PDA

View Full Version : Rank womens Olympic medal winning LPs since 1992



Pages : 1 2 3 4 [5] 6 7 8 9 10

leafygreens
07-11-2010, 02:46 AM
Right after Oksana's FS, Scott Hamilton remarked that "she did five triples, all different" like it was an amazing feat - does anyone agree? At the time, was it considered amazing?

judgejudy27
07-11-2010, 04:15 AM
Right after Oksana's FS, Scott Hamilton remarked that "she did five triples, all different" like it was an amazing feat - does anyone agree? At the time, was it considered amazing?

Meh not really. If doing all 5 triples constitutes merely standing them up then Chen did all 5 different types of triples, but 7 triples overall, including 2 triple lutzes and 2 triple salchows. Chen's triple flip attempt was about as close to clean as Oksana's, and she didnt two foot a simple triple toe, and she had a couple decent combinations other than a weak double axel-double toe try that caused her to end past her music.

Marina Kiellmann at the majorly watered down post Olympic Worlds landed all 5 different triples (other than the triple axel too) which included 6 triples, a triple-triple combination, and a not totally clean triple flip like Baiul, and she didnt even medal. Was anyone there to jump to her defense and say what she achieved was amazing. :shuffle:

Hamilton was just desperate to build up anything he could find about Baiul.

alchemy void
07-11-2010, 04:40 AM
Marina Kiellmann at the majorly watered down post Olympic Worlds landed all 5 different triples (other than the triple axel too) which included 6 triples, a triple-triple combination, and a not totally clean triple flip like Baiul, and she didnt even medal. Was anyone there to jump to her defense and say what she achieved was amazing. :shuffle:

Hamilton was just desperate to build up anything he could find about Baiul.

You did not just compare Baiul to Marina freaking Kiellmann. :rofl:

Baiul >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Marina (as much as I adore her 1994 bleach blonde saved by the bell voids)

judgejudy27
07-11-2010, 05:10 AM
Of course Baiul is a better skater than Kiellmann. That is completely aside the point. The point was there is nothing remarkable about standing up (not cleanly executing) 5 different types of triples at that point. Even Kiellmann and Karen Preston could do it and have done it landing more total triples (both clean and otherwise).

neptune
07-11-2010, 05:52 AM
Chen Lu did 7 triples in the LP at Lillehammer? Didn't she put her hand down on one or something?

judgejudy27
07-11-2010, 06:28 AM
Chen Lu did 7 triples in the LP at Lillehammer? Didn't she put her hand down on one or something?

She put her hand down on the triple flip about 25 seconds from the end of her program, the same jump Baiul landed on two foot. Baiul put all of her tougher triples in the first 90 seconds of her program, combining a multiple of botched triple toe tries, double axel tries, and a nice triple salchow and nice camel-catchfoot spin as her only high points in the final 2 and a half minutes (all interspersed with an ugly ass death drop, a supposed spiral sequence with barely a recognizable spiral, some mugging on her toe picks, some unimpressive stroking, and some arm pumping and waving).

neptune
07-11-2010, 09:47 AM
She put her hand down on the triple flip about 25 seconds from the end of her program, the same jump Baiul landed on two foot.

Thanks. If she landed 6 triples, including two lutzes, then I could easily see her beating Nancy in the LP, perhaps by 2 places if you stick Yuka in the middle. ;)

judgejudy27
07-11-2010, 11:36 AM
Thanks. If she landed 6 triples, including two lutzes, then I could easily see her beating Nancy in the LP, perhaps by 2 places if you stick Yuka in the middle. ;)

Yeah I would be fine with that, and bump Baiul to 3rd behind Bonaly in the SP (which should have also happened) and you have an ideal podium:

Gold- Chen
Silver- Kerrigan
Bronze- Sato

All I know is Baiul deserved no higher than 3rd in the SP and no higher than 4th in the LP. I believe her victory will go down as the worst decision in Olympic skating history for many years to come.

leafygreens
07-11-2010, 02:14 PM
Of course Baiul is a better skater than Kiellmann. That is completely aside the point. The point was there is nothing remarkable about standing up (not cleanly executing) 5 different types of triples at that point. Even Kiellmann and Karen Preston could do it and have done it landing more total triples (both clean and otherwise).

I agree - I think Scott was just grasping at straws to explain her placement. I think Oksana's cuteness, backstory, and fanny wiggling are what won her the gold.

olympic
07-11-2010, 02:43 PM
^ Actually, Lu only attempted 6 triples and completed 5 triples in Lillehamer (3z [wild landing] - only 2t seq., 3s, 3l, 2x, 3z, split leap - 3t, 3f [hand down/step-out that broke rhythm], 2x). I think though that if she had more control on her first 3z, she would've attempted a 3t seq. (that was inferred in the broadcast) and a clean 3f at the end, that would equal 7 triples.

As I stated an earlier post, Nancy was ranked ahead of Lu by all 9 judges @ Lillehamer which I never realized before and find interesting (Wasn't there a Chinese judge on the panel?) It may have to do with the fact that both did 5 clean triples and although Lu's triples were nice and had decent height, NK did 3 triples in combination and was superior on non-jump elements like spins and spiral, posture. Some of Lu's MITF looked 'thrown-away' especially at the beginning of the program. I dunno. Just trying to see it thru the eyes of the judges...

museksk8r
07-11-2010, 02:59 PM
As I stated an earlier post, Nancy was ranked ahead of Lu by all 9 judges @ Lillehamer which I never realized before and find interesting (Wasn't there a Chinese judge on the panel?) It may have to do with the fact that both did 5 clean triples and although Lu's triples were nice and had decent height, NK did 3 triples in combination and was superior on non-jump elements like spins and spiral, posture. Some of Lu's MITF looked 'thrown-away' especially at the beginning of the program. I dunno. Just trying to see it thru the eyes of the judges...

Skating a clean SP goes a long way with the judges. Kerrigan did that on multiple occasions . . . the short was her forte. Remember Chen ran into the camera attempting to complete the 2toe portion of her 3Lutz combination in the SP at the '94 Olympics. Again, that horrid 3Lutz technique of her's. :wall: Going into the Games, Kerrigan already had the better resume/reputation ('92 Olympic bronze, '91 World bronze, '92 World silver, regardless if all her LPs in said competitions left a lot to be desired) of the 2 and going clean in the SP only served Nancy better in comparison to Lulu and the scores reflected that.

For years, the judges had been accustomed to seeing Nancy completely tank in the LP and maybe had predetermined scores in their minds when she would do so, but when she FINALLY delivered, they didn't know what had hit them and didn't quite know what to do with her scores in the '94 LP. Going into the Games, her image in their minds was the lady who could hit in the SP and yet be the same erratic, consistently-known-to-bomb-the-LP Nancy. I actually think that's what worked against Kerrigan in the LP in comparison to Baiul.

olympic
07-11-2010, 03:06 PM
Skating a clean SP goes a long way with the judges. Kerrigan did that on multiple occasions . . . the short was her forte. Remember Chen ran into the camera attempting to complete the 2toe portion of her 3Lutz combination in the SP at the '94 Olympics. Again, that horrid 3Lutz technique of her's. :wall: Going into the Games, Kerrigan already had the better resume/reputation ('92 Olympic bronze, '91 World bronze, '92 World silver, regardless if all her LPs in said competitions left a lot to be desired) of the 2 and going clean in the SP only served Nancy better in comparison to Lulu and the scores reflected that.

I think you have a very good point. But I still would've given the LP to NK based on what happened on the ice that night [although I can accept the arguments for Chen]

smarts1
07-12-2010, 12:10 AM
Skating a clean SP goes a long way with the judges. Kerrigan did that on multiple occasions . . . the short was her forte. Remember Chen ran into the camera attempting to complete the 2toe portion of her 3Lutz combination in the SP at the '94 Olympics. Again, that horrid 3Lutz technique of her's. :wall: Going into the Games, Kerrigan already had the better resume/reputation ('92 Olympic bronze, '91 World bronze, '92 World silver, regardless if all her LPs in said competitions left a lot to be desired) of the 2 and going clean in the SP only served Nancy better in comparison to Lulu and the scores reflected that.

For years, the judges had been accustomed to seeing Nancy completely tank in the LP and maybe had predetermined scores in their minds when she would do so, but when she FINALLY delivered, they didn't know what had hit them and didn't quite know what to do with her scores in the '94 LP. Going into the Games, her image in their minds was the lady who could hit in the SP and yet be the same erratic, consistently-known-to-bomb-the-LP Nancy. I actually think that's what worked against Kerrigan in the LP in comparison to Baiul.

But the thing is, Nancy had a pretty good season in '94 once she started to do her run-throughs in practice. Plus she had the whack story to help her out.

I think another thing that help Oksana was that she loved two-footing jumps. That along with underrotated is simply the hardest thing to look for in skating, and without slo-mo (since slo-mo wasn't instituted into judging until 2002), it was hard to find these things. Of course, the triple flip Oksana did was the worst two-footing anyone ever saw, but the second toe was very hard to catch to anyone.

As for Lulu, she simply was never a favorite of the judges. Never ever. I sometimes think it was lucky of her to have won the Worlds in '95 because simply put, politically, China did not care much for her (and hence no politiking). Lulu was still artistically maturing in '94(although I think that if she had thrown away that Winds of Narcissism LP program, she would have reached great artistic depth), and she didn't have the technically packed programs of a Surya Bonaly.

One thing that also hurt Lulu was that she skated extremely early in her group, and the marks she got for her LP were excellent for someone who had skated that early, receiving 5.8s and many 5.7s for technical merit and for artistic impression. Thus, Nancy really beat her on the second mark. But another big shock was that one judge put Lu Chen in 2 after her LP, and there was no way anyone else before her skated better than that.

But then again, what do I know? Yuka Sato had been loved by the judges since forever even without a triple lutz and flip in her jump elements until '94. She received even higher marks for her SP in Lillehammer with a popped lutz over many others.

falling_dance
07-12-2010, 12:18 AM
although I think that if she had thrown away that Winds of Narcissism LP program, she would have reached great artistic depth.

I can think of a few programs that deserve to be so damningly retitled, but I don't think that Chen's Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind LP is one of them. :shuffle: ;)

judgejudy27
07-12-2010, 01:05 AM
Sato actually skated a great LP at the Olympics. Not quite as strong as her Worlds LP but still excellent. Had she been in the final flight she would have been a real threat.