PDA

View Full Version : Man dies after falling off roller coaster.



Pages : [1] 2

Badams
07-09-2011, 05:10 AM
http://www.wgrz.com/news/article/127015/37/Deadly-Accident-on-Ride-of-Steel-Coaster-at-Darien-Lake

He was a decorated war vet who had lost both legs and suffered a brain injury caused by a roadside bomb. He's not the first person to fall off of this ride.:( So sad.

nerdycool
07-09-2011, 06:36 AM
I'm curious what they'll find in the investigation. For a few summers back when I was in college, I was in charge of a large roller coaster, and so a few questions pop out at me.

First, was he wearing prosthetics or not? Given where his legs were amputated (above the knees), if he weren't wearing any, he should have been denied entry*. When the entire lower half of both legs is missing, it changes the weight distribution, and makes it very easy for someone to slip out in low G areas regardless of whether they're secured or not. It's the same reason why people under a certain height aren't allowed on bigger rides... need to be more bottom-heavy, and that doesn't happen when feet can't touch the floor when in a seated position. But we don't know yet if he was wearing any or not, so we'll have to wait and see.

The second thing that comes to mind is whether he unbuckled after the train left the station or not. I can't tell you how many people (coincidentally, usually guys starting in their teens all the way up to mid-30's) think a ride is more thrilling without the seat belt and refuse to buckle it in the station. Only after realizing the ride won't go until after everyone is secured with the lap bar AND buckled in with the seat belt, they'll reluctantly do it. But once the train leaves the station, off comes the seat belt, leaving only the lap bar in place... which is very very risky. I myself have tried riding without the seat belt just once, and it was scary. In the low G areas without a seat belt, your butt comes off the seat and you're held in only by the lap bar. I thought I was going to fly out, so once my butt got back down, you can bet I buckled back in mid-ride.

But if he was wearing prosthetics AND was buckled in the entire time... I just don't know.

*Going off the assumption that all theme parks have similar policies for their big rides.

Cyn
07-09-2011, 06:43 AM
http://www.wgrz.com/news/article/127015/37/Deadly-Accident-on-Ride-of-Steel-Coaster-at-Darien-Lake

He was a decorated war vet who had lost both legs and suffered a brain injury caused by a roadside bomb. He's not the first person to fall off of this ride.:( So sad.

Unbelievably sad and tragic :( .

Back in the 60's, my Great-Aunt was riding a "scrambler" at a local fair when the equipment malfunctioned with one of the "arms," resulting in it flying out of control into another arm, injuring several people and beheading one of passengers in the seat in front of hers. My Aunt was hurt, thankfully with minor injuries, but she to this day still has occasional nightmares from what happened.

I fell in love with roller-coasters and other thrill rides since the first time I found out I met the "You must be "THIS" tall to ride the "________," the accidents and resulting tragedies make me now glad my back injuries force me to refrain from getting in the queue -- it keeps me from pulling that She-Gal, fearless tomboy urge to say "fcuk it" and hop on. To this day, I definitely miss the adrenaline rush and the sensation of being twisted, turned, spun, and inverted while traveling at high speeds, and one of my biggest regrets is that I will never get to experience the amazing coasters, etc., at Cedar Point, Kings Island, and other parks with the major E-Ticket rides :fragile: (for you young-'uns, ask one of us old farts what an "E-Ticket Ride" means :P.

*******

On a similar and sad note, a fan at the Texas Rangers baseball game fell to his death after losing his balance and falling headfirst while trying to catch a foul ball for his son that was "flipped" to the crowd by one of the Rangers' outfielders.

Yahoo Sports Article (http://sports.yahoo.com/mlb/blog/big_league_stew/post/Man-dies-after-falling-out-of-stands-at-Rangers-?urn=mlb-wp11900).


The Brownwood (Texas) Bulletin identified the man as Shannon Stone, a lieutenant in that town's fire department and a fireman for 18 years.

*snip*

Horrifying TV replays from the Oakland broadcast show Stone positioning himself to catch Hamilton's throw, then tumbling over a railing as his young son watched. A man next to Stone tried to hold onto him, but couldn't.

*snip*

It's the second fatal fall at a major league ballpark this season. In May, a fan at Coors Field fell down a stairwell and died. Also, last July at Rangers Ballpark, a fan fell 30 feet from the second deck of seats while trying to catch a foul ball and suffered a fractured skull and sprained ankle.

AliasJohnDoe
07-09-2011, 08:03 AM
That really is a sad story. Interesting to hear your perspective of it Nerdycool.

Having the coaster fly off the track, as it goes around a corner at the top, has always been a recurring dream of mine. Scares the crap outta me. :yikes:

Jenna
07-09-2011, 08:15 AM
Both stories are so, so tragic.

:( A father and his son go out to a baseball game together, a classic American tradition, and this happens. The horrifying part is that you just never know when death can strike.

A clip (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQZ5zL4OtD8&feature=related) of the accident.

MikiAndoFan#1
07-09-2011, 10:55 AM
So sad. :(

Cheylana
07-10-2011, 04:07 AM
Many thanks nerdycool. By the way, that link now contains a video clip that says he was NOT wearing his prosthetics. So it sounds like he should have been denied entry. Yikes!

I can't believe it's possible to unbuckle a seatbelt after the train has left the station...or that people would be so crazy as to unbuckle it! :eek: I always assumed that thing stayed buckled until the ride concluded and the train was back in the station.

Cyn, your aunt's story sounds like a total nightmare too :(

nerdycool
07-10-2011, 05:15 AM
Many thanks nerdycool. By the way, that link now contains a video clip that says he was NOT wearing his prosthetics. So it sounds like he should have been denied entry. Yikes!

I can't believe it's possible to unbuckle a seatbelt after the train has left the station...or that people would be so crazy as to unbuckle it! :eek: I always assumed that thing stayed buckled until the ride concluded and the train was back in the station.Huh... I wonder why he was let on then. Of course, it's up to the workers at the ride to spot something like that, because one just can't assume that people will abide by "the rules." (my example would be turning obviously pregnant women away) Or maybe he sweet-talked them into it, or perhaps he even got clearance by a supervisor. My bet is that he just got in line and other than the fact that he was in a wheelchair, was mostly overlooked by the workers.

But yes, the seat belt portion of a ride is just a simple lap belt found in vehicles, and the rider has the ability to operate it at will. The part you're thinking of that secures a person and doesn't open until after the ride is done is the lap bar. Most rides that don't have have over-the-shoulder restraints (like the ride in question) will have both a seat belt and a lap bar for extra security.

Badams
07-10-2011, 05:32 AM
http://www.wgrz.com/news/article/127137/37/Mass-Congressman-to-Introduce-Roller-Coaster-Safety-Legislation-

According to this article, there are currently no restrictions on riders based on having legs for The Ride of Steel, but there are for other rides in the park.

When the ride first opened, a large man fell out. He didn't die from his fall, but the fall was responsible for them installing safety belts on the ride.

Buzz
07-10-2011, 05:32 AM
Unbelievably sad and tragic. My prayers goes out to him and his family. He is in a better place now.

nerdycool
07-10-2011, 06:03 AM
http://www.wgrz.com/news/article/127137/37/Mass-Congressman-to-Introduce-Roller-Coaster-Safety-Legislation-

According to this article, there are currently no restrictions on riders based on having legs for The Ride of Steel, but there are for other rides in the park. That's surprisingly unfortunate, especially considering the size of the coaster. Although technically he should have been held to the 54" height requirement they have for the ride if there wasn't a no leg policy in place... but it would have been hard to measure in his case. It was probably assumed he met it, and who knows... maybe he did.

But I guarantee that restriction will be unofficially enforced until they can revise the SOP manual and also on the sign at the entrance of the ride. And all the amusement park workers across the US will get a refresher course in ride requirements.

Cheylana
07-10-2011, 10:03 PM
There surely will be a lawsuit...unless he was found to have unbuckled his seatbelt mid-ride...oh heck, there will be a lawsuit anyway, which will be settled out of court.

Beefcake
07-10-2011, 10:48 PM
Where does it say that his belt/bar came undone? I didn't see that, and if it isn't confirmed I've got to say that it was the law of physics that caused this tragedy.

The victim's left leg was amputated almost to the hip. There is no leg to buckle in ... and only about a foot of leg on the left to brace against a rollercoaster's inertia. He could have easily slipped out when he "leaned forward" (as described in the clip), especially if the description that he came out toward the end ... meaning that it could've been coming downhill and slowing down rapidly for the ride's end.

RIP, poor guy. And deep sympathies for his family. Hero gone. :(

But, let's not assume that the ride operators or the ride are at fault. The victim had to have been told either directly or indirectly that his riding was risky, given that he didn't have legs to surely keep him in place. And even if he wasn't (yes, bash me for blaming the victim), he should've considered the danger and opted not to ride or to ride with his prosthetics on.

Cheylana
07-10-2011, 11:00 PM
I didn't say the guy unbuckled his seatbelt or that anyone at the park was at fault. My point is that when these things happen, the family files a lawsuit, regardless of who is at fault. Most juries would sympathize with an Army veteran who lost his legs to the Iraq War, so the park would rather just settle out of court and avoid the protracted litigation.

nerdycool
07-10-2011, 11:56 PM
Where does it say that his belt/bar came undone? I didn't see that, and if it isn't confirmed I've got to say that it was the law of physics that caused this tragedy.

The victim's left leg was amputated almost to the hip. There is no leg to buckle in ... and only about a foot of leg on the left to brace against a rollercoaster's inertia. He could have easily slipped out when he "leaned forward" (as described in the clip), especially if the description that he came out toward the end ... meaning that it could've been coming downhill and slowing down rapidly for the ride's end.

But, let's not assume that the ride operators or the ride are at fault. The victim had to have been told either directly or indirectly that his riding was risky, given that he didn't have legs to surely keep him in place. And even if he wasn't (yes, bash me for blaming the victim), he should've considered the danger and opted not to ride or to ride with his prosthetics on.It's unknown whether he unbuckled or not, but I did mention it as one of the things that could have happened before we knew any specifics of the accident. But I do agree with you that his death was likely due to the law of physics, and that there is nothing wrong with the ride... although I would want to take a look at the ride policies (there are probably more than what they list on their website and only found in the SOP manuals given to employees) and whether the ride operators were following them or not. And that will be key in determining whether to press suit or not for the family. Since there's nothing wrong with the ride itself, I don't think they have a case yet.