PDA

View Full Version : Is this really living?



Pages : 1 [2] 3

Hannahclear
04-30-2010, 11:19 PM
Well, people can adjust to most anything, but I wouldn't say it means one isn't living. I'd say it means that there's a real estate bubble.

Angelskates
05-01-2010, 12:49 AM
cruisin - the article says there are public bathrooms outside. These rooms will be used for sleeping, and to get a little privacy/quiet time. Privacy and quiet time is all relative too - this is still much more quiet and private than out on the street!

If you ever come to Beijing and notice all the people standing/squatting and sitting around on little stools on the side of the road chatting or playing cards - this is why. Homes are not often private havens in Beijing - at least not for the lower class, they're shelter to sleep. In summer you'll see people sleeping on benches or random stretches of grass (I use the term loosely!) because the commute home is long so they nap in the middle of the day. I'm constantly amazing the places and positions I have seen the Chinese sleep.

essence_of_soy
05-01-2010, 02:26 AM
I'm dreading to think what the blue bucket in those photos is for.

cruisin
05-01-2010, 03:16 AM
cruisin - the article says there are public bathrooms outside. These rooms will be used for sleeping, and to get a little privacy/quiet time. Privacy and quiet time is all relative too - this is still much more quiet and private than out on the street!

If you ever come to Beijing and notice all the people standing/squatting and sitting around on little stools on the side of the road chatting or playing cards - this is why. Homes are not often private havens in Beijing - at least not for the lower class, they're shelter to sleep. In summer you'll see people sleeping on benches or random stretches of grass (I use the term loosely!) because the commute home is long so they nap in the middle of the day. I'm constantly amazing the places and positions I have seen the Chinese sleep.

I've actually been to Beijing twice. No offense, but I did not like it there. I am somewhat germ phobic, it was nightmarish for me.

Angelskates
05-01-2010, 05:11 AM
Why would that offend me? I do wonder what you, as a germphobe, were expecting though? Especially to come twice (was that a choice?) Most people who come to China realise before coming that the hygene standards and realities are lower than the developed world. China is a developing country.

Beijing is actually incredibly beautiful once you get beyond the pollution and hygene - which not that many Westerners do. :( Or those that do live in the expat areas (where the lack of hygene is better hidden and they can be in denial). Today is May Day long weekend and it's sunny and people are dancing in the parks and going to temple fairs. If you came before 2008 A LOT has changed because if the Olympics. It's hard to change habits, especially since the Chinese consider that their standards have been working for decades, why change? And then came SARS...

I think China celebrates spring more than most because it means less being in their cramped homes and more being outside. Four of my friends have said they'd live in the capsule if it was available in their areas.

Dr.Siouxs
05-01-2010, 06:32 AM
I'm dreading to think what the blue bucket in those photos is for.

it probably serves the dual purpose of holding both drinking water and urine. :D

Japanfan
05-01-2010, 09:39 AM
it probably serves the dual purpose of holding both drinking water and urine. :D

You just had to say that, didn't you. I thought that it was probably just for drinking/cleaning water. They do have bathrooms.

I would find it extremely claustrophobic to live in such a small room.

However, what we are accustomed to in the west is very different from what people are accustomed to ane expect in the developing world.

Many poorer people in developing countries live in dormitories where they have even less space than a cubicle in a room spared by many. And are happy to do so as it is preferable to living on the street or in a slum shanty.

When I was in the Philippines more than one Filipino who lived in a dormitory told me that he/she would feel very lonely to sleep alone in a room.

Different places and cultures have different orientations to space. The downside of our orientation to space is that it separates us. You have people living alone in big houses who are unbelievably lonely and people don't even know their neighbours. This is not a plight suffered by most Chinese, Japanese and Filipinos - and others who are collectivist in orientation.

You'd make friends very quickly in the Beijing cubicle. And surely have no problem should you have need to borrow one or two more blue pails.:)

cruisin
05-01-2010, 01:43 PM
Why would that offend me? I do wonder what you, as a germphobe, were expecting though? Especially to come twice (was that a choice?) Most people who come to China realise before coming that the hygene standards and realities are lower than the developed world. China is a developing country.

I wasn't expecting clean, but I wasn't expecting it to be as bad as it was. I was aware and prepared for the pollution, but hadn't really thought about the physical filth, even in some of the nicer places. It was before 2008. I did not want to go the second time, but sometimes we have to do things we don't like ;). At least the second time I knew to bring some hand wipes, Lysol, and peanut butter :lol:.

However, I feel fortunate that I met some very interesting people, walked on the Great Wall, saw The Forbidden City, Summer Palace, & Tiananman Square. It was just very difficult for me to be there.

orbitz
05-01-2010, 01:55 PM
You'd make friends very quickly in the Beijing cubicle. And surely have no problem should you have need to borrow one or two more blue pails.:)

My major concern is fire safety. There's only one door out of each cubicle. This is a disaster waiting to happen.

Angelskates
05-01-2010, 02:29 PM
At least the second time I knew to bring some hand wipes, Lysol, and peanut butter :lol:.

All of this is available at both foreign and local supermarkets. Peanut butter and hand wipes since at least 2000, and Lysol since around 2004 I think. Chinese peanut butter is much tastier than American (Australian is too :P), less salt (actually it may be salt free).

orbitz, my concern is also fire safety. The Chinese government takes fire safety seriously about once every two years, usually after there's a disaster publicised in the press, and sporadically in between and a quick money maker. :( :mad:

PrincessLeppard
05-01-2010, 03:54 PM
I figured many Westerners would be all :yikes: at this, as many can't believe I live in "only" 750 square feet.

For me personally, if it came down to a dorm vs. a cube, I'd take the cube every time.

numbers123
05-01-2010, 04:25 PM
As an American who is accustomed to a large living space, including a huge lawn, it seems a horrible situation.But I think it is all relative.

How much individual space does a crew member on a cruise ship have, how much room does a worker for traveling carnival - which on one of our walks, DH and I saw the trailers provided and they did not appear to be more than a sleeping compartment, etc. And are those individual spaces?

I am sure that there are other examples. Would I want to live in that type of space? Fortunately, I don't have to so I can't tell you how I would feel. I think that I am of the same opinion as PL.

Anita18
05-01-2010, 08:42 PM
As an American who is accustomed to a large living space, including a huge lawn, it seems a horrible situation.But I think it is all relative.

How much individual space does a crew member on a cruise ship have, how much room does a worker for traveling carnival - which on one of our walks, DH and I saw the trailers provided and they did not appear to be more than a sleeping compartment, etc. And are those individual spaces?

I am sure that there are other examples. Would I want to live in that type of space? Fortunately, I don't have to so I can't tell you how I would feel. I think that I am of the same opinion as PL.
I have no trouble in small spaces (in college I'd manage to sleep on half of a twin bed, because the other half would be full of textbooks and papers :lol: ), but I'd feel claustrophobic on a submarine. Mostly because I'd know that I'm stuck in a metal tube deep in the middle of the ocean...:scream:

I had friends who went to UCLA, and there, every piece of furniture touched another piece of furniture, with just enough space between the beds for people to walk through. It wasn't the fact that it was small - it was the fact you had to share such a tiny space with two other people! Lack of privacy would do me in. I'm an introvert and need the alone time.

Actually, recently I've been drooling over Tumbleweed Tiny Houses (http://www.tumbleweedhouses.com/). I don't like having such a large space to be in, it feels like a waste for me. I definitely prefer to be efficient. But yeah, a capsule is definitely too small, but then again I'm an introvert and I wouldn't be outside for the other 18 hours of the day. :lol:

GarrAarghHrumph
05-01-2010, 10:48 PM
As an American who is accustomed to a large living space, including a huge lawn, it seems a horrible situation.But I think it is all relative.

How much individual space does a crew member on a cruise ship have, how much room does a worker for traveling carnival - which on one of our walks, DH and I saw the trailers provided and they did not appear to be more than a sleeping compartment, etc. And are those individual spaces?

I am sure that there are other examples. Would I want to live in that type of space? Fortunately, I don't have to so I can't tell you how I would feel. I think that I am of the same opinion as PL.

My dad served on a submarine in the US Navy. They slept stacked - the butt of the man above you was inches from you - and in shifts.

My friends across the street from me are not from the US. Our houses are comparable in size. In mine, I have 3 people. In theirs, they have approx. 8 (it varies). Same number of bedrooms, but in their opinion, their house is so large that they've actually chosen to rent out what they consider to be the extra rooms. It's all relative.

Gazpacho
05-02-2010, 12:14 AM
It's kind of surreal in cities like Beijing or Hong Kong where everything else is pretty cheap compared to the US or European countries, but then you look for apartments.... :eek:

I guess that's to be expected when you have so many people in a small area.


Why is the ceiling so unusually high considering the narrow width of the mini-apartment? Perhaps they could drop the ceiling and expand the sides a bit.It's not unusually high, it's the camera angle. The article says the rooms are 2 meters high, about 6'6".



I had friends who went to UCLA, and there, every piece of furniture touched another piece of furniture, with just enough space between the beds for people to walk through. Yeah, that pretty much sums up a lot of college rooms. But even the smallest college dorms I've found to be a larger than the ones here. I mean, at least there was room for furniture.