PDA

View Full Version : Who medals in 2000 womens Olympic AA if everyone hits



judgejudy27
05-09-2010, 04:30 PM
Who do you believe medals in the 2000 Olympic AA with everyone hitting. This one is even more interesting to speculate as with the whole vault height controversy, some mild controversy about the floor mat which possibly led to some of the problems there, and the horrible DQ of Raducan we never really saw it play out. I am going to assume the top 4 Russians are all healthy and able to compete even though we know that wasnt the case. I dont want to leave Produnova off the poll though. Pick 3 gymnasts.

Braulio
05-11-2010, 08:24 PM
Poll???

gk_891
05-14-2010, 04:14 PM
Hmm, that's a tough one. Here are my scores if everyone hits.

Khorkina
V - 9.750 UB - 9.850 BB - 9.750 FX - 9.750 Total - 39.100

Karpenko
V - 9.650 UB - 9.800 BB - 9.750 FX - 9.800 Total - 39.000

Lobazniouk
V - 9.700 UB - 9.700 BB - 9.800 FX - 9.850 Total - 39.050

Zamolodchikova
V - 9.750 UB - 9.650 BB - 9.650 FX - 9.800 Total - 38.850

Raducan
V - 9.700 UB - 9.500 BB - 9.800 FX - 9.800 Total - 38.800

Yang
V - 9.675 UB - 9.800 BB - 9.800 FX - 9.700 Total - 38.975

Dong
V - 9.600 UB - 9.650 BB - 9.875 FX - 9.775 Total - 38.900

Liu
V - 9.475 UB - 9.725 BB - 9.825 FX - 9.650 Total - 38.675

Amanar (if she goes for her 2.5 Yurchenko)
V - 9.800 UB - 9.300 BB - 9.700 FX - 9.800 Total - 38.600

Olaru
V - 9.650 UB - 9.400 BB - 9.725 FX - 9.750 Total - 38.525

Ray
V - 9.600 UB - 9.800 BB - 9.725 FX - 9.675 Total - 38.800

My vault scores are probably off because I tend to judge more generously than on that event than the judges ever did. I'm a little surprised I didn't have Karpenko higher because I always preferred both her and Lobazniouk to Khorkina.

ETA - Oops, didn't notice the other thread. I guess I'll cut and paste my answer here to there.