American Idol - Top 13 (March 9th and 10th)

[LuckyCharm]

Really? He said in an interview that the one thing he wouldn't change during the makeover was his tail.

I guess the pod people got him, because it's gone.


Jacob with some really awkward transitions in that performance. I really like him, but that was flawed.

[Jenna]

I liked Jacob a lot too. He is SO soulful and powerful and passionate.

[LuckyCharm]

Thia. I love this girl so much that it doesn't even annoy me that she's never heard of Charlie Chaplin.

[topaz]

I didn't like the 2nd arrangement but Thia and Jacob are my favorites. If they do Jazz that heffa is going to bury the competition.

[shan]

I hate the song I Believe I Can Fly, so Jacob didn't stand a chance with me. I liked the beginning of Thia's performance. I can't believe I'm agreeing with Randy. :eek:

[Cyn]

I missed seeing Haley singing and all but the tail end of Jacob's performance (which, wtf? :yikes: ).

So far, Pia and James are the two I've enjoyed the most. Thia was great in the first part of "Smile," but damn, did she ever have a case of the dead eyes as soon as Randy's review was glowing.

[rfisher]

I've been bored. 18 minutes of singing out of 2 hours is boring and I lost interest some time ago.

[LuckyCharm]

I hate the song I Believe I Can Fly, so Jacob didn't stand a chance with me. I liked the beginning of Thia's performance. I can't believe I'm agreeing with Randy. :eek:

I Believe I Can Fly never was my fave either. He should have done Feelin On Yo Booty.

[kylet3]

I hope they give Thia another shot she deserves it, even if it wasn't her best she's got HUGE potential

[LuckyCharm]

I hope they give Thia another shot she deserves it, even if it wasn't her best she's got HUGE potential

ITA.

Not liking Stefano's Lately so far...

ETA: The finish is stronger than the start at least.

[rfisher]

Singers can get away with pitchy problems with upbeat songs. They at least get the audience moving. Slow ballads have to be amazing or they're sleep inducing.

I don't like Stefano. :yawn:

[kylet3]

Techno version of lately? hell no! this makes no sense, pitchy and sharp notes all over the place, I'm confused... one of my candidates to leave tomorrow night

[phoenixflamezzz]

i didn't like that arrangement. and his lower register is shaky.

[kylet3]

Karen has a lovely voice but this performance is truly yawn worthy and she really needs to stop with the Jennifer Lopez ass kissing...

[LuckyCharm]

Is there an award for most boring performance of the night. I know it's not over, but I'm pretty confident that Karen is winning!