PDA

View Full Version : Toller Cranston on the music chosen by today's skaters for their programs and COP



Pages : [1] 2 3

Maofan7
01-16-2012, 08:03 PM
Interesting article (http://www.edmontonjournal.com/entertainment/Skating+legend+Toller+Cranston+pairs+with+Edmonton +Symphony/6003283/story.html?cid=megadrop_story) about Toller Cranston. He also has some interesting views about the music chosen by modern day skaters for their programs and COP/IJS. The article reads:-

Skating has changed dramatically since this skater’s [(i.e. Cranston's)] heyday, and not necessarily for the better. At one time, certain music was associated with certain skaters. No more. “It began with the likes of Elvis Stojko,” [Cranston] says. “This isn’t a criticism: they were more interested in another rotation in the air than choosing music that was a creative launching pad.” Patrick Chan, the 2011 World Champion, is “a million times better than I ever was,” says Cranston, but the music he skates to is completely forgettable. “It seems to me the music now is second to technical abilities on the ice. That’s how you get marked. There’s no reason to be as bent upon being as creative as I was, because there’s no benefit to that. I was lucky enough to be in an age where the actual music you skated to, say for a world championship, was kept secret. It was a big surprise.”

At the heart of the debate yet again is COP/IJS. Its removed a lot of the artistry, musicality, and choreography from skating programs. Accordingly, I agree with Cranston that, as he puts it: "the music now is second to technical abilities on the ice." Skating should not be just about technical ability. The music is integral to a fully rounded and properly packaged program. A skaters artistry and musicality, and their ability to interpret a program, can only be fully realised with good choreography and music. The advent of COP has mean't that programs have been asphyxiated and stifled by an over-abundance of technical content, which has mean't that there far less room for artistry. Result: more monotonous and tedious programs than there used to be (with less choreography, and more and more competitors just skating through programs without paying any attention to the music, or trying to interpret what is behind the program). That in my opinion is why audiences and public interest have fallen, and the reason why TV coverage has dropped off. No doubt the COP supporters will disagree. But, if the spectators are going to return and if TV company's are going to start broadcasting events again, then COP/IJS needs to go. The ISU would have been better off fixing the old 6.0 system, rather than throwing the baby out with the bathwater as it were.

Its an old debate that Toller has reopened. However, with public interest and TV coverage at an all time low, it remains a debate of the utmost importance if the decline in figure skating is to be reversed. Here are a few of the old articles:-

Article 1 (http://www.iceskatingintnl.com/archive/features/Skating%20Fix.htm)
Article 2 (http://sports.espn.go.com/oly/figureskating/columns/story?id=3212691)
Article 3 (http://www.iceskatingintnl.com/archive/features/A%20measured%20fall%20from%20freedom.htm)
Article 4 (http://www.thesmartset.com/article/article11080703.aspx)
Article 5 (http://www.eiskunstlauf-ecke.de/announce/sonia_bianchetti-will_there_be_an_end_to_figure_skatings_decline.pd f)

nylynnr
01-16-2012, 08:20 PM
Accordingly, I agree with Cranston that, as he puts it: "the music now is second to technical abilities on the ice."

I agree as well. After all, if it's first and foremost wonderful music you are after, go to Avery Fisher Hall.

skatesindreams
01-16-2012, 08:26 PM
Hope that someone can attend the concert:

Skating legend Toller Cranston pairs up with Edmonton Symphony
Gold Medal Skates: Figure Skating’s Greatest Hits

With: Toller Cranston (host), Lucas Waldin (conductor) and the Edmonton Symphony Orchestra
When: Thursday at 8 p.m.
Where: Winspear Centre

Tickets: $20 to $75 plus service charges at ticketmaster.com or edmontonsymphony.com

MacMadame
01-16-2012, 08:48 PM
I agree that music selection is a lot different than when Toller skated. Back in his day, skaters routinely skated to music with 5 different cuts often different composers and pieces all slammed together and chosen only to show off different aspects of the skater's skills and not to tie together as a performance at all.

And yet a lot of it still managed to be forgettable!

overedge
01-16-2012, 09:14 PM
I agree that music selection is a lot different than when Toller skated. Back in his day, skaters routinely skated to music with 5 different cuts often different composers and pieces all slammed together and chosen only to show off different aspects of the skater's skills and not to tie together as a performance at all.

And yet a lot of it still managed to be forgettable!

That doesn't mean skating music now doesn't suck. It just sucks in a different way than it sucked in Toller's day.

I think Toller has some very valid points.

Aussie Willy
01-16-2012, 09:32 PM
I agree that music selection is a lot different than when Toller skated. Back in his day, skaters routinely skated to music with 5 different cuts often different composers and pieces all slammed together and chosen only to show off different aspects of the skater's skills and not to tie together as a performance at all.

And yet a lot of it still managed to be forgettable!
Toller = Disco Firebird

I totally agree. The problem still is that regardless of how much music there is out there to choose from, skaters tend to pick the same pieces over and over again. It has gone on for years. There are still many pieces that the moment I hear them I groan because I am just over them.

manhn
01-16-2012, 09:58 PM
Who doesn't associate Dragon with Elvis? What the hell music do people associate with Schuba?

flowerpower
01-16-2012, 10:14 PM
I agree that music selection is a lot different than when Toller skated. Back in his day, skaters routinely skated to music with 5 different cuts often different composers and pieces all slammed together and chosen only to show off different aspects of the skater's skills and not to tie together as a performance at all.



This.

The memorable music of the past was by far the exception and not the rule.

Subway
01-16-2012, 10:28 PM
I don't know - the artistry as actually scored under 6.0 (presentation which is when I was first familiar) is a technical mark too. It's this theatre-type verdict on how expressive you are or how moving or whose music was better or deeper or whose theme more significant artistically. That's impossible. We're not a sport then.

Just on this forum, one person's idea of memorable artistry is another person's Vegas kitsch. Another person's idea of classic is someone else's sterile. There's no consensus and it can't be legislated through judging either. You just can't.

gkelly
01-16-2012, 10:31 PM
Sabre Dance? Really? Sorry, but after seeing these (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=he4yEgRFrZg&feature=related&t=1m24s) performances (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MZkwxz6bBVo&t=1m4s) I can't see skating to that music as anything other than a joke.

snoopysnake
01-16-2012, 11:06 PM
Who doesn't associate Dragon with Elvis? What the hell music do people associate with Schuba?

Schubie-doobie-do, where are you?
You got some work to do now....

:scream::P:yikes::slinkaway

Couldn't resist!

I sure wish I could attend that concert!

professordeb
01-16-2012, 11:11 PM
When I first started to watch skating it was back in the 60's whenever ABC decided to throw us a bone with the occassional treat by CBC. I remember hearing wierd cuts of music and for the life of me I couldn't understand why someone would use multiple pieces of music with with to skate. Puzzled, until some kind commentator (I don't remember who but just as likely to be Uncle Dick) explained it - sort of. I still wasn't buying it but since this was what was seemingly required, I put up with the music to see the skating.
Then came the early 90's when I got to see more on TV and I found the internet. More and more skaters were using one piece of music - or at least one "movie" track. At least with the movie tracks, I found I could at least resonate with some of what people were trying to express on ice.
Do I miss the days of those bad music cuts? NOPE!
Do I like all the music or cuts currently used today? NOPE
and I doubt I ever will.
For me it has always been the music supporting what was taking place on the ice instead of it being the other way around. Some music is just SOOOOOOO big, that it carries the skater rather than the music and skater working together to weave a spell under which I would love to fall under.

kwanfan1818
01-16-2012, 11:30 PM
I find neither Vivaldi's "Four Seasons" nor "Aranjuez" forgettable music.

Penniless Rostrum
01-17-2012, 02:26 AM
OH dearest Toller, I wish they could bring back the mould you broke and make a younger one of you to watch cause all my VHS tapes have gotten old and rotten too!!! My deepest deepest love and adoration to you.:rollin:

nubka
01-17-2012, 03:54 AM
Interesting article (http://www.edmontonjournal.com/entertainment/Skating+legend+Toller+Cranston+pairs+with+Edmonton +Symphony/6003283/story.html?cid=megadrop_story) about Toller Cranston. He also has some interesting views about the music chosen by modern day skaters for their programs and COP/IJS. The article reads:-

Skating has changed dramatically since this skater’s [(i.e. Cranston's)] heyday, and not necessarily for the better. At one time, certain music was associated with certain skaters. No more. “It began with the likes of Elvis Stojko,” [Cranston] says. “This isn’t a criticism: they were more interested in another rotation in the air than choosing music that was a creative launching pad.” Patrick Chan, the 2011 World Champion, is “a million times better than I ever was,” says Cranston, but the music he skates to is completely forgettable. “It seems to me the music now is second to technical abilities on the ice. That’s how you get marked. There’s no reason to be as bent upon being as creative as I was, because there’s no benefit to that. I was lucky enough to be in an age where the actual music you skated to, say for a world championship, was kept secret. It was a big surprise.”

I wonder how he managed that? Wouldn't he have skated to that music at Canadian Nationals before Worlds? :confused: