PDA

View Full Version : SAG Awards



Pages : 1 2 3 [4] 5

Jimena
01-30-2012, 06:03 PM
After last night I'm ready to come out of the closet and say I do, not, get the Michelle Williams love. I think she dresses crap at awards shows, and her little headbands and smug interviews make her look childish and stand offish to me.

She did an interview in the Today show and she was adorable. I like her a lot. I don't get her style, however.

I'll come out and say that I do not get the Octavia Spencer love. I didn't think there was much to her performance in The Help.

Allen
01-30-2012, 06:15 PM
I thought The Help was competently acted and made, but it isn't a movie that I plan on ever watching again or using in one of my classes, even when I teach films of the South again in the fall. Viola Davis was the best performance in that film, but she wasn't close to Michelle Williams in my opinion.

Jenny
01-30-2012, 06:38 PM
I thought The Help was competently acted and made, but it isn't a movie that I plan on ever watching again or using in one of my classes, even when I teach films of the South again in the fall. Viola Davis was the best performance in that film, but she wasn't close to Michelle Williams in my opinion.

I haven't seen either, but I do think that Hollywood loves a cause, and in their acceptance speeches and interviews, everyone is doing a good job of keeping the cause front and centre for The Help. I have to wonder if all the Hollywood people who employ domestics are patting themselves on the back right now for supporting this movie.

nlyoung
01-30-2012, 07:46 PM
She did an interview in the Today show and she was adorable. I like her a lot. I don't get her style, however.


I have no style myself - my hair lives in a ponytail and I spend far too much time in hockey rinks and on FSU - but I will take credit for the fact that my first cousin is Michelle Williams' stylist (she also dresses Natalie Portman). You may not like the look, but I know that her aim is to not look conventional, which is something I love about her. The color of the dress is fantastic. :cool:

Vash01
01-30-2012, 08:55 PM
I finally saw The Descendants and was pleasantly surprised at how good Clooney was. I'm not much of a fan, but I think that he would've deserved it if he won.

I adored Jean Dujardin in The Artist, though, and I'm rooting for him to win the Oscar.


I agree with you about the actors. I liked the Descendants as a movie better than The Artist.
Jean D. was better than Clooney, who was actually very good. I think it will be right either way between those two for the best actor Oscar.

Carmen Ovsiannikov
01-30-2012, 09:21 PM
....After last night I'm ready to come out of the closet and say I do, not, get the Michelle Williams love. I think she dresses crap at awards shows, and her little headbands and smug interviews make her look childish and stand offish to me. And what's with her latest accessory these days - Busy Philips in a mu mu!

......

I think that Michelle might be getting Heath Ledger sympathy points. Ever since his death it's as if she can do no wrong. That seems to have changed at tiny bit; at least with the fans. Lately in interviews, she has been using Heath's death to sell her image as the greiving put upon widow and I've seen some begin to criticize her for it. It's all about what she had to go through. I know they have a child together and she would have some feelings about the death of her daughters father but it seems as if she has milked that connection for all it's worth.

ITA with the headbands; IMO her hair is far too short to carry off a headband. It looks silly. It reminds me of the people who put headbands on tiny babygirls.

Angelina may be known for her gorgeous face but her body has never been that great IMO. I thought she looked nice at the Golden Globes but last night she went back to usual Angelina. She's always had the arms of an emaciated 90 year old; bony arms and claw hands. The way the gown hung emphasized it.

Rose Byrne what were you thinking?

Jenny
01-30-2012, 09:31 PM
I think that Michelle might be getting Heath Ledger sympathy points.

I wondered that too, but it's been four years, and they weren't even together at the time of his death. Like you said, that doesn't negate the fact that it had an impact on her and her daughter, but at the time everyone acting like she was a grieving widow when she was actually a grieving ex/mother of his child.

If voters still pity her, I can't see her winning on that basis. She didn't win in 2010, so why now? I'm speaking purely on politics and not actual performances here, but it's looking more and more like it's Viola Davis. Meryl will get a lot of votes of course, but "there's always next time" with her, and I think the days of getting an Oscar for playing someone of the opposite sex have passed - been there done that, even if you are Glenn Close. Haven't heard any buzz on Rooney Mara - sometimes Hollywood likes to award a fresh young face, but I don't think it will be this time.

ETA: Just double checking something in the official rulz. If I'm reading it right, for the nomination process, voting is by members of a particular branch of the academy, which means only actors were part of the process of nominating actors. For the actual award vote though, it's the entire academy. So last night we saw what the *actors* think, but what about all the directors, producers, sound guys, makeup artists, etc?

According to their websites, there are only 6000 members of the Academy, but there are 120,000 SAG members - all eligible to vote apparently.

cruisin
01-30-2012, 09:48 PM
I thought Emma Stone was the best dressed. SHe looked fantastic!

orbitz
01-30-2012, 09:50 PM
Meryl will get a lot of votes of course, but "there's always next time" with her,

I would hate for Streep to have to wait until she gets to be Kathryn Hepburn's "On Golden Pond" age before the Academy awards her with a 3rd Oscar. Streep definitely should be in a league above all the other two-time Oscar winners. I hope she'll win.

Jenny
01-30-2012, 10:06 PM
I would hate for Streep to have to wait until she gets to be Kathryn Hepburn's "On Golden Pond" age before the Academy awards her with a 3rd Oscar. Streep definitely should be in a league above all the other two-time Oscar winners. I hope she'll win.

I know! This is her *seventeenth* nom, but her only two wins were in 1979 (supporting) and 1982 (lead) - 30 years ago! I haven't seen all her movies, including Iron Lady, but I think she was absolutely brilliant in Devil Wears Prada and Julie and Julia in particular. I would love her to win this year.

It's Viola Davis' second nom - last was for Doubt, for which Meryl was also nominated.

Artemis@BC
01-30-2012, 10:16 PM
I would hate for Streep to have to wait until she gets to be Kathryn Hepburn's "On Golden Pond" age before the Academy awards her with a 3rd Oscar. Streep definitely should be in a league above all the other two-time Oscar winners. I hope she'll win.

The problem with Streep is that she makes it look too easy! She's 100% fantastic in everything she does ... it's hard to distinguish one award-worthy performance from another.

Based on an objective comparison, I think Streep is more deserving of the award, but Davis was pretty great in her own way, and I certainly understand the political motivations behind giving her the nod.

Artemis@BC
01-30-2012, 10:22 PM
Actor in a Supporting Role - Christopher Plummer (Oscar favorite)

I'm very, very happy about this. It's amazing to me that he's never won an Oscar, and only ever been nominated once before! (But then, arguably his best work has been on stage ...)

John 3 17
01-30-2012, 10:42 PM
I think she's somewhat conservative and quite devoted to her religion. Could that be why she doesn't dress with the classic red carpet styles of plunging necklines, dresses slit up the thigh and over the top jewels?


A fab dress does not need to be cut down to there or cut up to there. Just a dress that FITS. This one was frumpy, esp. the bodice. I missed most of the WNTW show she did, but I'm sure Stacy & Clinton took into account her modesty while still teaching her fit, fit, fit.

-Bridget

Vash01
01-30-2012, 11:45 PM
I know! This is her *seventeenth* nom, but her only two wins were in 1979 (supporting) and 1982 (lead) - 30 years ago! I haven't seen all her movies, including Iron Lady, but I think she was absolutely brilliant in Devil Wears Prada and Julie and Julia in particular. I would love her to win this year.

It's Viola Davis' second nom - last was for Doubt, for which Meryl was also nominated.

She was brilliant in many other movies too, but the Oscar always went to someone else.

Examples: The French Lt's woman, Out of Africa, Silkwood, Doubt, and I am forgetting the one word title of a movie about 4-5 years ago where she got the supporting actress nom. She was brilliant in both 'Devil' and 'Julia'. She should have won 4 Oscars by now.

Jimena
01-30-2012, 11:50 PM
She was brilliant in many other movies too, but the Oscar always went to someone else.

Examples: The French Lt's woman, Out of Africa, Silkwood, Doubt, and I am forgetting the one word title of a movie about 4-5 years ago where she got the supporting actress nom. She was brilliant in both 'Devil' and 'Julia'. She should have won 4 Oscars by now.

Adaptation? She was fantastic there and IMO should've won. And she should've won for Julie and Julia. I can't believe Sandra Bullock won.