PDA

View Full Version : Who is a better skater: Alena Leonova or Rachel Flatt?



Pages : [1] 2 3

krenseby
07-14-2011, 08:58 PM
The general public, when watching skaters nowadays, may not so clearly understand which skater is overall better than another. COP is complicated enough that a comparison of any two skaters may lead to a long discussion rather than a quick assessment. Nevertheless, people on this board do have a good feel for what makes one skater better than another and may be able to explain it clearly and succinctly. So let's see how we do with a comparison of the following two skaters: Alena Leonova and Rachael Flatt. Who do you consider a better skater and why? (Note: In answering this question, do not restrict yourself to the last World Championships but consider the way these two women have skated overall over the last two years.)

briancoogaert
07-14-2011, 09:01 PM
This thread will turn into a "who is the worst ?" very quickly !

judgejudy27
07-14-2011, 09:06 PM
Leonova would have won a medal at Worlds this year without her one mistake. Flatt is not capable of winning a medal at Worlds even skating her best. So I guess Leonova.

kwanatic
07-14-2011, 09:19 PM
Rachael, at her core, is a solid skater. Her technique is a bit weird on a few of her jumps (particularly her lean and rock entrance into her lutz), she lacks speed at times as well, but overall, she's a solid skater. What Rachael lacks is appeal. There's something about her that just doesn't connect with people. I find her a bit boring to watch at times...it's a combination of bad music, choreography, dress, and other factors. She's missing that spark that skaters have that set them apart and make them stand out...

Alena, to me, has decent speed and big jumps. She eerily reminds me of Irina Slutskaya when I watch her skate.:eek: There's an energy and personality about her when she's on the ice that makes her fun to watch. OTOH, there isn't a speck of refinement to her movements. There is nothing graceful or elegant about her skating to me. She's a big ball of infectious energy and that is what she plays to in her programs and it works for her...

So, IMO, I think both skaters have their merits. Similarly, both skaters are lacking certain things. If it comes down to a choice of who I'd prefer to watch, I'd have to go with Alena. I kinda hate her style of skating, but I do find her my-head's-on-fire hair, fingernailed gloves and chicken dance spirals entertaining albeit wholly unrefined. For me, Rachael's skating lacks excitement or feeling which, in turn, makes her a bit blah to watch most of the time...

gkelly
07-14-2011, 10:42 PM
Without having compared them live, I'd say they're pretty similar. Either one could beat the other on any given day, depending who's having a better day.

El Rey
07-14-2011, 11:05 PM
Leonova has more entertaining hair.

museksk8r
07-14-2011, 11:27 PM
Leonova is better and a lot more interesting! :cheer2: Flatt completely lost me when she skated to East of Eden and copied Lysacek's cringe-worthy flailing (throw your arms out of their sockets without interpreting the music only to leave your audience saying or wondering WTF?! :confused:) in her footwork sequence. :scream:

Jenna
07-14-2011, 11:48 PM
All around, Alena Leonova.

Ziggy
07-15-2011, 12:06 AM
Alena Leonova, obviously.

Whilst there are some weaknesses in her skating, she makes up for that with great attack and personality on the ice.

Rachael Flatt just defines bland.

blue_idealist
07-15-2011, 03:12 AM
I think Alena is overall a better skater but lacks Rachael's usual consistency. Alena's definitely more interesting and her skating skills are probably better. Now that Rachael isn't even as consistent as she used to be, I really have to say it's Alena..

RumbleFish
07-15-2011, 06:05 AM
Flatt completely lost me when she skated to East of Eden and copied Lysacek's cringe-worthy flailing (throw your arms out of their sockets without interpreting the music only to leave your audience saying or wondering WTF?! :confused:) in her footwork sequence. :scream:

Her step sequence got a level 4 for doing a Lysacek's cringe-worthy flailing. I'd say it was worth it. ;)

Until last season, only way for skaters to get a level 4 on step sequences was having Lori Nichol put together their own version of Lysacek's cringe-worthy flailing. Just ask Flatt, Kostner, and Chan how they got their level4s and ensuing fat GOE marks.

Thank goodness that the ISU has finally come to realized this and changed rules for level 4 requirements. From next season, skaters will be required to flail through only one-third of their step sequences, not half like they had to until last season.

Vagabond
07-15-2011, 07:24 AM
Perkova (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ynu7gXcs1qk&feature=related) or Good Old Reliable Rachael (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AG6lUHYxUMY&feature=player_detailpage#t=57s)?

Gee, that's a toughie!

:coffee:

Finnice
07-15-2011, 11:02 AM
I prefer blandness to perkiness, so for me it is Flatt. :slinkaway But it is between apples and oranges, really.

Jaana
07-15-2011, 11:43 AM
To me they both are equally boring skaters, although in a different way. Flatt used to be more consistent, but is she that anymore? She has never been near the podium as Leonova was now (but the Worlds were held in Moscow:rofl:). Leonova has a better looking body type, but her over-the-top perkiness, awful. Neither of them gives the impression of having true feeling towards the music.

Japanfan
07-15-2011, 11:47 AM
Leonova is the better skater in terns of jump technique and basics.