PDA

View Full Version : Japanese qualification rules for worlds



Pages : [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7

Jeschke
12-12-2010, 11:01 PM
hi people,

i wondered, if somebody knows the exact qualification rules of the japanese figure skating federation for the world championships and the four continents?

last year, if i remember correctly, the lady at the grand prix final who ist best placed and on the podium gets a bye to the olympics. in that case this was miki ando, so her 4th place finish at nationals doesnīt hurt her.

so now, murakamis the best with a medal.
that would be interresting, if the federation now hast to chose between ando, asada and suzuki?
if so, i bet, suzuki will stay at home.

but does anybody know something?

MR-FAN
12-12-2010, 11:51 PM
Highest placement at the GPF does not automatically qualify a japanese lady to worlds this season, so Murakami might still not make it to Tokyo. I think top 3 at nationals will go to worlds, but the Japanese fed. can pick any of the ladies really.

Jeschke
12-13-2010, 12:06 AM
Highest placement at the GPF does not automatically qualify a japanese lady to worlds this season, so Murakami might still not make it to Tokyo. I think top 3 at nationals will go to worlds, but the Japanese fed. can pick any of the ladies really.

thatīs nice to hear, so still 3 places open for ando. i can not imagine worlds in tokyo without asada or ando. i think both of them are on the track to worlds, if they deliver solid performances at nationals. i think itīs between suzuki and murakami for the third place, suguri and imai are out of any chances.

Tak
12-13-2010, 12:08 AM
Highest placement at the GPF does not automatically qualify a japanese lady to worlds this season, so Murakami might still not make it to Tokyo. I think top 3 at nationals will go to worlds, but the Japanese fed. can pick any of the ladies really.

Are you sure? Tak told me the opposite - that the highest medalist from GPF would get sent to Worlds - which means Oda and Murakami are on the team. [Although he told me before the final results, so ....... ]

letsskate
12-13-2010, 12:23 AM
I'm not sure about the qualification rules. But based on the season so far, Murakami, Suzuki and Ando deserve to go, regardless of the Japanese Nationals results IMO, but I think the japanese fed will send the top 3 finishers at Nationals, and Mao's score will be bumped up.

Oh the other hand, it'd be also stupid of the japanese fed to not send Murakami, she's their future star, and should get her worlds experience.

Jeschke
12-13-2010, 12:34 AM
I'm not sure about the qualification rules. But based on the season so far, Murakami, Suzuki and Ando deserve to go, regardless of the Japanese Nationals results IMO, but I think the japanese fed will send the top 3 finishers at Nationals, and Mao's score will be bumped up.

Oh the other hand, it'd be also stupid of the japanese fed to not send Murakami, she's their future star, and should get her worlds experience.

i agree, i would pick those three, too.
but letīs wait for maos performance at nationals, but i expect the same: exploded component scores, not downgraded triple axels although obviously downgraded...letīs wait.

murakami could be dangereous. the japanese have to ensure their three starting places at worlds, murakami and suzuki may bomb.

Yukari Lepisto
12-13-2010, 12:47 AM
i agree, i would pick those three, too.
but letīs wait for maos performance at nationals, but i expect the same: exploded component scores, not downgraded triple axels although obviously downgraded...letīs wait.

murakami could be dangereous. the japanese have to ensure their three starting places at worlds, murakami and suzuki may bomb.

You're right about waiting to see Mao's performance at Japanese Nationals.. but I also think that it should be the other three going to worlds, regardless of the nationals result.. and I don't think murakami will bomb, she's known for being very consistent, she didn't do well in the LP of NHK, but that's her first senior competition ever.. and after that, it's been very good.

bek
12-13-2010, 12:48 AM
murakami could be dangereous. the japanese have to ensure their three starting places at worlds, murakami and suzuki may bomb.

At this point I'd be trusting Murakami and Suzuki over Mao. Both have been fairly consistent this season. Please don't get me wrong if Asada skates well at Nationals, or is skating well by Four Continents I would want to send her. But clearly there are issues going on with Asada, and who knows if last years Mao will even be back.

I don't see why the Japanese federation has in that sense any real reason to hold up Asada. IF Mao places fourth at Japanese Nationals, I'd say that if Asada skates really well at Four Continents then I'd send her on account that she's reigning World Champ. But otherwise, NO.

Angelskates
12-13-2010, 12:57 AM
I think top 3 at nationals will go to worlds, but the Japanese fed. can pick any of the ladies really.

This is correct, and it is why an announcement on rules is not being made.

Marroncream
12-13-2010, 01:00 AM
This is the Japanese figure skating federation's criteria for the selection of the skaters for the Worlds.
http://www.skatingjapan.or.jp/image_data/fck/file/2010_Figure/2010-11%20selection%20procedure.pdf

They will examine the following criteria comprehensively and select the skaters.
1. The best 3 skaters of GPS, including GPF in the ranking
2. The top 3 skaters at the National Championships.
3. The best 3 skaters in World Standings as of the end of the nationals.

For the criteria #1, Kanako, Akiko and Miki are applied, and for #3 Akiko, Miki and Mao fit in among the ladies.

Sooo, I guess it depends on the nationals... and it's going to be nail biting...

luCN
12-13-2010, 01:40 AM
after watch COC and GPF,I hope suzuki and murakami can make the team with Mao.

Miki seemed had some problems,and....to say the truth,her programs for this seanson are really awful.....

suzuki and murakami are very lyrical and have the energy and speed at the same time.beside these ,their EX numbers are gorgeous and made all the audience crazy!

Marco
12-13-2010, 04:05 AM
Between how close the free skate scores are for 2nd to 5th place, how close the bronze medal fight is between the 3 Japanese ladies, and Murakami's generous PCS here against Suzuki being robbed blind again, it would be too hasty to name anyone onto the team just yet. I am very confused as to Suzuki's flutz call in the sp and lip call in the lp.

Ando continues to have problems with the flip but also continues to have strong free skates. So does Suzuki but it does not appear like the judges appreciate her all that much, especially compared to how they score Murakami.

I am pleasantly surprised for Murakami. I do hope her quick success so far this season does not hinder her motivation for improvements. She still has a long way to go.

If Mao delivers at Nationals, I think it can be a difficult decision as to who between these ladies to leave home for Worlds. I think leaving Ando home is even harder than leaving Mao home. The international judges are already loving Murakami more than Suzuki. If they decide to send Mao, I think Suzuki probably needs to outskate everyone else quite convincingly to be secure of the world team spot as they are likely to hold down her PCS or give her some <s.

miki88
12-13-2010, 04:30 AM
There's some inflation at Japanese Nationals, but Mao's Nat scores were never ridiculously inflated. Last year, she was basically marked the same way as she was later at worlds in terms of downgrades. She has gotten good scores at Nats because she usually delivers at this competition.

burntBREAD
12-13-2010, 04:46 AM
Between how close the free skate scores are for 2nd to 5th place, how close the bronze medal fight is between the 3 Japanese ladies, and Murakami's generous PCS here against Suzuki being robbed blind again, it would be too hasty to name anyone onto the team just yet. I am very confused as to Suzuki's flutz call in the sp and lip call in the lp.

Ando continues to have problems with the flip but also continues to have strong free skates. So does Suzuki but it does not appear like the judges appreciate her all that much, especially compared to how they score Murakami.

I am pleasantly surprised for Murakami. I do hope her quick success so far this season does not hinder her motivation for improvements. She still has a long way to go.

If Mao delivers at Nationals, I think it can be a difficult decision as to who between these ladies to leave home for Worlds. I think leaving Ando home is even harder than leaving Mao home. The international judges are already loving Murakami more than Suzuki. If they decide to send Mao, I think Suzuki probably needs to outskate everyone else quite convincingly to be secure of the world team spot as they are likely to hold down her PCS or give her some <s.

Suzuki is perpetually the underdog. I have no idea why, her jumps are pretty big, her spins are at least decent (she can get the levels pretty consistently unlike Miki), footwork great, skates fast, performs well, one of the few ladies who actually listen to the music...when will judges ever pay attention to her? :mad:

Tak
12-13-2010, 06:43 AM
Suzuki is perpetually the underdog.

Taking the place of Yukari Nakano, who I always thought was better than the marks she got - and who I still believe should have been sent to Torino Olympics instead of Miki.