PDA

View Full Version : Rank the Mens Olympic medal winning long programs from 1992 to 2010



Pages : [1] 2 3 4

judgejudy27
07-07-2010, 11:42 PM
How would you rank the mens Olympic medal winning LPs from 1992 to 2010. Here would be mine:

1. Alexei Yagudin 2002 gold - do I really need to say anything.

2. Evgeny Plushenko 2006 gold- technical merit would be too strong for the others, whether you like the overall package much or not.

3. Ilia Kulik 1998 gold- beautiful amazing jumps and great style. Spins were the only iffy area, a few too many posing sections, and guys would later be doing multiple quads. Still an amazing skater, great to see him finally put it together.

4. Evgeny Plushenko 2002 gold- very strong performance inspite of a few small mistakes. Again technically nearly unmatchable outside a few noteables.

5. Tim Goebel- just because of the 3 quads, which is an amazing athletic feat.

6. Stephane Lambiel- I probably overrank him but I loved his skating. Anyway he skated far worse in 2010 and nearly medaled and was only 5 points from winning the LP against a field now lacking anything close to a prime Plushenko.

7-9. Takahashi-Plushenko-Lysacek 2010 podium- since I dont feel like arguing this again. Only will say if Takahashi didnt fall on the quad he was planets above the other 2 this year whether the judges would have recognized it or not.

10. Jeff Buttle 2006 bronze- I know he beat Lambiel in the LP phase in 2006 but he shouldnt have.

11. Alexei Urmanov 1994 gold- I actually agreed with his victory this year. Beautiful and effortless jumps and very strong presentation. Spins and footwork make him inferior to the 2006 and 2010 podium.

12. Elvis Stojko 1994 silver- a much debated runner up to Urmanov in 94. Personally I think the overall level of the two were quite close this year.

13. Elvis Stojko 1998 silver- a very gutsy performance and very strong technically inspite of the his handicapt.

14. Victor Petrenko 1992 gold- not great but was the rightful winner that night.

15. Philipe Candelero 1994 bronze- if he hadnt botched that 2nd triple axel planned near the end he might have won that night. Wonderfully inventive program but his skating is full of technique and stylistic flaws all the same.

16. Paul Wylie 1992 silver- great artistry but technically he isnt that strong for a top level skater even on a decent day.

17. Philipe Candelero 1998 bronze- lucky medal really.

18. Petr Barna 1992 bronze- bad program for him well below his artistic potential, and a bad performance to it that night.

parasolka
07-07-2010, 11:52 PM
According to this above Plushy is two times Oly champ. Not too bad to start with.

museksk8r
07-08-2010, 02:13 AM
1. Alexei Yagudin 2002 gold

2. Stephane Lambiel 2006 silver

3. Daisuke Takahashi 2010 bronze

4. Alexei Urmanov 1994 gold

5. Ilia Kulik 1998 gold

6. Jeff Buttle 2006 bronze

7. Paul Wylie 1992 silver

8. Evgeny Plushenko 2002 silver

9. Tim Goebel 2002 bronze

10. Evgeny Plushenko 2006 gold

11. Philipe Candelero 1994 bronze

12. Elvis Stojko 1994 silver

13. Evan Lysacek 2010 gold

14. Philipe Candelero 1998 bronze

15. Evgeny Plushenko 2010 silver

16. Elvis Stojko 1998 silver

17. Victor Petrenko 1992 gold

18. Petr Barna 1992 bronze

Squibble
07-08-2010, 06:17 AM
8. Evgeny Plushenko 2002 silver

...

10. Evgeny Plushenko 2006 gold

...

15. Evgeny Plushenko 2010 silver

:EVILLE:

:respec:

:rofl:

:watch:

IneZR
07-08-2010, 08:53 AM
1. Alexei Yagudin 2002 gold

2. Ilia Kulik 1998 gold

3. Evgeni Plushenko 2006 gold

4. Stephane Lambiel 2006 silver

5. Alexei Urmanov 1994 gold

6. Victor Petrenko 1992 gold

7. Evgeni Plushenko 2002 silver

8. Paul Wylie 1992 silver

9. Evan Lysacek 2010 gold

10. Evgeni Plushenko 2010 silver

11. Jeff Buttle 2006 bronze

12. Daisuke Takahashi 2010 bronze

13. Philippe Candeloro 1998 bronze

14. Timothy Goebel 2002 bronze

15. Elvis Stojko 1994 silver

16. Petr Barna 1992 bronze

17. Elvis Stojko 1998 silver

18. Philippe Candeloro 1994 bronze

Jaana
07-08-2010, 08:59 AM
I rate only the gold medal performers and they are in the order of how much I appreciated the lp programme, interpretation and the skaterīs skating style and person on the ice:

1. Evan Lysacek
2. Ilia Kulik
3. Alexei Urmanov
4. Alexei Yagudin
5. Evgeni Plushenko
6. Viktor Petrenko

Jaana
07-08-2010, 09:09 AM
7-9. Takahashi-Plushenko-Lysacek 2010 podium- since I dont feel like arguing this again. Only will say if Takahashi didnt fall on the quad he was planets above the other 2 this year whether the judges would have recognized it or not.

But Takahasi did fall on the quad. One can naturally have futile opinions about ifīs such as if pigs had wings, they would fly....

I rate only the gold medal performers and they are in the order of how much I appreciated the programme, interpretation and the skaterīs skating style and person on the ice:

1. Evan Lysacek
2. Ilia Kulik
3. Alexei Urmanov
4. Alexei Yagudin
5. Evgeni Plushenko
6. Viktor Petrenko

DickButtonFan
07-08-2010, 09:18 AM
1. Alexei Yagudin 2002 gold (what a gorgeous man, no one has since come close to his skating, athletic huge jumps with artistry that combines masculinity with beautiful heart and soul, saw him live he's just amazing)

2. Ilia Kulik 1998 gold (lol at the shirt but as he said the shirt won, he was flawless)

3. Evgeny Plushenko 2006 gold (jumps were on like a robot and he had his usual passion)

4. Evgeny Plushenko 2002 silver

5. Evan Lysacek 2010 gold (flawless except the few tech probs, great footwork)

6. Evgeny Plushenko 2010 silver (amazing for his age and to comeback after being heavier the year or so before, he should write a weight loss book)

7. Philipe Candelero 1998 bronze (will never forget that footwork and that performance)

8. Elvis Stojko 1994 silver

9. Elvis Stojko 1998 silver

10. Tim Goebel 2002 bronze (amazing jumper and loved his innocence in his skating, that suit and his style reminded me a lot of the skaters in the early 1990s and my fav Dick Button)

11. Victor Petrenko 1992 gold (high jumper, good program even though it was used over and over)

12. Alexei Urmanov 1994 gold (didn't like his spins but good jumper)

13. Daisuke Takahashi 2010 bronze (he's not my fav, don't really get the hype over him but he's ok, program was just kind of boring to me but he landed most of the jumps nicely)

14. Stephane Lambiel 2006 silver (the zebra costume was really funny, amazing spins)

15. Paul Wylie 1992 silver (great jumps)

16. Philipe Candelero 1994 bronze

17. Jeff Buttle 2006 bronze

18. Petr Barna 1992 bronze

judgejudy27
07-08-2010, 10:32 AM
1. Evan Lysacek
2. Ilia Kulik
3. Alexei Urmanov
4. Alexei Yagudin
5. Evgeni Plushenko
6. Viktor Petrenko

:lol:

orientalplane
07-08-2010, 11:51 AM
:lol:

I don't agree with Jaana's opinion on Lysacek, but there's no point in you posting a thread like this and then laughing at people who express a view.

Zokko!
07-08-2010, 12:29 PM
My personal ranking:

1. Alexei Yagudin - Gold 2002 :encore:
2. Ilia Kulik - Gold 1998
3. Phillipe Candeloro - Bronze 1998
4. Daisuke Takahashi - Bronze 2010
5. Viktor Petrenko - Gold 1992
6. Alexei Urmanov - Gold 1994
7. Evgeni Plushenko - Silver 2002
8. Evgeni Plushenko - Gold 2006

Guys without getting a medal:
- Kurt Browning - 1994
- Johnny Weir - 2010 :swoon:

briancoogaert
07-08-2010, 01:06 PM
1-Alexei Yagudin 2002
2-Ilia Kulik 1998
3-Evan Lysacek 2010
4-Evgeny Plushenko 2006
5-Evgeny Plushenko 2002
6-Tim Goebel 2002
7-Stephane Lambiel 2006
8-Daisuke Takahashi 2010
9-Philippe Candeloro 1998
10-Evgeny Plushenko 2010
11-Alexei Urmanov 1994
12-Jeffrey Buttle 2006
13-Elvis Stojko 1994
14-Paul Wylie 1992
15-Petr Barna 1992
16-Elvis Stojko 1998 (I haven't watched it for a long time)
17-Philippe Candeloro 1994
18-Viktor Petrenko 1992 (sorry, but it didn't deserve the Gold, IMO)

Special mention : Kurt Browning 1994 !!! One of the best ever. So touching.

Beefcake
07-08-2010, 08:54 PM
1. Alexei Yagudin 2002 gold

2. Ilia Kulik 1998 gold
.
.
.

... the field. But, in all seriousness, huge congrats to all of them! All well-deserved.

Looking at these Oly medal winners huddled together, it's stark realization that Olympics really have been rough on the boys' free performances. The strain of the moment mitigating itself via performance sapping nerves/tightness. (Exceptions, of course, including Wyle, Candeloro (twice), and Goebel, who each had career days.) Thinking that a much more bountiful crop of "all-time" medal winning FS performances can be found in the Worlds category.

dots
07-09-2010, 03:10 AM
Here are mine:

1. Evan Lysacek 2010 Gold
2. Ilia Kulik 1998 Gold
3. Alexie Yagudin 2002 Gold
4. Daisuke Takahashi Bronze 2010
5. Alexei Urmanov Gold 1994
6. Yevgeny Plushenko Silver 2002
7. Elvis Stojko Silver 1994
8. Tim Goebel Bronze 2002
9. Paul Wylie Silver 1992
10. Viktor Patrenko 1992

Spinner
07-09-2010, 04:52 AM
I don't agree with Jaana's opinion on Lysacek, but there's no point in you posting a thread like this and then laughing at people who express a view.

I wish I could give rep.