PDA

View Full Version : Oscar Nominations Announced



Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 10

Vash01
01-24-2012, 10:29 PM
That didn't stop Meryl Streep from being nominated for a role in a film getting less than average reviews everywhere

You can't really compare Leo with Meryl Streep. :lol:

Vash01
01-24-2012, 10:31 PM
What a great list, Peter. I'd also like to add Liv Ullmann's nominations for The Emigrants and Face to Face and Ingrid Bergman for Autumn Sonata. Oh, and Valentina Cortese for Day for Night.

You are making the same mistake as PeterG. I am not against foreign actors; just foreign language films- and I am not against them; they deserve their own category, but other noms need to be for English language films (or mainly English; occasionally you do hear the actors speaking German/Russian, etc. but only in a few scenes). Actually, in general, the foreign language movies are much better than many Hollywood blockbusters.

emason
01-24-2012, 10:46 PM
You are making the same mistake as PeterG. I am not against foreign actors; just foreign language films- and I am not against them; they deserve their own category, but other noms need to be for English language films (or mainly English; occasionally you do hear the actors speaking German/Russian, etc. but only in a few scenes). Actually, in general, the foreign language movies are much better than many Hollywood blockbusters.


You keep insisting that the other film noms should be for English language films, but why? What's the rationale? I really don't see one; a good film is a good film and deserving of a nom no matter what language it's in.

caseyedwards
01-24-2012, 10:59 PM
Could a rationale be that the voting body doesn't really know the language so they don't really know the performance? They know the translation of the words but not like they know English straight off?

pat c
01-24-2012, 11:01 PM
Could a rationale be that the voting body doesn't really know the language so they don't really know the performance? They know the translation of the words but not like they know English straight off?

A good actor is a good actor. They (the voting body) should be able to tell the difference, but then I think they vote with their chequebook. Just saying.........;) I on the other hand, perhaps can't tell the difference and it doesn't matter to my chequebook.

overedge
01-24-2012, 11:03 PM
Not according to the majority of critics. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 76% positive reviews. (ie 140 critics out of 188 liked it) That's pretty good.


Everyone I know who has seen it did NOT like it. The general complaint was that there were too many action sequences, at the expense of things like plot and character development.....

Ziggy
01-24-2012, 11:16 PM
It's great to see "The Artist" getting so many nominations. Oscars usually are a total joke so it's really refreshing to see a good, arty film rewarded.

For the most part it's box office trash, as usual.

Tilda Swinton not nominated is an outrage and calls for self-immolation. :drama:

If Meryl Streep will get an Oscar for that abortion of a film, I'll gag. :scream:

What normally is the only interesting category at the Oscars, Foreign Language Film, is really predictable this year.

"A Seperation" should easily win, based on its universal critical acclaim and the tons of awards it got already.

Although given it's muppets like Beyonce voting, who knows. I somehow doubt that she has an interest in New Iranian Cinema (she should because it's amazing). :D


Really happy for Gary Oldman (agree with the "about time!").

I was thrilled to see "Paradise Lost 3" in the Documentary list -- would love to see Berlinger and Sinofsky win.

"Pina" has to win. It's an incredible masterpiece. :swoon:


And I can't believe brad Pitt was nominated for moneyball over fassbender.

They needed him to attend. :P

Although as Vash01 said, he deserved it for "Tree of Life" anyhow.


Another snub - and I understand she campaigned long and hard for it - is Angelina Jolie's In the Land of Blood and Honey. As director/writer/producer she was hoping for a nomination for Best Foreign Language Film.

Oh, what a shame. :EVILLE:


What happened to Madonna's song she won a Globe for this year?

What Jenny said. It's going to be on her upcoming album MDNA so it wasn't eligible.


I feel as if the Academy is trying to bring in younger viewers (the Rooney Mara nomination as well)

I totally agree with you on somebody being nominated for "Bridemaids" being :rolleyes: but hasn't Rooney Mara's performance received a lot of critical acclaim?


it'll be interesting the see if the nominated films will change distribution roll-out strategies, as some of the films that ended up being shortlisted were already retracting a large number of screens this past week before the nominations were announced.

Hopefully "The Artist" will get a proper, general release now. :)


Not according to the majority of critics. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 76% positive reviews. (ie 140 critics out of 188 liked it) That's pretty good.

I have no opinion of the film either but Rotten Tomatoes gathers all available reviews, the vast majority of which are worth as much as marks handed out at Canadian and Russian Nationals. ;)

Jimena
01-24-2012, 11:17 PM
Marion Cotillard (La Vie en Rose)
Christoph Waltz (Inglorious Basterds)
PenÚlope Cruz (Volver...or Vicky Cristina Barcelona)
Catalina Sandino Moreno (Maria Full of Grace)
Fernanda Montenegro (Central Station)
Roberto Benigni (Life Is Beautiful)
Catherine Deneuve (Indochine)
Graham Greene (Dances With Wolves)
Isabelle Adjani (Camille Claudel...or The Story of Adele H.)
Sophia Loren (Two Women...or Marriage Italian-Style)


I don't think you understood my post. I am not against foreign actors; I am referring to movies that are in other languages.

So I will stick with my opinion that no matter how good these nominated performances in foreign language (not foreign born actors) are, they should not be included in other categories. Yes, it will be disappointing to not see Marion C. or Roberto Benigni or Bardem in the best actor category, unless they are in an English language film, but it will be more fair overall.

Just to clarify, Camille Claudel, Volver, Indochine, Central Station and Maria Full of Grace are in French, Spanish, French, Portuguese and Spanish (with a little English), respectively.

I think the academy should definitely consider foreign language performances and scripts in their nominations. I don't understand how excluding them makes things more "fair". Sometimes, a foreign film gets noticed by chance more than anything and if an actor has a chance to have a bigger career out of luck, I say more power to him/her.

I bet there are great performances in American and British films that never get noticed and never get nominations. That's not fair either, but it's the way it is.

I don't think we should be against having a handful of actors in foreign films who, sometimes by chance, make an impact in the Oscar race. It's much better for foreign films in general when someone gets recognized in any of the other categories. And I, for one, tend to love foreign films.

DarrellH
01-24-2012, 11:25 PM
I believe under an older system the Academy used, the film would be nominated for foreign film one year, then the actors, directors, writers, etc. would be eligible the next year.

soxxy
01-24-2012, 11:32 PM
I believe under an older system the Academy used, the film would be nominated for foreign film one year, then the actors, directors, writers, etc. would be eligible the next year.

Good memory, that sounds right. Ingrid Bergman "complains" about it in her (gracious) acceptance speech for Murder on the Orient Express:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ky5sW4no_cg

AragornElessar
01-24-2012, 11:39 PM
So thrilled for Gary Oldman and Bret McKenzie!! Way long overdue for Oldman and as a LOTR fan who got to know Bret through his participation there and then w/Flight of the Conchords...So wonderful that such a talented guy is getting an Oscar Nom. :D

Also happy for Melissa McCarthy. While I won't be watching Bridesmaids as it's not my kind of comedy, I do really love her in whatever I've seen her in. To repeat myself in a way...So wonderful that such a talented lady is getting an Oscar Nom. :D

I'd love to see Glenn *finally* get an Oscar, but I also think it's Meryl's. Could care less about Best Actor as I'm so tired of George Clooney playing himself and getting rave reviews for his "acting" and the same goes for Brad Pitt. That's just me, but if you want to throw some rotten fruit or veg my way... ;)

No Madonna nomination for Best Song? Excuse me while I head over the corner in order to laugh myself silly over that one. :D

And for those lamenting the no Nomination for Michael Fassbender. I'm a Viggo Mortensen fan. I say this w/sadness, but welcome to our club. :(

I'll be pulling for The Artist on Oscar Night, as it's beyond fantastic to see this little movie that I'm guessing no one thought would do anything, get all of the buzz and recogiztion it's getting. Plus, I want to see that adorable Jack Russell up on the stage w/them again. :D

PeterG
01-24-2012, 11:50 PM
You are making the same mistake as PeterG. I am not against foreign actors; just foreign language films- and I am not against them; they deserve their own category, but other noms need to be for English language films (or mainly English; occasionally you do hear the actors speaking German/Russian, etc. but only in a few scenes). Actually, in general, the foreign language movies are much better than many Hollywood blockbusters.

You sound like you love the sinner, but not the sin. :P ;)

Vash01
01-24-2012, 11:53 PM
You keep insisting that the other film noms should be for English language films, but why? What's the rationale? I really don't see one; a good film is a good film and deserving of a nom no matter what language it's in.


Again, you are missing my point. I am not talking about the film; I am talking about awards other than the foreign film award- like best actor, best screenplay, as examples. I already explained the rationale in my original post- there are just too many foreign language films to pick up the best actor/actress/screenplay/anything else from. Only a few get the visibility to be nominated for those awards, so it is unfair to all the others that had great performances but they did not get the visibility just because the film was not among the top. That is the rationale- pick from a smaller pool (English language only) when they give a few token awards to non-English speaking movie actors/writers, etc. They are essentially ignoring other great performances by doing that. How do you know a great performance in a foreign language film only occurs once in 3-4 years? How do you know that only one film in 10 years has a good enough screenplay to compete with an English language screenplay? It's a matter of being fair to the whole world that makes movies in other languages.

I have no problem with foreign language films; I actually like them better than the cheap stuff Hollywood puts out. They do get their awards- for best foreign film, and I have no problem with it. I try to see all those that got the nominations, because I know there is a good chance of them being good.

Ziggy
01-24-2012, 11:56 PM
And for those lamenting the no Nomination for Michael Fassbender. I'm a Viggo Mortensen fan. I say this w/sadness, but welcome to our club. :(

Only Fassbender is actually a good actor, whilst Mortensen is appalling. :P

Vash01
01-24-2012, 11:57 PM
Just to clarify, Camille Claudel, Volver, Indochine, Central Station and Maria Full of Grace are in French, Spanish, French, Portuguese and Spanish (with a little English), respectively.

I think the academy should definitely consider foreign language performances and scripts in their nominations. I don't understand how excluding them makes things more "fair". Sometimes, a foreign film gets noticed by chance more than anything and if an actor has a chance to have a bigger career out of luck, I say more power to him/her. I bet there are great performances in American and British films that never get noticed and never get nominations. That's not fair either, but it's the way it is.

I don't think we should be against having a handful of actors in foreign films who, sometimes by chance, make an impact in the Oscar race. It's much better for foreign films in general when someone gets recognized in any of the other categories. And I, for one, tend to love foreign films.

It can't be fair unless they are considering all the films made worldwide, and all the performances in them, and that pool is just too big to make that determination, with just 5 spots available. Are you willing to give all the best actor nominations (for example) to 4 foreign language movies and just one in English? That won't happen, ever.

I never said anything against foreign films; I have already said I like them better than most Hollywood films, so you don't need to tell me how good they are.