl mentioned it previously).

When I had my Nook, I got the WiFi model and I was fine. It depends on the user. If you're the type of person who goes through books quickly, is on the go often and wants to be able to download a new book whenever you feel like it, the getting an e-reader with 3G might be a priority. However, if you don't need to download e-books whenever you feel like it, a WiFi reader might work. It really depends on your wants and needs.

Christina
04-09-2012, 10:54 PM
I love my Nook Tablet. It has expandable memory (the Kindle Fire doesn't), which means you can put movies onto an SD card and watch them where ever. I also download books from other sources and put them on my Nook.

It's color, and it is fabulous. Also, it has a better screen than the Kindle.