AI: Top 3 (May 18th & 19th) (merged with the poll)

[Cyn]

Haley, Lauren, and Scotty.

Let the :drama: :argue: :yikes: :sekret: :bloc: begin!!

I am not bothering to watch seeing as how I broke up with American Idol last week after a turbulent and contemptuous 9 year relationship :scream:, but if someone could please post Haley's numbers it would be greatly appreciated.

[PrincessLeppard]

You have GOT to see what Lauren is wearing. Total trainwreck. :yikes:

Oh, and Scotty's gonna sing us a country song. You probably didn't see that coming. :watch:

[Jenna]

Scotty's up first after the break.

[my little pony]

gosh beyonce is marble mouthed

[shan]

Will do ((Cyn)). Sorry for the breakup!

[Jenna]

1. Scotty McCreery - "Amazed" by Lone Star.

[PrincessLeppard]

Beyonce says Scotty goes into his upper range "effortlessly." I didn't get that.

[kylet3]

First thought after ending my Boycott since Pia got kicked off... Scotty looks like an elf

[Allen]

I'm watching the first hour until time for Ameica's Next Top Model.

I didn't get Beyonce's comment about Scotty going into the high range effortlessly either. Especially since she said she wondered if he needed to go into the upper range.

[kylet3]

He's incredibly flat and pitchy and ahead of the backup singers, Lonestar should come out with their guns pointed at him... because that was a disaster. Yuck

[Jenna]

Scotty: I thought he did a nice job. I liked that he explored his range. Better than the past few weeks for me.

[Cyn]

Oh, and Scotty's gonna sing us a country song. You probably didn't see that coming. :watch:

:eek: :eek: :eek: But it can't be!! :drama: Surely you jest!

Beyonce's there? In what capacity?

If she's on as a mentor or guest judge, I feel hella better about not watching. That witch worked my last nerve long before Dreamgirls came out :blah: .

[nerdycool]

A little pitchy, and a little off with his backup singers, but not bad overall.

[my little pony]

for me, scotty is ordinary. he gets by w/o the criticism the others sometimes get because of the "well, country music isn't my thing but i guess this was ok" phenomenon.

[PrincessLeppard]

He doesn't go higher on the live performance.

I thought it was kind of flat. Not his singing, just the whole performance. Here comes the tongue bath....