PDA

View Full Version : Ladies Medalists at Canadian Nationals



Pages : [1] 2

haribobo
12-06-2010, 03:12 AM
Who will medal? Multiple choice allowed.

geoskate
12-06-2010, 05:20 AM
This one is a lot easier than the men's poll, IMO.

haribobo
12-06-2010, 05:25 AM
Yea, I'm realizing its not that interesting. Maybe a poll for 4-6 places would be better...

judgejudy27
12-06-2010, 06:01 AM
Phaneuf, Samson, and Lacoste. In any order. Would like to see Samson win but somehow I am doubting it. LOL at the Jessica Dube votes. I doubt she will even be top 10.

museksk8r
12-06-2010, 04:36 PM
Not one of these ladies has a clear path to the Nationals gold based on skating this season. Phaneuf had momentum coming in from her Worlds 5th place, but her results have not been better than Lacoste on the Grand Prix. Amelie, a 3rd and a 5th, has actually bettered Cynthia, with two 4th places, due to her bronze from Skate Canada, the only senior international medal from a Canadian lady so far this season.

Seerek
12-06-2010, 06:25 PM
Will there be skate-off for the Worlds spots at 4CC if Myriam Samson finishes top 2 at Nationals? Here scores from the GP are actually not too far behind Lacoste or Phaneuf even though she had a 7th and 8th place finish.

Skate Talker
12-06-2010, 07:17 PM
Usually Skate Canada will let it be known prior to Canadians if they will base selection solely on those results or if they will keep their options open until after 4CC.

haribobo
12-06-2010, 07:24 PM
Will there be skate-off for the Worlds spots at 4CC if Myriam Samson finishes top 2 at Nationals?

Not that I would put it past them, but really what would be the point of a skateoff? Top 2 at Nats should go, end of story. It's not as if Cynthia or Amelie has been so dominant as to warrant some kind of extra treatment (although Myriane has had some pretty disappointing results over the years) SC hasn't used 4CC as a skateoff for several years now, right? I think Myriane will need to skate close to a blinder to make top 2 anyway, I'd imagine she isn't exactly favored at this point, but could slip in if Cynthia or Amelie blow up.

pinky166
12-06-2010, 10:18 PM
I think Lacoste has a good shot at winning the event depending on which Cynthia shows up. Amelie has been pretty consistent with her jumps so far this season, so if Cynthia has problems with her FS, and Amelie doesn't, I could see Amelie edging her out for the gold. Anyone else agree?

museksk8r
12-07-2010, 12:16 AM
It's really a toss-up. Both Cynthia and Amelie often struggle on the 3Lutz. Both of them have great 3loops though. Neither one needs to do a long program where they repeat the 3Lutz. Phaneuf's jump layout from TEB is a much better strategy for her and more resembles her Worlds LP layout from last season that she had more success with. Both of them have to fully rotate their jumps and avoid popping. I think Cynthia has better spins, but I prefer Amelie's footwork.

pinky166
12-07-2010, 01:11 AM
It's really a toss-up. Both Cynthia and Amelie often struggle on the 3Lutz. Both of them have great 3loops though. Neither one needs to do a long program where they repeat the 3Lutz. Phaneuf's jump layout from TEB is a much better strategy for her and more resembles her Worlds LP layout from last season that she had more success with. Both of them have to fully rotate their jumps and avoid popping. I think Cynthia has better spins, but I prefer Amelie's footwork.

Judging from last year's scores though, if Cynthia skates well her PCS will be HUGE (remember, she scored 66+ for her SP last season with no 3-3 and a 3t out of steps), whereas I'm not sure Amelie's will, her PCS last year weren't so good, but maybe that's because she didn't skate very well. Amelie does seem to have improved her 2nd mark this season though, and even at SC Cynthia wasn't held up when she faltered in the FS.

judgejudy27
12-07-2010, 07:32 AM
A clean Samson cant even beat a clean Mira Leung. She certainly isnt going to beat even Lacoste, let alone Phaneuf, without major help.

pinky166
12-07-2010, 03:57 PM
A clean Samson cant even beat a clean Mira Leung. She certainly isnt going to beat even Lacoste, let alone Phaneuf, without major help.

I was talking about Lacoste, not Samson :)

judgejudy27
12-08-2010, 05:29 AM
I wasnt referring to your post specifically, just the general points of this thread.

essence_of_soy
12-08-2010, 12:02 PM
Gawd, if Lesley Hawker were still competing, she could probably beat all of them.