PDA

View Full Version : Your Favourite & Least Favourite Elements



Pages : [1] 2

jettasian
03-07-2012, 04:32 AM
Favourite:

Men - Footwork
- I always find it exciting and with great skating skill, it can be amazing. I can never get enough of Patrick Chan's footwork sequence.

Women - Spiral
- Simply beautiful

Pairs - Throw

Dance - Twizzle

Least Favourite:

Men - Spin
- Some spins are just ugly, espeically the donut and the Y spin. Three spins in LP are too much. I wish they'd take one off, and add back another footwork.

Women - Jumps
- They are just too weak

Pairs - Side by Side Spin
- Unison is always off, and then one partner has to slow down so the other partner can catch up. Simply painful to watch

Dance - I can't think of any yet.

paskatefan
03-07-2012, 11:18 AM
Favorites - Russian Split Jumps, Spread Eagles, Ina Bauers, scratchspins, camel spins

Least favorite - the "butt" spin

Frau Muller
03-07-2012, 01:06 PM
Favorite

For either Ladies or Mens Singles: a long, sustained forward spiral, capturing the soul of a beautiful piece of classical music

For Pairs: a high, sustained one-handed lift in only one position, going from one end of the rink to another (without clutzy shifts of position, grabbing of blades, etc.)

Least favorite

Pairs - any "girl grabs the skate-blade" move -- lift, death spiral, whatever -- done just to garner extra points

Singles - butt spin; any laboured, overly-complex, s-l-o-w footwork; a Biellman position attempted by any lady with thick thighs, no matter how flexible she may be

Aaron W
03-07-2012, 01:58 PM
Dislike
With rare exception, I generally find footwork sequences to be unbearably tedious today, especially from pair teams. Patrick Chan is one of the few I actually don't dread seeing perform the footwork sequence (I always look forward to his sequences).

I don't enjoy seeing skaters who are barely flexible enough to do the Biellmann spin position opting to stick it in their programs for purely math reasons. As far as execution is concerned, they deserve to be docked enough to avoid the points benefit of including the spin in their programs.

I'm sick of the death spirals with the various odd positions the lady takes and the lack of speed that generally results after changing hands. If a team can't maintain good speed (and a steady edge) after changing hands, execution should be hit hard enough to eliminate the benefit of changing positions at all. I'd rather see a nicely performed single death spiral rather than a crappy change-of-hand death spiral.

Like
A steady & well-positioned forward inside spiral. For the men, I can't help but think of Jeff Buttle. And for ladies, of course it's Michelle Kwan.

A sit spin with a straight back and most especially with the free leg extended parallel to the ice and the toe pointed. And a camel spin that's well positioned on the blade and well arched (again I'm thinking of Jeff Buttle here).

Pair team where the man gently places the lady down onto the ice during a lift dismount.

And what I like the most is seeing very strong stroking. Powerful skaters generally make me happy. :) See Gordeeva & Grinkov.

Jenny
03-07-2012, 02:06 PM
At the risk of being completely out of technik here ...

Dislikes


Spins where they have to rev up with a few strokes to get into it - if you can't get into a spin smoothly and effortlessly, I don't want to see it.

Biellmans and Y/egg beater spins - unless you have the flexibility of Shawn Sawyer, they're ugly and awkward.

Jump sequences that are too close to the boards, especially when they tack on another one just for points.


Likes


Agree that a well executed one arm lift with a gentle set down is always a joy to watch.

I do miss B&K's hydroblading - they had some wonderful positions, always perfectly executed. Not sure I'd want to see too much of it otherwise, but occasionally when a singles skater does it it brings a smile to me.

Complicated footwork ala Chan, Yagudin, Stojko and Browning - always a pleasure to masters of the ice and blade.

jettasian
03-07-2012, 03:15 PM
Ah, of course, the "butt" spin. Whoever does that should get an automatic -3GOE :P

barbk
03-07-2012, 03:16 PM
Likes
-Powerful, musical straight line step sequences
- spread eagles or Ina Bauers that last more than two seconds
- spins in a single position that are fast and fully extended
- long spirals
- old style LPs where top skaters were expected to deliver programs containing at least one of each type of jump.

Dislikes
- The meandering, slow, pointless step sequences we see all too much of today.
- Three jump combos. (Okay, there are a few exceptions, but they're very few, and the number of piddly three jump combos is far too high.)
- Blades to the head, and most blade grabs in general. (A simple limitation of one blade grab per program would go a long way towards solving that.)
- Pairs lifts that look like a series of gymnastics contortions.
- SBS camel spins that are too close. (Really, I'd like to see something like diving's penalty for coming too close to the board even if you don't hit it as a way of discouraging those risks.)
- Tango music.

midori
03-07-2012, 03:26 PM
Favorites:
Jumps, footworks, and spread eagles.
Especially quads, good smooth one-foot sequences, and deep inside eagles.


Dislikes:
Spins, especially sit spins!! Not only that most spins are boring to watch, but also my knees feel hurt when I see sit positions. Bending your knee more than 90 degree, standing on one foot, and rotate so twist the knee??? Is it even safe??

And I would not mind if they'd reduce or remove spin elements from mandatory requirements. I do not need to watch ladies' layback spins and men's change foot spins in SP.

julieann
03-07-2012, 03:59 PM
Least Favourite:

Men - Spin
- Some spins are just ugly, espeically the donut and the Y spin. Three spins in LP are too much. I wish they'd take one off, and add back another footwork.

Women - Jumps
- They are just too weak

Pairs - Side by Side Spin
- Unison is always off, and then one partner has to slow down so the other partner can catch up. Simply painful to watch



:confused:

I don't think you are watching the right skaters. Some do these move magnificently. My dislikes are mostly COP issues like death spirals and footwork that goes on forever.

PashaFan
03-07-2012, 04:02 PM
Like- A simple spiral (with NO pull up to the head)
Dislike- Ladies putting a double-loop on the end of nearly every triple jump.
It just looks messy & more & more are doing it:mad:

viennese
03-07-2012, 04:05 PM
Unfavorites

Besti Squats - Ugh. Even the name is kind of awful. However...some pair teams do these in tandem, in connecting moves, and I can't help but admire their control.

Blade grabbing/dog-leg/hydrant position - This should not count as a toe catch or a Biellmann. A move that says: I wish you were wearing dark colored leggings.

gkelly
03-07-2012, 04:10 PM
There is no move that I hate in principle. It's always good to see someone try something unique even if it isn't beautiful at first, and it's always good to see skaters who can take a move that risks looking awkward and make it look good.

But specific skaters doing moves that don't look good on them even at their best, just to earn points or just because it's trendy, is a different story.

Marco
03-07-2012, 04:31 PM
Favorite jump: tano variation jumps and jumps taking off directly from a MITF
Least favorite jump: 3 jump combos, Lipinski Salchow

Favorite spin: extended camel, Y spin, headless scratch
Least favorite spin: Russian catchfoot camel, most sit variations, I spin, Biellmann spin

Favorite steps: serpentine, circular
Least favorite steps: those with no clear patterns, those that take one whole minute to complete

Favorite spiral: extended arabesque
Least favorite spiral: catchfoot, hydrant

Favorite MITF: ones that last
Least favorite MITF: ones that don't last

Favorite pair elements: pre-COP ones

walei
03-08-2012, 01:10 AM
My favorite element of anything from skating has to be the side by side straight line footwork sequence in Ice Dance. I don't really like the circular version required for the SD this year so hope they bring the straight line back next season.

Least favorite element, ugly ugly spirals that look like inflexible rag dolls in pain.

RunnersHigh
03-08-2012, 03:40 AM
There is no move that I hate in principle. It's always good to see someone try something unique even if it isn't beautiful at first, and it's always good to see skaters who can take a move that risks looking awkward and make it look good.

But specific skaters doing moves that don't look good on them even at their best, just to earn points or just because it's trendy, is a different story.

ITA!!!